2 ms·

I think some might read the original question as saying that the books reviewed wouldn't be reviewed unless they were contributors. Zadie Smith's books would ge

I think some might read the original question as saying that the books reviewed wouldn't be reviewed unless they were contributors. Zadie Smith's books would get reviewed whether she'd contributed or not, but she still counts towards the "clubby" total.

starwind 5y ago
Oh OK that makes sense. I thought "part of the club" as in "club of high profile authors"