4 ms·
I do wonder what the future is for the Arduino with the upcoming launch of the Raspberry Pi[1]. What aspiring hardware hacker would spend $30 on an Atmel develo
by jdietrich 15y ago
I do wonder what the future is for the Arduino with the upcoming launch of the Raspberry Pi[1]. What aspiring hardware hacker would spend $30 on an Atmel development board when there's an ARM-based board available for $25 that'll do so much more?
I think we're in for a fascinating few years, as powerful but dirt-cheap featurephone chipsets start trickling out into the hardware hacking community.
[1] www.raspberrypi.org
- sliverstorm 15y agoMCU's will still win on cost and power. Unfortunately for Atmel, Texas Instrument's MSP430 currently has an aggressive lead on both; if platforms like the Rasberry Pi become common, I forsee the cost of Atmel chips falling and hopefully the prices as well.
- nrp 15y agoThere are already several significantly more powerful ARM Cortex-M3 boards available for around the price of an Arduino[0][1]. The draw of the Arduino is ease of use in interfacing to GPIO/UART/i2c and in the community of accessories, documentation, and code that exists around it. [0] http://shop.ngxtechnologies.com/product_info.php?cPath=21&products_id=65 http://shop.ngxtechnologies.com/product_info.php?cPath=21... [1] http://www.sparkfun.com/products/8559 http://www.sparkfun.com/products/8559
- reemrevnivek 15y agoThis is wrong. Raspberry Pi is a completely different domain than Arduino. There isn't a great price difference between the cheapest (<$1) microcontrollers and powerful SoCs like the Raspberry Pi's Broadcom part, which only cost $20 or so (either when buying in huge quantities or by pulling strings as Broadcom employees). In small quantities, that doesn't leave a lot of room to make a profit. However, the Arduino (and other products based on 8-bit micros) are and will always be lower power, lower cost, and lower complexity than the Raspberry Pi parts. They're lower power because you can only flip so many bits with your battery, and running Linux at 800 MHz instead of an RTOS at 8 MHz is going to drain your little watch battery fast. They're lower cost because each square millimeter of silicon costs money. Economies of scale can only take you so far. They're lower complexity because you can write an assembly program in a few dozen bytes for the Arduino. On the Raspberry Pi, you'll need lots of libraries and there will be layers upon layers upon layers of abstraction. With increased power comes increased complexity. Hacking on a phone has a huge barrier to entry and huge complexity levels. No one at Apple, Nokia, Samsung, or any other phone manufacturer can hold the whole code base in their mind at one time. Most Arduino sketches are two functions with just a couple hundred lines of code leveraging one layer of simple and understandable libraries. Furthermore, if you want to mass-produce your Arduino design, you can do it with home-printed PCBs and a Digikey or Sparkfun order. The chips used in the Raspberry Pi aren't available anywhere at any price in small quantities, and using them requires X-ray inspection equipment and professional 4+ layer boards. Raspberry Pi aims to be the cheapest PC available. Arduino aims to be the easiest hardware platform to start on. Raspberry Pi is not a competitor to Arduino.