5 ms·
Russia cuts off Poland and Bulgaria from its gas in war escalation
- eimrine 5y agobees against honey
- jleyank 5y agoGee, you’d think the Warsaw Pact countries would have thought twice about relying on Russia for energy…
- necovek 5y agoIf Russia is able to offer a product at the best price after the wider EU public stops caring about Ukraine (which is inevitable), I am sure most countries will simply go back to buying from Russia. Globalisation simply demands for that to happen, as otherwise, gas will go to non-sanctioning countries who'd suddenly be able to produce products cheaper than sanctioning countries. The only question is how long will this take. Ukrainians will need decades, but rest of the World?
- jleyank 5y agoa) Only if what's being offered cannot easily be replaced. b) The Cold War lasted a long time. This was a generational change.
- necovek 5y agoThe Cold War was not a war. Thus "cold". Throughout history, we only had a few very long wars.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The Cold War was not a war. Thus "cold". The Cold War was a war. Thus “war”.
- trasz 5y agoThat's assuming there will be some Russia that can sell it. The future for Russia is to either become a larger North Korea, or splitting up again, like it already happened with USSR twenty years ago. Ukraine, on the other hand, will get an absurd economical boost thanks to money confiscated from Russia. Or Russia might be forced to provide gas for free as reparations. It's pretty much impossible to predict what is going to happen in the following months at this point.
- necovek 5y agoThe most likely outcome is that Putin is out of power in 5-10 years and everything turns to being just what it was prior to this invasion (in terms of working with the Western countries). No money was confiscated from Russia yet (it was only frozen), and it will take long legal battles for that to happen (10+ years). Ukraine will get EU/USA help (it's already getting a ton in weaponry), but nothing can cover for the loss of human life and years lost to emigration and rebuilding.
- trasz 5y agoRussian aggressiveness was only tolerated because of its army. Now we know all this military might was just a bluff. There is no point, from the western point of view, to get back to previous state of affairs - especially so given the only important thing Russia provides, the fossil fuels, is being gradually phased out. Also, it’s highly improbable that Russia, as a state, can survive this defeat.
- necovek 5y agoUhm, what Russian aggressiveness was tolerated? In Ukraine? Even with their fluffs, it is still being tolerated, so I am not sure of your point. The West is reasonably careful to appear as not participating in the conflict, yet it obviously is. I also can't believe that someone would make a claim that "Russia, as a state, can (not) survive this defeat". Like USA cannot survive a defeat in, say... Vietnam? Afghanistan?
- 5y ago
- simonblack 5y agoTANSTAAFL. No cash, no gas. My energy supplier works the same way as the Russians: they do cut off my supply very fast when I don't pay the bill.
- trasz 5y agoExcept that Europe does pay. It’s just that Russia wants them to break the law and pay with fake money instead.
- macilacilove 5y agoEU does pay. But then EU 'freezes' the Euro account that the payment went to, effectively erasing the transaction, right? From the Russian perspective the rouble is much less fake money.
- simonblack 5y ago"Fake money" is money that isn't freely usable as cash. For the Russians, the Euro is fake money because the Europeans won't let the Russians use it. However, there is no impediment to anybody using Rubles, so the Ruble can be considered non-fake money. In the greater scheme of things, if a contract transaction can't be made in one currency, the world requires that we use another. A contract is an exchange of one thing for another. There is no such thing as a legal contract in which one party gains and the other party does not. (Try buying a car from a dealer then not handing over the cash to that dealer. You could say "I've paid you the money, I'm just holding it for you at my bank." See how far you get with buying that car.)
- trasz 5y agoOne can pay with rare Pokémons; it doesn’t make them cash. Rubles aren’t real money, because they’re not exchangeable. Try buying a car from a dealer that insists on paying for it in cocaine.
- simonblack 5y ago
- necovek 5y agoWait, sanctions are a political tool to attempt to make another country do or stop doing something, and this is... blackmail? Aren't both of those "blackmail"? (sanctions are simply a very specific type of blackmail, which is a more general term) I guess they pick their vocabulary from the "Emotional Words" dictionary.
- mirntyfirty 5y agoOne difference is that they have contracts in place that they aren’t honoring. The descriptive verbiage changes when discussing an invading country. Similar actions can be described a number of ways depending upon their context.
- necovek 5y agoI am sure there are plenty of contracts between companies in sanctioning countries and Russian companies or institutions that are not being honoured due to sanctions (pretty confident none of them had the clause "Contract is void if Russia invades Ukraine"). One of the prominent contracts not being followed is all those US banks freezing Russian USD holdings/reserves measuring in hundreds of billions of USD IIRC. So I don't see that difference you are talking about. I mean, that's the purpose of sanctions, to stop doing business with a country (iow, stop honouring existing contracts in addition to not signing new ones) to make them change course. IOW, to blackmail them to change course. It seems like you are disputing that sanctions are a type of blackmail? Perhaps both are better described as "extortion" instead, but "blackmail" applies equally well. Again, this is an attempt to use more emotionally charged language for effectively the same actions. I am not sure why it needs extra explanation though.