4 ms·
> MHO they should have let the biggest banks crash and relied on the FDIC to protect Joe Schmoe's bank accounts. The problem have never been bank accounts. The
by mschuster91 5y ago
> MHO they should have let the biggest banks crash and relied on the FDIC to protect Joe Schmoe's bank accounts.
The problem have never been bank accounts. The problem have been pension accounts, all the time.
Instead of the old European way of a public, universally funded rolling pension scheme (aka current workers pay for the pensions of the current pensioners in exchange for credits), the US went for almost pure stock and other IOU-based (e.g. bonds) pension funds - a decision that has been biting the US in the butt for the last fifteen years. The FED literally can't do anything that even has the potential of sending the stock market into a major decline because even small corrections wipe out the pension security of the people.
Of course, Big Finance has been exploiting that forced abundance of money ever since. When 35 trillion dollars (!) [1] are available in the market solely due to pension funds, even extremely tiny management fees of a tenth of a percent add to a massive payout for the industry!
The US is in for a really, really wild ride: The pension system obviously needs reform when large amounts of "pensioners" have to work at age 75 and above because their pensions are too low [2], the pension system is unsustainable because it effectively requires endless printing of money and introduces extremely bad side effects (such as enormous amounts of capital being wasted on bullshit in the vain hope it might evolve into a "unicorn"), and at the same time the political deciders can be very well said to be bought off by Big Finance which will do everything it can to avoid being cut off of the money heroin spigot that is pension funds. Not to mention that voters are not going to vote for any politician that the opposition (aka either primary competitors or the actual opposition) can smear as "it will endanger pensions".
The effective way out would be a nationalization of all pension fund assets and a complete turnover of the entire system, but we all know that that is not going to happen.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/421729/pension-funds-assets-usa/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/421729/pension-funds-ass...
[2] https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/dec/13/americans-retire-work-social-security https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/dec/13/americans-reti...
- titzer 5y agoI agree with this too. Savings accounts became a thing of the past 20 years ago or more; the Fed wiped out returns on them with permanently low interest rates. It was deliberate to get that cash into the stock market. The whole shebang was absolutely engineered to make the stock market the center of all fiscal policy, centralizing all risk and driving all decision-making towards keeping that Jenga tower piling up.
- polishdude20 5y agoMakes me think all the articles and advice to invest in index funds were all part of this plan too.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe idea of investing into an index fund is pretty solid in any case. The money from savings accounts ends up on the stock market just the same, only with the bank pocketing the profits between the savings account interest and the rise of the usual indices.
- reducesuffering 5y agoDon't US banks have financial regulations that they can't just take savings deposits and buy stocks? I thought they have narrow leeway with risk and deposits are mostly used for loans.
- polishdude20 5y agoYeah that's true. Although I guess the bank guarantees your savings will still be the same amount if their investments go down?
- Dma54rhs 5y agoBut Europeans park their pensions to markets now as well, the times when new workers paid for old ones are long gone. People don't reproduce enough to keep the system stable.
- titzer 5y agoTBH I don't know if any economic system is stable in the long term. It's something that neither pops out of the mathematics of the universe nor has been selected for and tuned by evolution. We're far, far out on a branch that this planet has likely never seen before. With long life spans and high standard of living, caring for the elderly in societies is a really tough problem. Throughout most of human history, people haven't lived this long, and if they did, they were either of the few tribal elders or taken care of in multi-generation households. The modern individualism and independence assumed today doesn't have a lot of good solutions.
- reducesuffering 5y agoIt's not only that life spans are longer with higher care, it's that society has also hamstrung fertility rates and removed the pyramid-shaped scheme that population levels and society have grown accustomed to supporting for centuries. We're in uncharted territory with an upside-down pyramid. Without immense automation, young labor will be priced very high and deflation will naturally occur without constant inflationary monetary intervention which has other nasty side effects. Imagine society always had 2 young people helping out 1 elderly and just within the last two generations we've flipped to needing 1 young person to help out 2 elderly. That's 4 times the burden.
- mschuster91 5y agoWe could, as a society, also get rid of bullshit jobs and provide better, meaningful education. Not to mention we could also cut down on waste (fast fashion and similar trends). Both of that will be inevitable (either due to capitalist forces aka costs or because of actual natural disasters), the key question is if politicians will act early enough to be able to influence and guide society through the transformation or if it will be a chaotic, the-strongest-survive transformation.
- ac29 5y ago> Instead of the old European way of a public, universally funded rolling pension scheme (aka current workers pay for the pensions of the current pensioners in exchange for credits), the US went for almost pure stock and other IOU-based (e.g. bonds) pension funds What? The US absolutely has a public, universally funded pension plan: Social Security. Its the one of the largest government expenses.