5 ms·
By act of Congress, not Constitutional amendment. It could be repealed in a matter of weeks if Congress saw fit.
by ceejayoz 5y ago
By act of Congress, not Constitutional amendment.
It could be repealed in a matter of weeks if Congress saw fit.
- ham-sandwich 5y agoI know many people who would oppose removal of water from the region with weaponry. People deeply care about them, more than outsiders know
- pc86 5y agoAnd that's all well and good so long as the law backs you up. When it doesn't, that then falls somewhere on a spectrum from felony to treason.
- bilbo0s 5y agoYeah. I was just thinking that. I mean if the rest of the country decides that georgia and florida need our water, which is one of the more serious current proposals, then that's democracy. I'm from Wisconsin. Born and raised right on the shores of Lake Michigan. But the law is the law. Our best bet is to do our utmost to ensure that the law stays the way it is despite whatever pressures there are from other areas of the country.
- ianai 5y agoIt’s not really worth it nor likely. Plenty of places in the US with excess water closer to the dry regions. Ie desalination in California makes more sense.
- aurizon 5y agoDo they also fight the Atlantic Alliance - a network of global seas whose task is to suck the land dry? In jest. A large part of runoff leads to the Arctic oceans = warm water = melts ice. Southern diversion would help the southwest. Since it is political, it will be delayed ad infinitum until there is only dry dust to pump.
- renewiltord 5y agoWe will desalinate in CA before we’ll come for the Great Lakes but if we came (and the United States must have ended) then that would be a petty resistance. Pipelines can’t be defended but canals are harder to break and then, once the pipeline is over friendly soil, breaking it will still only shed water into the West.
- Aeronwen 5y agoIf you want to build the midwest a new sewer system, go ahead.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoOr sell a poop-derivative from your midwest sewer for $17 a bag. Honestly, it's amazing fertilizer. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milorganite-32-lbs-Slow-Release-Nitrogen-Fertilizer-100539618/308888983 https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milorganite-32-lbs-Slow-Release-...
- mywittyname 5y agoThere's a "I drank your milkshake" situation with this. Find the area with people willing to sell out, and build there.
- bell-cot 5y agoPolitically brighter Congressmen might see such a repeal not as a one-off special event, but instead as a precedent for further "inter-state resource raids". Some of which raids could target their own states. So - support for that repeal might prove scarcer than you'd think, from just looking at a map of drought-plagued areas of the U.S. Also - burning needs for water tend to be sudden & immediate things. Vs. designing, approving, funding, and building the infrastructure to actually move large quantities of water long distances is more of a "decade-plus time scale" thing.
- aurizon 5y agoThe great lakes water is simply channelled to the Atlantic. It would take an engineering project to divert 10-20% to the west. No hard tasks, just the creation of a sloped canal. In desert areas you could cover it with solar cells - also land based ones, to provide the pump energy over hills/mountains etc. Tunnels can be drilled where mounts are high. This water added to the west would revive it from the death spiral it is now in,
- Kon-Peki 5y agoWhen you say "No hard tasks" I assume you mean that the engineering is relatively straightforward. The surface of Lake Michigan is around 650 feet above sea level. Go 50 miles due west and you are at 800-900 feet elevation. The average elevation in Kansas is around 2000 feet above sea level! If you go southwest, it is naturally downhill - the existing rivers prove that - but you run into the problem that the water is heading south more than it is heading west. It's a serious uphill climb to get that water out west. You don't need a sloped canal, you need a sloped tunnel thousands of feet below the surface!
- aurizon 5y agoWe are familiar with pipes, pumps, siphons, canals. etc. It is engineering of a routine, but massive scale to perform a major shift like this. The question is cost? Water can be pumped with solar/wind energy. With major area on their way to become parched deserts - except for water. What is the Value of all California crops every year - that can go to zero every year versus the one time cost of a major water project = a spend once, plus maintain = get a permanent 'annual California crop every year' Water project, by their nature are long lived and low maintenance.
- duped 5y agoMinnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, and New York have 97 votes in the house and 12 votes in the Senate. Good luck passing any legislation that sees major diversion of water out of these states.
- itslennysfault 5y agoIt could certainly be changed, but it's actually an international treaty with Canada so it's a bit more complicated than that.