4 ms·
Because of RoHS countless otherwise perfect functioning equipment was turned into e-waste. There's a reason aerospace still uses leaded solder.
by userbinator 5y ago
Because of RoHS countless otherwise perfect functioning equipment was turned into e-waste. There's a reason aerospace still uses leaded solder.
- orangepurple 5y agoIs it because of tin whiskers under vacuum and low temperature? Conditions not present here on Earth?
- nickff 5y agoWhiskers were an early problem, but the biggest issues right now are: - Lead-free solders don't wet/flow as well as leaded, which causes lower manufacturing yields. - Lead-free solders are generally more brittle and subject to earlier fatigue failures than leaded solders, so the lead-free units often fail prematurely (compared to leaded ones).
- InitialLastName 5y agoSolder whiskers are more likely at low pressure and low temp, but they happen with lead-free solder (more slowly and at a lower frequency) under standard conditions as well [1]. Given the number of connections on any given PCB, and that we have no way to prevent or predict whiskers, the failure rate over reasonable time-frames of any ROHS PCBA converges to 100%. [1] https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2005-dadonna-nuclear-reactor-shutdown.pdf https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2005-dad...
- compumike 5y agoTin whiskers also occur on earth at ambient temperature and pressure. I’ve personally experienced tin whiskers growing between adjacent TQFP pins (resulting in product failures). We successfully mitigated this with (1) electronic redesign so the whisker was likely to fuse (self-destruct melting via resistive heating) if it made contact with the adjacent pin in question, and (2) urethane conformal coating. NASA studies such as https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2010-Panashchenko-IPC-Tin-Whisker.pdf https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2010-Pan... show that urethane conformal coating is effective against tin whiskers. But that does add another chemical and processing step and its own hazards.
- bydo 5y agoThey also still use leaded fuel. As an industry they move very, very slowly.
- soco 5y agoI thought that as of today only North Korea and a handful of countries (Yemen, Afghanistan...) still use leaded.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIt took a while yes. The solder ball BGA issues with GPUs were a typical example. But they're pretty much ironed out now. The EU is doing the right thing though. Lead is bad for us and cumulative. And RoHS was about a lot more than just solder.
- nickff 5y ago>"The EU is doing the right thing though. Lead is bad for us and cumulative. And RoHS was about a lot more than just solder." If you're worried about lead used in electronics and electrical systems, the focus should be lead-acid batteries, which use >10x more lead than circuit assemblies ever did. Lead-acid batteries were, however exempted from RoHS, while circuit assemblies were not.
- babypuncher 5y agoNearly all lead acid batteries are properly recycled as required by law. Passing laws like that for electronics using leaded solder would be way more intrusive and annoying than just telling manufacturers to use a safer alternative.
- bbojan 5y agoLead acid batteries have something like 99% recycling rate. Whereas most electronics ends up in the trash.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYes but this lead is in contained units that can be removed and recycled separately. Not spread all over the entire device. Also at the time there was no alternative for these. Now that even UPSes are starting to use lithium, I think these will be banned sooner rather than later too.
- CamperBob2 5y agoThe thing about metallic lead is, it pretty much stays where it is. Don't eat it or spread it around by atomizing it, you'll be fine.