4 ms·
Everyone's using that word in this thread: research. Watching a bunch of YouTube videos is not research. Browsing medical web sites and choosing "treatments" th
by ryandrake 5y ago
Everyone's using that word in this thread: research. Watching a bunch of YouTube videos is not research. Browsing medical web sites and choosing "treatments" that are cleverly and subtly marketed to you is not research. Matching your symptoms with a TV ad is not research. We saw what two years of "dO yOuR oWn ReSeArCh!" left us with during a deadly pandemic.
We're all dunking on doctors in this thread, but look at it from their perspective: They're probably sick and tired of patients coming in to their office saying "The TV told me: Ask your doctor about Provalanix!" And patients who googled "How to get your doctor to proscribe SSRI medication". And patients who insist they should go with their aunt's Healing Crystal Therapy. And patients who asked HN for medical advice[1] !! If you want to really do research, go get a medical degree and then do actual research in an actual academic institution.
Yes, have a discussion with your doctor. Yes, ask him or her if you have concerns. Maybe even get a second opinion (from another real doctor). But don't think your keyboard is going to bring you to The Truth That Doctors Dont Want You To Know.
1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31098263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31098263
EDIT: Right, the comment is not directed in particular towards its immediate parent, more in general at the entire thread.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vasco 5y agoMaybe you should reply to those comments instead. I mentioned: - reading medical research papers - bringing detailed information about your symptoms - mentioning things you ruled out and things you've tried - having a good understanding of your medical history I didn't mention ads on tv, youtube videos or HN comments. Perhaps you should reserve your outrage for the proper place.
- ipaddr 5y agoThe internet with the latest and most information available to mankind can be ignored? If someone gets information from video format they should be ignored? If someone came in and wanted to have a conversation about a medical product they recently heard about they shouldn't go to their doctor with questions? Sounds like someone is close to retirement or leaving the field with that attitude. Those are all valid concerns the general public may have. That's your job as a gp (to schedule appointments while patients tell you things you suggest your ideas).
- wtetzner 5y agoWho said anything about YouTube or TV ads? PubMed is a great resource. Of course, it takes a lot of effort to really get something useful from those papers, since you need to try to understand the experiment they did, and not just read the conclusion (scientists have biases as well, and will often read what they want into the results). But depending on how bad your condition is, it could absolutely be worth the time. > But don't think your keyboard is going to bring you to The Truth That Doctors Dont Want You To Know. Neither do I. I expect instead it might bring you to The Truth That Doctors Don't Know.