6 ms·
E Ink (the company) keeps improving their electrophoresis display technology. Unfortunately the technology necessarily has very low refresh rates since it it is
by cubefox 5y ago
E Ink (the company) keeps improving their electrophoresis display technology. Unfortunately the technology necessarily has very low refresh rates since it it is based on moving around solid particles submerged in a liquid.
There were other passive e-paper display technologies like the one by Liquavista (based on moving colored oil droplets) or Mirasol by Qualcomm (mechanical micro-shutters create colored light via interference). These were capable of achieving high refresh rates, but unfortunately they have long been abandoned.
I believe the monochromatic electrophoresis displays by E Ink had higher reflectivity and lower price, which is what mattered for e-readers, so all the others went out of business.
- webmobdev 5y agoI wish Qualcomm's Mirasol display had seen light - you could even watch videos on them comfortably (as per the demo). They were building a huge plant to manufacture those displays commercially and suddenly the whole thing tanked. I think Apple bought parts of it.
- cubefox 5y agoTheir last innovation was called Mirasol SMI, which let them change color within one MEMS block (instead of just switching it between color/black), so that they wouldn't need subpixels to create color. They were way ahead of E Ink in these respects. Unfortunately Qualcomm pulled the plug shortly after the SMI announcement. I'm not sure which part Apple actually bought, whether it was just labs or actual IP as well.
- orril 5y agoapple device with back light toggle would be fantastic. the pulse width modulation used on their current screens makes my vision slightly blurry even after only a few minutes of use. i didn't realize there was a chance they might own some passively lit screen technology already. you've gotten my hopes up.
- thrown12 5y agoIf you don't do a full screen refresh you can get 10Hz refresh rates on newer products. The quality is similar to the newspapers of yesteryear.
- other_herbert 5y agoYeah but newspaper refresh rates are terrible…
- innocenat 5y agoAnd tons of ghosting.
- ricksunny 5y agoIn a notification-heavy, video-ad intensive world, maybe slow refresh will someday turn out to be a feature rather than a bug. Confining one's portable device to applications that preserve mindfulness, focus & attention...
- beowulfey 5y agoThe high refresh is what makes epaper notebooks such a joy to use though
- mackrevinack 5y agoevery now and again i read hackernews and reddit stuff on my boox ereader and having a slow refresh rate is definitely a good "feature" since it makes it a lot more tedious to read things compared to my phone, which helps me spend less time scrolling aimlessly
- cubefox 5y agoThis reminds me of the time when I bought my first smartphone, which was quite late. I delayed it as long as possible, but as soon as I had it, I stopped reading books on the train. The Web is just too addictive. At least with snappy refresh rates.
- mdp2021 5y agoThe user is the one supposed to be disciplined, "not the dumb device".
- giraffe_lady 5y agoYes, definitely, this and all related problems people have with focus and attention on modern devices is just because they aren't virtuous enough. ???
- mdp2021 5y agoTo the original point: "crutches" are not a feature, they are a device. They are not universally useful - the same way that prescription glasses are not. A low refresh display may help some people: it is not helpful in general; some people find featureless text editors less distracting, normalcy greets happily the availability of features and options and hides the GUI with a keyboard shortcut. To your statement: I do not see how «modern devices», on literal terms, can be the issue: they are *organizers* (meant to optimize your time). If people use them differently, that is not a fault in the device. To your statement again: focus and attention are skills that individuals develop. If they are underdeveloped, they should if sough be developed. If your point is elsewhere, please make it explicit. I must presume you do not think that it is the responsibility of your sofa to sculpt your abdominals (nor, for that matter, to make you use your sofa wisely).
- Rygian 5y agoI thought the color in Mirasol displays was achieved by electrically adjusting the distance between a transparent and a reflective plate, creating a controlled iridescence. Were there shutters on top?
- cubefox 5y agoNo you are right, the term "shutter" wasn't appropriate. Not a native speaker...
- grishka 5y agoMight be a dumb question, but I'll ask anyway. In the 00s, there were reflective color LCDs in things like phones and portable game consoles. The kind that isn't black when off. Why is this technology not developed further any more, and all modern color LCDs rely on backlight? If it's a dead end, why?
- nicoburns 5y agoThese still exist. Some smart watches still use them.
- henryackerman 5y agoGarmin uses them extensively in both their smart watches and handheld GPS devices like the GPSmap series. The displays are not very impressive as far as color reproduction or contrast goes, but the readability in bright sunlight is superb - way better than any LCD or OLED screen. Which is far more important for outdoor devices.
- skykooler 5y agoBrightness and contrast in reflective color LCDs are very poor, because the polarizing filter blocks half the light, then the color filter on each subpixel blocks a further two thirds, so a fully "white" image will only return one-sixth of the incoming light. Power efficiency has also improved for backlights, so there's less of a benefit to omitting one than there once was.
- 5y ago
- throw10920 5y ago> Unfortunately the technology necessarily has very low refresh rates since it it is based on moving around solid particles submerged in a liquid. Why is the ReMarkable 2 screen able to follow your pen stroke with such low latency, then?
- adamrmcd 5y agoThere are full updates and partial updates. The former involves refreshing the whole display multiple times to remove ghosting, and a complete redraw. The latter is a targeted change at specific coordinates, which typically involves going from white to black. Very fast, but it's a single point/block at a time.
- abeppu 5y agoI do wish there was a reasonably priced color remarkable equivalent. Very frequently, I start reading a paper on the remarkable and have to bail when a chart distinguishes lines by color.
- rnmp 5y agoRemarkable owner here. RM display doesn't anti-alias actual pen strokes, pretty sure this makes the screen refresh faster. Everything else that is anti-alias tho is a bit slower to refresh.
- h-w 5y agoYou can watch videos on modern eink devices from boox and hisense. Looks like an old TV.