3 ms·
State taxes make it clear that the state has a fully legal claim on some percentage of anyone's income. If you want to interpret that as slavery, go ahead, but
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
State taxes make it clear that the state has a fully legal claim on some percentage of anyone's income. If you want to interpret that as slavery, go ahead, but that's not very fashionable in legal circles.
- AdrianB1 5y agoThen explain how is that not modern slavery: someone declares rights over you (your income). I don't care what legal circles fashion, the same legal circles in various countries fashioned slavery, genocide, wars etc. without blinking.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoApparently you take an extreme position on this, in which it is not possible for a society to adopt political processes that end up asserting the collective right to some part of the society's economic output and a mechanism for obtaining that based on taxation ... at least, not without that being termed "slavery". I have no doubt that you can find some sort of analogy that explains how slavery and taxation are equivalent. Good work. I'll be moving on.