2 ms·
These guys must be making a mint. They caught me on my way out, scheduled a time to come back, then when I cancelled at the last minute, came again. All they go
by netcan 18y ago
These guys must be making a mint. They caught me on my way out, scheduled a time to come back, then when I cancelled at the last minute, came again. All they got where 3 bulbs, but they still seemed pretty pleased. More persistent then door to door mobile phone guys.
I guess this is like a super simple case study in carbon trading, pitfalls & all. How many credits should these guys be getting?
In my case, I probably would have replaced those bulbs anyway. In other cases, the incentive can be weirder. For one thing, There's a double jeopardy going on here. 1. Individual feel-goodness of the guy who traded in his bulbs 2. Individual feel-goodness via the carbon market.
Both are getting credit here. I feel like I'm lowering my emissions. But since those credits have been sold, someone else is emitting them in my place. They do the equivalent of taking my 100W bulb & plugging it into their wall with the fuzzy feeling that even thought they are emitting carbon, it is being offset. We are both claiming credit.
That's before the perverse incentives kick in. Why should I pay $8 X 10 to bulb my house with low watt bulbs when I can pay $0.50 X 10 to do so with cheap bulbs & call in these guys?
- jwilliams 18y agoBut since those credits have been sold, someone else is emitting them in my place. I know what you mean - but they will be paying to emit them, which will set up an economic basis in the long term.
- netcan 18y agoSure, it may eventually. If they need to buy them to do whatever it is they want to do & I sell because I want the money. But at the moment this is just a way of cashing in public sentiment towards climate change: at a bad rate.
- jwilliams 18y agoWhy at a bad rate? Companies are compelled to do this in Australia (amongst others) due to our Kyoto targets, etc.
- netcan 18y agoWhy at a bad rate? I feel like I am saving X watt hours & the purchaser does too. So they (the company) are trading in 2X watt hours "emotional credits" (the utility of this market) for 1x watt hour savings. Of course, that's an exaggeration. I lost my drive & ability to save those emissions by replacing my bulbs, but it's not 100% certain that I would have done so anyway. Companies are compelled to do this in Australia (amongst others) due to our Kyoto targets, etc. Are they? I don't think they are directly. The Government is probably subsidising this & other efforts but there is no compulsion to purchase carbon credits. They Get bought by bus companies, airlines, etc. They are basically also riding on public sentiment.
- Alex3917 18y ago"...the fuzzy feeling that even thought they are emitting carbon, it is being offset." You shouldn't get a warm fuzzy feeling. You're not reducing the total amount of CO2, you're just changing the allocation. However, both parties should feel good about the transaction because each party is economically better off than they were beforehand.
- netcan 18y agoIf we don't get the warm fuzzy feelings, the only one better off is the dealer.