3 ms·
There was a math error at 1TW, 4 billion tons lasting 100,000 years means 100,000 billion tons lasts 100,000 years / 4 * 100,000 = 2.5 billion years. Though I
by Retric 5y ago
There was a math error at 1TW, 4 billion tons lasting 100,000 years means 100,000 billion tons lasts 100,000 years / 4 * 100,000 = 2.5 billion years. Though I wouldn’t be sure of the rest of those calculations.
Of course that’s also ignoring the natural decay rate of uranium, and the fact the global electricity consumption is already close to 3TW and rising rapidly. Or the fact that the chemical replacement rate likely depends on the amount of Uranium left in those rocks etc etc. None of which is important in the short term but it seriously undermines their argument.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- titzer 5y agoThe half life of U-235 is 700 million years.
- Retric 5y agoYes, and obvious if you are predicting out 2.5 million years that’s important. Though U238 is more plentiful and has a half life of 4.468 billion years. So, if the reactor needs a fixed amount of U235 that’s an issue but if you change the designs it’s less of a problem. Really, it’s just more complicated than I wanted to get into.
- titzer 5y ago> if you are predicting out 2.5 million years that’s important I believe the stated claim is that there is enough fuel for 100,000 years, which is about 7000x smaller than the half-life of U-235. Even then, 2.5 million years with a 700 million year half-life is absolutely negligible. It's exponential decay, not linear, so you won't even get a 1% reduction. > U238 is more plentiful It's not radioactive enough; you need to subject it to a neutron flux to get something fissile, e.g. P239 through exposure in a reactor (https://www.britannica.com/technology/uranium-processing/Conversion-to-plutonium https://www.britannica.com/technology/uranium-processing/Con...), which incidentally is what breeder reactors are designed to do. If we're talking breeder reactors, then we have several orders of magnitude more energy available to us than the above calculations.
- Retric 5y ago> million years that was a typo it should have been billion. “It is impossible for humans to extract enough uranium to lower the overall seawater concentrations of uranium over the next billion years, even if nuclear provided 100% of our energy and our species lasted a billion years.” At which point decay rates do matter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zeristor 5y agoThere is the other angle to global warming beyond CO2, that heat engines produce heat itself which directly heats the Earth. I hadn’t thought of that angle until I read Gerald K. O’Neil’s book 2081 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2081:_A_Hopeful_View_of_the_Human_Future https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2081:_A_Hopeful_View_of_the_Hu... The upshot being at a certain point it would be wise move heavy industry into space. Of course rocket fuel production, rocket launches, and material orbital de-acceleration down to Earth would be issues. My point being that Nuclear power will at some point have its own issues. Edit: GOK’s book in question being 2081, not 2086 (confused with Japanese Anime ‘Thunderbirds 2086’ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbirds_2086 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbirds_2086)
- Retric 5y agoSolar power doesn’t need a heat engine and can therefore avoid heating the atmosphere. We would need to be using something like 20,000 times as much energy before moving off the earth becomes useful.
- cookingrobot 5y agoIn general adding heat to the earth doesn’t really matter, because it’s constantly radiating to space. The sun shines adding a ton of heat all the time, and the same amount radiates out. Running some more power plants isn’t going to compete with the amount of energy we’re getting from the sun. The problem comes if you add an insulator (greenhouse gas) that raises the equilibrium temperature.