4 ms·
> There is no shortage of people wanting to be nurses (in some places it is extremely competitive), and there is a huge demand for nurses based on shortages eve
by johnnyanmac 5y ago
> There is no shortage of people wanting to be nurses (in some places it is extremely competitive), and there is a huge demand for nurses based on shortages everywhere, but somehow we are in a situation where nurses are overworked because they are short staffed.
why is this such a common story across pretty much every single industry? There's more people in the country than 10, 20, 30 years ago. More customers, more money. Why do they think they can handle more work with less workers whose salary is less when adjusting for inflation?
- chiefofgxbxl 5y agoThey don't think they can handle more work with fewer workers. It's just a profit squeeze, and someone else pays the price.
- heavyset_go 5y agoOwners and operators have learned that they can keep the lights on by running their businesses with skeleton crews and, at the same time, reap the rewards of lower costs as profits.
- zamfi 5y ago> reap the rewards of lower costs as profits yeah...or stay in business because their prices aren't 10x their competitors. The anti-capitalism is strong on HN these days...
- rocqua 5y agoI think 'we have to exploit our workers to stay competitive' is a bigger argument against capitalism than 'I choose to exploit my workers because it gives me more profits'.
- rightbyte 5y agoAttrition sucks money. It is just not on the spread sheets for the bean counters.
- kingludite 5y agoI don´t know much about nursing specifically but it is actually interesting to account for how many customers served per employee and how many there are at the bottom of the organization. If you are earning next to nothing and are doing 200 widgets per minute a 10 fold salary increase wouldn't change the cost of the product per customer. If there also is a large profit margin the desire to keep wages down is more of a fetish than the sensible choice it is at the other end of the spectrum. Depending on the type of job you also get a different "product" depending on how much you pay and you might not be able to measure it. Employees cut corners in the least visible way and do not brag about extra effort if they are paid well enough. This[0] was a fun read. >Nursing care services are the most intensely used hospital services by acute hospital inpatients yet are poorly economically measured [...] >Nurses are an anomaly in the current inpatient billing system. Rather than bill for the actual services provided to the patient or the amount of time spent providing nursing care, the cost of nursing is embedded into the line item for room and board, which is the same fixed cost for every patient receiving the same level of care within a particular institution. In other words, all patients cared for on a given unit are billed the same room and board charge regardless of the actual amount of nursing care the patient utilized during that hospitalization. [0] - http://frogfind.com/read.php?a=https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5887158/ http://frogfind.com/read.php?a=https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/...
- everforward 5y ago> If you are earning next to nothing and are doing 200 widgets per minute a 10 fold salary increase wouldn't change the cost of the product per customer. If there also is a large profit margin the desire to keep wages down is more of a fetish than the sensible choice it is at the other end of the spectrum. It depends on what portion of the cost of production is materials vs capital costs vs labor. You're presuming that labor is a small portion of the cost of production, which is probably true if you're selling them for $10. If it's an extremely low cost item, like plastic washers, labor can still be a significant part of the production costs. It also depends on whether you carry that down the supply chain, since part of your material cost is someone else's labor costs. > Nursing care services are the most intensely used hospital services by acute hospital inpatients yet are poorly economically measured This doesn't strike me as utterly insane. Most treatment prices should include the cost to have a nurse deliver it. The tiers of rooms should roughly approximate the amount of nursing care required outside of treatments. It's not perfect, but it might be better on the net than having nurses spend more time on the patient chart to add billing items. I.e. it might be overall better to not have a specific line item for "rolled patient over to prevent sores" that the nurse has to enter in, and then billing has to argue with insurance about whether a roll was needed or not. It might be cheaper for everyone to figure out the average cost of providing nursing per tier, add a profit margin, and charge everyone that. I'm not saying it is better, but it seems at least plausible.
- bitsnbytes 5y agoCovid was also used to exploited the issue further and as an excuse for horrible service and skeleton crews. During covid Business owners saw that the consumer was willing to take it so they will continue to run on skeleton crews as long as the consumer takes it. Sure the consumer will complain but they are still using their money to buy from skeleton run places.Partly because most industries nowadays are Oligarch control and what one does the other does as well and the consumer has lost their control of the marketplace. We are living in a world where the big guys have the majority control of the market place and the market want's skeleton crews. This is seen across the board in all big business run industries. However with nursing, especially in the ER and the ICU that are now running a skeleton crew the consequence is your health and even your life. Until the big healthcare providers,insurance industry, hospitals, doctors , etc start to get sued over low staffing as the cause of death nothing will change and they know how to document to prevent such a case.
- Nasrudith 5y agoBecause they really can in many cases from more automation, better tools, and better processes and understanding. The demand also doesn't neccessarily increase linearly with the population.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoin many cases there is room for automation. I'm not quite confident we are at the level of an Auto-Doc assisting/replacing nurses yet, though. Nurses being thrown into multiple duties for 1.5x standard full time work seems to suggest that one or all of the above factors are not being met. >The demand also doesn't neccessarily increase linearly with the population. for elastic goods, no. But medicine is about as inelastic a product as you can get.
- failuser 5y agoBecause it's more profitable to have a single person that works 80 hours and one desperate for a job than 2 that work 40 hours.