2 ms·
(C). Human behavior and societies are generally not amenable to rigorous analysis, and therefore aren't the proper subject of academic fields that purport to ge
by rayiner 5y ago
(C). Human behavior and societies are generally not amenable to rigorous analysis, and therefore aren't the proper subject of academic fields that purport to generate truth value and produce expertise worthy of deference.
That is not to say we can't seek to understand these things. To the contrary, humans have myriad ways to understand and respond to these things, including religion, tradition, culture, convention, etc. Academic inquiry that has the veneer of rigor--through credentials, peer review, conferences, etc.--but isn't actually rigorous improperly displaces those other ways of knowing, and cedes social power to a narrow class of elites.
The education and socialization of children, for example, is one of the fundamental pillars of society. People around the world have their own ideas of how best to socialize their kids. Unless you can bring real science to the table--unless you can create reproducible results that speak for themselves--you shouldn't be so arrogant as to act like your work can substitute for those other ways of knowing.