3 ms·
Pulications like NYRB and the New Yorker review books in many genres. Arguably, what defines 'literature' is quality (which I'll leave undefined), regardless of
by wolverine876 5y ago
Pulications like NYRB and the New Yorker review books in many genres. Arguably, what defines 'literature' is quality (which I'll leave undefined), regardless of the genre. From that perspective, saying there is no difference between literature and non-literature is like saying there is no difference between NBA basketball players and those who couldn't make the NBA, or maybe more accurately, that there is no difference between typical developers at Google and those in the IT department of a mid-sized law firm (to pick an organization outside the tech field).
My experience is that there is, generally speaking, a clear qualitative difference between literature and non-literature.
It's an old trope to deny 'fine' arts have merit, but often such denials lack an assertion or evidence - they just deny someone else's. What do you think the state of such things is? All is equal? Everything is subjective? That would be pretty extreme.
- swatcoder 5y agoI wrote more in response to an adjacent reply, but your analogy is missing the point. The work featured in those publications does indeed showcase the best “NBA players” and is better than quite a lot of other work at large. But it simply doesn’t aim to speak at all about the “players” of the NFL, NHL, FIFA, Starcraft, etc. And that’s exactly what the analysis in this article reveals. Writers in the literary genre critique and share literary works in journals for readers who enjoy that style. Meanwhile, other journals do exactly the same thing for their own styles-of-focus, and lots of writers and readers stride across all of them.
- wolverine876 5y ago> your analogy is missing the point It's disagreeing with the point.