4 ms·
The author has confused himself for multiple people; one name appears on the paper which makes frequent references to some "we". Or possibly, it is the royal "w
by kazinator 5y ago
The author has confused himself for multiple people; one name appears on the paper which makes frequent references to some "we". Or possibly, it is the royal "we", as in "we are not amused". He's also confused himself for someone who is fit to give recommendations to Lisp implementors based on studying a thing or two about ancient history of syntax.
> If improper lists and circular lists are rarely used and
can always be simulated in the rare case, it is better to kick them out to favor the common case.
"We" had better get a smidgeon of Lisp development experience, methinks. Plus, taking a look at Lisp from 1960 to 2022 wouldn't hurt, rather than obsessing about what MacCarthy meant when he said this and was he aware of that at that moment in 1959, and how should we do things today as a consequence. Good grief. Let's not have closures, because in 1959, MacCarthy saved and restored globals to simulate locals.
- js8 5y agoI thought it was pretty common to use 1st person plural in academic publications.
- kazinator 5y agoYes, in a way that is inclusive of the reader. E.g "we next examine the implications of theorem 3". This guy uses it in ways that clearly refer only to himself, and not this rhetorical "we".
- owl57 5y agoIs this something like a trailing comma in lists — a quirk to minimize diffs because you don't generally know when you start writing the paper whether you will remain the sole author or co-authors will join the work?