8 ms·
FB is nuts. Bears focused on the slowing growth ,ignoring that Facebook is making $40/billion profit in a year, which is just astounding. That's 3x Walmart. You
by paulpauper 5y ago
FB is nuts. Bears focused on the slowing growth ,ignoring that Facebook is making $40/billion profit in a year, which is just astounding. That's 3x Walmart. You don't need much growth when you have so much profit and market dominance. Buying Facebook stock with a PE ratio of 13 , cheaper than any 'blue chip' company, was a steal. $400-600 soon imho.
- msoad 5y agoPeople don't decide to go another store instead of Walmart in a span of few months. But migrating from Instagram to TikTok can happen very quickly.
- paulpauper 5y agoBut migrating from Instagram to TikTok can happen very quickly. they simply use both. That is what I have observed.
- msoad 5y agoThere is a finite number of hours in a day -- unfortunately
- paulpauper 5y agodoes not take many hours to check a timeline or to upload something
- colinmhayes 5y agoPeople looking at a timeline for a couple minutes a day isn't going to cut it for facebook. They need hours of scrolling every day to hit their engagement numbers.
- andrewinardeer 5y agoSleep is also a competitor to screen usage.
- akreal 5y agoOne could outsource the work to other people.
- munk-a 5y agoWalmart has shifted a decent chunk of their business to the internet and that business does suffer from quite a bit of attrition when competitors manage to undercut their prices - and Walmart established itself by stealing consumers in a short time and forcing local businesses to shutter - then consolidating their locations. It is an extremely impressive business and they've been quite careful managing costs to maintain their position, but they could easily lose their dominant position quite quickly. Customer loyalty to Walmart is entirely objective - they offer the best deals. As a company their image is pretty terrible and very few people would weep if they were overtaken. Compare that to services that FB runs that have years of your personal history carefully cataloged in it - that data can be exported, but there aren't many services where it can be richly imported. Both companies may seem to be are in fragile positions because of their size and public opinion but I wouldn't bet either of them will shutter their doors anytime soon.
- political12345 5y ago2022.04.27 i'm saving the url of your comment and i will add a reminder in 3 months to comment on this article. i fear you will lose your money and the stock will not be at that level but lets wait and see.
- x3sphere 5y agoI agree it is a cheap price for FB but the macro environment matters too… if we are entering a recession tech stocks will see more downside still.
- mrtksn 5y agoIsn't it that FB type of businesses are a bit like pro-athlete like, in terms of viable career lifetime? I remember digg, friendster, myspace, tumblr, bebo, msn messenger, Foursquare etc... Some gone, some still alive but all of them had what's FB's primary moat: network effect. It's a strong moat but once things start to move to the wrong direction things can move fast... unlike with Walmart.
- ethbr0 5y agoThey can, but I'd argue that none of those had the pervasiveness of Facebook. Moreso due to timing & mobile adoption, than any actual failing. Facebook's moat is that it's the Yellow Pages of social. It took the web to kill Yellow Pages, not a better phone book. Which is probably why you see FB investing in acquiring social-but-different competitors and researching paradigm shifts.
- pkdpic 5y agoI like that analogy but I'm realizing I have no real understanding of if people saw the yellow pages as a problematic monopoly in any way. I'm sure no where near where facebook is with negative perception but it seems like small businesses at least could have viewed the yellow pages as problematic.
- gnatman 5y agoThey saw it as problematic enough that AT&T was broken up in the 80s.
- jdrc 5y agoyellow pages did not have network effect.
- paulpauper 5y agobut that was a long time ago, before any social network had the opportunity to establish the sort of dominance Facebook + Instagram + WhatsApp have
- Evan_Hellmuth 5y agoI agree with your assessment, and I’m a long term holder. I’d love to hear your rebuttal to the following bear case: - $10 billion to Reality Labs R&D in 2021 expected to increase annually will eat into earnings - Last year saw first ever decline in US Facebook user base, expected to continue shrinking (albeit slowly) - Apple’s 2021 opt-in privacy change makes FB/Insta/Messenger/WhatsApp ads less effective permanently for the highest margin demographic (iPhone users) - Hugely negative public sentiment* hurts adoption and makes continued litigation headwinds likely * to be clear, I think the negative sentiment is unfair towards Meta. You use their service and in exchange they show you ads based on your behavior. They’ve always been transparent about that, there’s nothing particularly secretive or nefarious going on. Ads power most of the free internet stuff we enjoy. YouTube, Snap, Google search, Tiktok, they all do the same thing! But people for whatever reason really seethe when it comes to Mark Zuckerberg and FB. In fact, it’s pretty insane that TikTok isn’t under more scrutiny in the US from a national security perspective. At least the other ad-powered entertainment apps aren’t controlled by a foreign adversary!
- redeux 5y ago> there’s nothing particularly secretive or nefarious going on. Other than selling data and ads to foreign groups that use it for electioneering / sowing domestic discord. Minor detail though, I’m sure.
- Evan_Hellmuth 5y agoThey don’t sell data, they let anyone who buys ads choose who the ads go to based on anonymized data. They also made it way harder to run political ads after public sentiment changed in 2016. You can go buy an ad from them right now. So can “foreign groups.” Neither of you will get access to anyone’s data. Same goes for YouTube, Twitter, Snap, etc. If you’re worried about “foreign groups” there’s this Chinese app called TikTok that knows everything about every American under 30 that no one seems to be concerned about.
- redeux 5y ago
- rubiquity 5y agoI was following along until your call for $400-$600 share price. The problem with FB is that growth is slowing and will eventually decline, and it's a growth stock. Unless the Metaverse pans out it is going to be a while before the stock is anywhere near its previous valuations, and that's putting aside the current macro environment.
- RivieraKid 5y ago> and it's a growth stock How do you define a growth stock?
- rubiquity 5y agoStocks bought largely on expectations of future growth in share price because the underlying business is promising. In contrast to well run businesses that pay consistent dividends to shareholders. Right now FB is neither a growth stock nor a value stock, and that's bad because as revenue declines so will share buybacks.
- paulpauper 5y agoit can get to $400 just with PE multiple expansion back to 26 or so , which is not overvalued.
- sjg007 5y agoLikely not going to happen in the next 2 years unless we see general economic growth/rebound. After 2 years if FB has a new offering then maybe.
- topper-123 5y ago> $400-600 soon imho. Revenue growth is stopping, no way they’re going to that level anytime soon. Also, if a recession is coming, as some say with interest rates rising, ad expenditure will fall, affecting Meta greatly. OTOH, it has a moat from its network effect and its earnings are insane in absolute terms, so could also pivot to become a nice cash cow instead of a growth stock in the coming years.
- lvl102 5y agoCompared to something like GOOGL? I rather own GOOGL and diversified business lines. What FB needs to do is create 3-4 additional businesses preferably with its cloud/infrastructure.
- marticode 5y agoA business is valued as roughly profits times growth. The issue here is Meta used to have both growth and profit and now it mostly has profits. It doesn't mean the business is doomed obviously, but it means it should trade at a much lower valuation. A correction in PE means a huge drop in stock price despite profits still being there. Google is growing its top line over 20% YoY and has a PE of 20. What PE would you give another business that sell ads but has a stagnating top line? Probably much less than 20.
- akhosravian 5y agoSomething to consider is google has not built an original product that matters since gmail —- Android and YouTube we’re acquisitions. I would argue they are structurally incapable of building some significant new business internally. Zuck seems pretty all in on VR, and if they actually get it somewhere good the financial reward is insane. I have no way to gauge how long his interest will last. I also have my doubts it is even possible to get it somewhere good with our current level of technology —- in short I think we need some kind of low latency neural link that doesn’t require brain surgery. Anything controller or machine vision based will never be good enough for mass market (i.e. smartphone level) appeal.
- marticode 5y agoI would argue that Google Photos, Google Apps, Google Cloud, Google TV, Google Pay, Google Chrome, ChromeOS, Maps, Chromecast, Drive, Keep, etc. are all original products that matter and often dominate their field. Android is an acquisition but Google made it the success that it is today. Conversely how many original Meta products are successes? Messenger is the only one that I can think of.
- sjg007 5y agoThese are not original products but rather fast followers after someone else proved the market. Google search itself was a fast follower.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoAnd we have ourselves a bagholder.
- Traster 5y agoI think an important thing to point out in the comparison to Walmart is that Facebook have actively said to the market "We don't think this revenue stream is going to last, and we're going to plough billions into a completely new area". We all know fundamentally what Walmart does as a business is going to be here 50 years from now. That's why the P/E is so low - because people are discounting future earnings by a lot because over the next 5 years there are about 3 big threats that are going to eat away at that revenue stream. (1: High value users leaving, 2: Regulatory pressure, 3: Massive spending on a new unproven business)
- blagie 5y agoI'm bearish on Facebook in the long-term: 1) The market seems saturated, and users are starting to slip away. If it ever loses critical mass, it collapses. 2) Facebook can't execute complex technical plans anymore. It's investing billions into a risky new area -- the metaversa -- with nothing to show for it. 3) The internal culture focuses on politics and pet projects. It's not a bad backstabbing politics -- it's a great place to work -- but it's just not aligned to business success. Most Metamates want to do fun, interesting things, with little connection to business success. 4) Costs are out-of-control, and decoupled from revenue. Revenue is high, so it's not a pain point right now, but that decoupling will lead to massive pain once things go south. I would short Facebook, but I don't know how long the "long term" is. I don't think it's at a risk of becoming MySpace, but I suspect it will go the way of AOL at some point. I still know older people with @aol.com emails, but it's not worth a lot and no longer relevant. It feels brittle -- once things start to unravel, they'll continue to do so very quickly. It needs a good tipping point, whether that's a scandal, a new regulation, or whatever.
- TenJack 5y agoHave you tried their Oculus 2 VR headset?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoIn March the stock lost 20% of it value because Apple decided to allow iOS users to stop apps from tracking them. The "business" relies on people allowing the company to do stuff that if the people were given a conscious choice, they would generally not allow. This number of people that would not agree to let the company surveil them is not only large but it is increasing.