3 ms·
> I don't think protection against human-factor scams and frauds was ever a goal, you certainly never hear it as an argument. In a sense, it admits that tradit
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
> I don't think protection against human-factor scams and frauds was ever a goal, you certainly never hear it as an argument.
In a sense, it admits that traditional banking has the advantage in that regard because it has things like traceability, reversibility, insurance, accountability, and legal guarantees. These have been put aside on purpose in the crypto market, and while I think I understand the whys and wherefores, I don't see giving up these consumer protections is worth it.
Well, not to me anyway, but I'm not getting rich off of crypto.
- Grustaf 5y agoFor most people it isn't. Maybe at some point it will, if governments let the money printer brr even more, or if we see more of what Canada did. If that is amplified by say 10x, I think a lot of people would start to reconsider.
- pm90 5y agoAt no point will people deliberately give up consumer protections they have today. If an economy is undergoing extreme hyperinflation, the consumer protections would have likely already been gone at that point.
- cmoscoso 5y ago
- Grustaf 5y agoWhat does it matter if people "give up the protections" or if they disappear? The result could still be that they flock to crypto, which is what we're discussing. But it's not a binary question. Some people are already "giving up consumer protections" in some cases. And not just by buying crypto. Ordering stuff from Wish is also a gamble.
- nicbou 5y agoIf the money printer runs for long enough, we might get to see the sort of volatility that's a daily occurence with crypto. ...so therefore crypto is better? And if you're afraid of cancel culture coming to a financial instrument near you, why would you want to put all your financial transactions on a permanent record? Sure, it's pseudonymous, but your entire purchase history is one hell of a fingerprint. Traditional currency has a perfectly anonymous payment method: send cash.
- Grustaf 5y agoYes, cash is great, but it's pretty clear that most first world governments are trying to get rid of cash. And it's pretty inconvenient, especially since you need to trust the recipient. Crypto currencies being volatile is not inherent in the technology. You can easily imagine a crypto currency pegged to something like gold, ideally not run by scammers like in the case of tether. The purchase history is also a non-argument, that's not inherent in the concept of a crypto currency. Also, the problem with inflation is not really volatility as such, it's depreciation. Having a currency that jumps up and down by a factor of 2 like bitcoin in the last year is still better than one that melts away, so if BTC can remain as "stable" as it is now that would be pretty acceptable
- nicbou 5y ago> Crypto currencies being volatile is not inherent in the technology How so? It has no control mechanism to prevent it. I get that the brakes (central banks) don't always work perfectly, but removing them entirely is an odd choice. > Having a currency that jumps up and down by a factor of 2 like bitcoin in the last year is still better than one that melts away To whom? When? > You can easily imagine [...], that's not inherent in the concept of a crypto currency It's easy to win an argument when you compare a real world system to one that doesn't exist.
- Grustaf 5y agoWe're discussing the technology of crypto currencies, not just the currencies that exist now. It wouldn't be hard to make a utility coin that gives you something real, but virtual, like megabytes of data on your phone plan, domain hosting, virtual goods in games to the value of 1 dollar etc. Such a coin would not be as volatile as one that is untethered from anything tangible, like Bitcoin. > To whom? When? To most people. Look at BTC/USD for the last year, and then look at a currency during hyperinflation, that loses 10% a day, every day. Which would you rather hold?