3 ms·
It's somewhat fashionable for well-off people/families to have a vacation home somewhere vacation-y. Before Airbnb, most of those homes just sat vacant for mos
by kelnos 5y ago
It's somewhat fashionable for well-off people/families to have a vacation home somewhere vacation-y. Before Airbnb, most of those homes just sat vacant for most of the year[0]. Clearly, that's not a great use of that land. Often these sorts of properties would be in pretty desirable locations, and doing it this way would deprive most people the use of that space.
Certainly there are still some people who are wealthy enough to keep their vacation homes vacant most of the time (and prefer it that way, since doing short-term rentals tends to involve quite a bit of wear-and-tear on a house and its furnishings). But many list on Airbnb now. I consider this a net positive for society.
Of course, Airbnb isn't all roses. In many places, investors buy up housing stock that would otherwise be used for long-term rentals, and deprive locals of much-needed stable housing. My guess would be that this is even -- unfortunately -- the primary use of Airbnb these days (I doubt they are primarily people renting out a room in their already-occupied house anymore). So this does suck.
On the renter side, I've found a lot of great places to stay through Airbnb over the years, experiences hotels just can't provide, and often prices hotels can't match. Should I just not be allowed to have these sorts of experiences? (It's totally fair if the answer to that is "yes", as much as it'd be disappointing.)
Can we find some sort of balance so that we can curb most of the negatives that come with real-estate investing, but keep most of the positives?
[0] Yes, vacation rental companies existed before Airbnb, but Airbnb completely changed this space.
- wheelerwj 5y ago> Certainly there are still some people who are wealthy enough to keep their vacation homes vacant most of the time (and prefer it that way, since doing short-term rentals tends to involve quite a bit of wear-and-tear on a house and its furnishings). But many list on Airbnb now. I consider this a net positive for society. why? Do you think the average person is renting out vacation homes for extended stays? Yes, having cool places to stay is fun but there are better ways to accomplish that then rich people renting out their 2-nth homes.
- kelnos 5y ago> Do you think the average person is renting out vacation homes for extended stays? Why do the stays have to be extended? I consider simply making more nice real estate in desirable locations accessible to more people a good thing. Doesn't matter if it's for a long weekend or several months. > Yes, having cool places to stay is fun but there are better ways to accomplish that then rich people renting out their 2-nth homes. Such as? Hotels are the primary existing option, and they're fine, but not always what I'm looking for (especially if I want to cook; hotel rooms with full kitchens are rare and expensive). Hostels are meh; I'm not a broke college student anymore. Actual bed and breakfasts are nice, but aren't for everyone. If I want to stay in something that feels like an actual home for a short duration, is there a better way than something like Airbnb? To be clear, I agree with the top-level poster's bit about us not needing people hoarding homes just so they can rent them out as Airbnbs. That's exclusionary, (literally) rent-seeking behavior. But is there no middle ground where people like that don't get to satisfy their greed, but we still get to have nice things?
- whimsicalism 5y ago> Certainly there are still some people who are wealthy enough to keep their vacation homes vacant most of the time (and prefer it that way, since doing short-term rentals tends to involve quite a bit of wear-and-tear on a house and its furnishings). But many list on Airbnb now. I consider this a net positive for society. You are missing a critical issue. Airbnb makes it way more affordable to have this second home, so now many more only-sorta-wealthy people can afford vacation homes while pricing people out of the local housing market.
- kelnos 5y agoI'm not missing it so much as I'm ignoring it, I guess. While this phenomenon is bad for people looking for long-term primary homes, it is nice to be able to afford a vacation home when you couldn't before. Certainly I would prioritize locals over non-locals looking for a second home, but can't we have both? Build more.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI agree, build more - but given that we are not currently doing it, AirBnB is only making this situation worse. The market doesn't care whether someone is buying a vacation home or buying the only home that lets them stay in the region. It is the responsibility of the state to put its thumb on the scale in favor of positive externalities that the market is agnostic between.
- caeril 5y agoLegitimately not trolling here, trying to understand. How is it that the high-IQ HN zeitgeist centers on the contradictory positions of "climate change is an existential threat" and "we must expend more resources and build more housing"? Seems like reducing population in high-carbon-footprint countries is the obvious solution to both problems. What am I missing, here?
- whimsicalism 5y agoIncreasing density reduces climate change impact, urban sprawl increases it.
- eli_gottlieb 5y agoI say we just tax every house you're not living in full-time as if you owned an apartment building or hotel. You wanna run an Airbnb? Sure, go ahead, but pay the same taxes as an actual hotelier.