11 ms·
College Was the Biggest Mistake of My Life
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoPeople should treat undergrad more like grad school: don't go if you have to take out loans for most of it. Go and learn as much as you can as soon as you've got the big scholarship or someone (family, employer, etc…) to sponsor you.
- Saint_Genet 5y agoSociety as a whole would probably benefit from more trade schools, even for many jobs that are typically thought of as traditional white collar jobs. Though on the individual level it’d probably limit options and make it harder to switch careers.
- paulpauper 5y agotons of trade schools and trade jobs exist. the problem is the jobs are not that enticing.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoI think part of the problem is the perception that trades don't pay well. Trades median pay (salary.com): * Plumber $59,698 * Carpenter $58,542 * Journeyman Welder $51,413 * Electrician $61,350
- slothtrop 5y agoWell the money can be enticing.. if you manage to get an apprenticeship. Notwithstanding that trades aren't created equal. I initially went to tradeschool, before college. This was a reflection of self-confidence. I hated it. I often didn't have important tools or had them stolen, I didn't connect with anyone, and there was frankly a lot of standing around and waiting for your turn, there was a substantial lack of written reference material if you so happened to miss what a prof says (and their attention was always monopolized by 1-2 guys). I also didn't want to work graveyard shifts and 12 hour days.
- stillbourne 5y agoI'm glad I didn't bother going to college.
- amznbyebyebye 5y agoIt doesn’t have to be. Ideally it should be some time boxed mix of (1) finding yourself (2) once you find yourself specialize in that (3) make friends (4) get some work/research experience Obviously that’s not for everyone. You don’t need to go to college to do any of that either. It’s a signal that you may have learnt something and may have some smarts if you went to a good school. Beyond that if you’re sharp and GSD on the job, that ultimately outweighs everything else. How you get there - doesn’t have to be via college.
- TimPC 5y agoI think the author underestimates how long he's financially hamstrung for. Yes he paid off the debt in a decade which is relatively impressive from a no degree job. But without that debt and with four extra years of work while he was in school when would he have had some sort of housing downpayment? Keeping in mind the insane acceleration of real estate prices in many markets he might find he'll never have a down payment now, but could have had one as early as 2012 if the four years of work done instead of school generated it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RappingBoomer 5y agoif you read around on the internet, in various and sundry forums, there is a rising acknowledgement among people that maybe their friends who accidentally got their girlfriend pregnant in high school and then got married and started working right away were the lucky ones... at the time it seemed as if those friends had messed up royally, but in hindsight, looking back over time and it seems as if the ones who got a girl pregnant in high school, dropped out and started working and got married often had the best outcomes...anecdotal evidence...but there is some logic behind it...
- polishdude20 5y agoTurns out, starting work 4 years earlier in your life helps with compound interest.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoYes, if you're saving. But if you have no degree or work experience and a kid to support, your money isn't staying in your pocket unless your parents are willing to help out.
- anonymoushn 5y agoWe should perhaps compare having a kid to support and having a job to having a kid to support and using loans to go to film school.
- mypalmike 5y agohttps://xkcd.com/947/ https://xkcd.com/947/
- mtVessel 5y agoI think you'd be hard-pressed to find anything more than anecdotal that supports this conclusion.
- snow_mac 5y ago"Best outcomes" by what metric? My dad did that in college and dropped out, joined the military. We were always poor growing up. Every person I know who did not go to college and got someone pregnant is very poor. Trailer park poor. I was trailer park poor growing up... I'm the lucky one. I went to college, graduated at the bottom of my class because I was working 40 hours a week trying to stay afloat. I was the first of my class to get a job, the only one with a job before graduation. After about 2 years, I was making six figures and have for the last 8 years. I'm lucky. Today I'm closing on my second house. The first one I bought 6 years ago with only $9,000 down on a 3% conventional loan has ballooned in value to give us a home 2.5x the space with over $240,000 down. $9000 into $240,000 in 6 years. Magic. I have a wife and a kid. Lucky. Waited until I was 30 to have a kid. He's almost 3 now. The best outcomes? If I had a kid at 18, he'd be 12 and I'd be poor, never had gone to college. I would have either worked a full time job, retail or restaurants only in my small colorado town and never had the opportunity to go to college, to get internships and work part time. After community college, I went to state school and started working 40-50 hours a week. Multiple internships to reduce the debt.
- lbriner 5y agoThis resonates for many disciplines, even in engineering, I found my college course (pre-University in the UK) to be much more useful than most of what I did at University but there is a mixture of universities wanting the income; some companies who insist on degrees at least as a crude measure of ability; peer or family pressure etc. At least when I graduated in 1998, I only had loans of around $8K, since the course back then was free to take, in the US, I can't believe the sums involved but when you see the gravy train and insecurity in some institutions, it is no wonder they rinse their students for as much as possible. I think we are seeing more routes now into work that look more like traineeships especially in comp-sci and other technical roles.
- coldpie 5y agoBiggest mistake of my life, too, but I got off easy. I attended a community college for 2 years, then transferred to a state university, to get a 4-year Computer Science degree in 2011. Complete waste of time and money. I made no friends; I knew more about programming than most of my teachers; and it turns out I hate computer science (enjoy programming, though!). Mercifully, I was already employed in software before my first year, so I made it out without debt, but if I could do my life over again, I wouldn't have wasted that time and money in the first place. When asked, I now tell young people not to waste their time with college. Almost no one I know works in the field which they studied in college, they're just steeped in useless debt. It's a scam.
- ncmncm 5y agoLearn O(f(n)) notation and caches, and you're good to go. Judging by interviews, they don't teach the caches part in CS.
- coldpie 5y agoTurns out DFAs and Turing machines don't have caches. Wow, what incredibly useful models to spend several semesters examining /s
- ncmncm 5y agoComputer Science has "science" right there in the name: it isn't meant to be useful. But caches are DFAs. So, sometimes it is, by accident.
- anonymoushn 5y agoIs that about memoization, software fixed-size caches, physical caches on CPU dies, or caches that you can put in front of HTTP servers?
- ncmncm 5y agoYes. And many others. If you want to do science of computation, halting problem, P?=?NP, lambda calculus, good. Those are legitimate to study, and to write papers about. But studying them does not prepare you to engineer systems.
- beej71 5y agoI went to college in the early 90s when it was 5x cheaper, inflation -adjusted. It was the best decision of my life. No way I'd be where I am without it. But times and technology has changed. The antique system that is education needs to be completely upended. And, in the process, be made affordable again.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago30 states provide some means of a free community college education (eligibility limits in some case, for all in others). Get the other 20 on board, nuke student loan debt, and no longer have the government guarantee future debt for loans (which will drive down college costs). The system will then provide more value at lower cost to system participants (although it will be a painful adjustment process for bloated institutions that have fed off of government loans for decades). https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/08/free-college-is-now-a-reality-in-nearly-30-states.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/08/free-college-is-now-a-realit... https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107044086-1649433548660-MapImage1.png?v=1649433575&ffmt=webp https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107044086-164943354866...
- whywhywhywhy 5y ago> nuke student loan debt Do people who paid theirs off, get their money back?
- coldpie 5y agoSo did I. No, we don't, but it will still benefit you. When your peers are less beholden to their jobs because of their debt shackles, they can ask more of their employers, which will also raise your working conditions. Sometimes life isn't 100% fair, and that sucks and I'm sorry. But looking at it objectively, it's still an improvement for you. (And, "I suffered, so others must suffer, too" isn't a great way to set policy regardless.)
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThank you for being a knowledgeable, decent human participating in a democracy. More of this is needed all around.
- omarhaneef 5y agoOne point of view arguing for a non-stem degree is that it teaches you to read, write and think. And there is some logic to that thought. Even if you spend 4 years just learning about, say, Sociology, you have to read up on a debate, summarize the background, have an opinion, be challenged and so forth. And you are on your way to 10k hours. Now film school might have a component of that, or maybe it is teaching you how to launch projects and bring people together. Or perhaps it is "worthless" as the author claims. I have never been to film school so I cannot guess. However, it seems the author's issue may be a change in curriculum: "A degree in film is absolutely worthless for obtaining work in the film industry. What matters are connections, professional experience, and the ability to raise large sums of money. Those aren’t things film school can teach you." Perhaps the film school should add some courses on networking, fund raising and an internship at film shoots?
- browningstreet 5y ago> "A degree in film is absolutely worthless for obtaining work in the film industry. What matters are connections, professional experience, and the ability to raise large sums of money. Those aren’t things film school can teach you." > Perhaps the film school should add some courses on networking, fund raising and an internship at film shoots? If you go to film school not knowing the quoted hot take above, you've watched or read zero about the industry, history, etc. of film making.
- em-bee 5y agohow much do you expect a high-school student to research if that information is not provided by career counseling? i did a film project in high school, and i am involved in one now. if i were to go to college now i might think, hey this is fun. i would not even consider the idea that film-school would not help me get a job in the film industry. that's totally counter intuitive. the only way to address that is to put picking a career onto the high school curriculum, and make the necessary research a class assignment. and once the students have made some potential choices bring in veterans from those industries to talk to the students about their choices.
- 5y ago
- dr_dshiv 5y agoThis guy could totally make a film about his life someday.
- shortstuffsushi 5y agoI'll offer one anecdote of counter-college hate. I went to a local state school, graduated in three years with winter and summer classes, commuted for the second and third, worked the whole time, and came out with a very small amount of debt (maybe 5-10k, been a while now and I don't remember). I made friends in college, I was able to get into a great job via an internship that I got from the school job fair, and got a great understanding of some of the fundamentals of computer science that I wouldn't have otherwise learned (though my practical learning was really done on the job). I also had a child my first year. I don't regret college, and it was certainly a worthwhile investment for me.
- jrochkind1 5y agoWhat year did you graduate?
- brimble 5y agoI had a similar experience, and this was way into the era of "OMG college is unaffordable". College can still be affordable. The specific college you want, the one that other people have heard of outside an eight-county radius, dorm living the whole time, out-of-state tuition, famous professors, guest lecturers whose names are well-known... well, probably not. Just checked, the one I went to is about $18k/yr now, in-state tuition & fees. That's roughly an inflation-rate increase since when I went. You'll likely have some debt without scholarships or parental help, but a college job can keep that under control. CLEP out of a couple early classes, take advantage of that tuition being flat-rate rather than per-hour(!), and it's very manageable. Start at a community college and transfer, and the numbers look even better.
- the_only_law 5y ago> College can still be affordable. The specific college you want, the one that other people have heard of outside an eight-county radius, dorm living the whole time, out-of-state tuition, famous professors, guest lecturers whose names are well-known... well, probably not. This is purely from a software development context and obviously doesn’t apply outside, but Given that choice is almost just eschew college period. I have not seen good quality programs at a small schools and I imagine you also lose out in quality of employer sourcing, networking etc. The time cost alone would make it seem that it’s better just to break into the field without education. It’s not easy, but it’s not particularly difficult either.
- christophilus 5y agoMy advice: go somewhere cheap, and get a practical degree. I went to CCU for most of my college career (back when it had just become a standalone university). Wasn't (still isn't) prestigious, but with scholarships, was entirely free for me, and it had the added benefit of attracting some decent professors who had retired to the beach and still wanted to teach part time. Today, for in-state tuition, it's around $47K for a 4-year degree. That's about double what it was when I attended, IIRC, which isn't too bad given how long ago that was. Maybe I'm in a bubble, but ~$12K per year seems doable for just about anyone who can manage to work a part time job and / or get scholarships. If you go through their business school, comp-sci program, marine-biology, or other practical degree programs, my guess is you'll probably come out ahead in the end. [0] https://www.coastal.edu/admissionsaid/tuitionfees/ https://www.coastal.edu/admissionsaid/tuitionfees/
- TimPC 5y ago$47K for the degree itself leads to much larger debt if you're in the sizeable contingent of students that also needs to pay for things like a place to live and meals rather than relying on parents. You're paying $12K/year for the degree and likely $18K/year for rent and another $18K or so for other expenses. If you're making $30K/year from a part time job and paying $4K of that to taxes. you end up with a $22K/year shortfall which after interest is likely to be $100K of college debt.
- tomrod 5y agoIs $1,500 /month rent with roommates common? I'd think that can be reduced somewhat, if needed? I'll admit, I don't watch the college town apartment cost trends.
- ac29 5y agoI'd assume $1500/month is to live alone. With a roommate that would imply a $3k/month 2 bedroom apartment, which certainly exist, but only in the most expensive cities.
- sologoub 5y ago
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoThe only problem I see is how in the USA, no one is stopping young adults from taking ruinous loans for worthless degrees. Why do people keep doing this to themselves and why don‘t peers, parents and teachers advise them better. Many of them then start screaming for the government (=tax payers) to bail them out, which is absurd to me.
- gkilmain 5y agoIt doesn't just stop at college tho. After college, you can obtain a ruinous loan for just about anything. At least with a ruinous college loan you should be able to "come out ahead" at some point. Ruinous home loan? Generally leads to foreclosure. Ruinous car loan? Repo man. Payday loan? Good luck!
- paulpauper 5y agoI don't agree with this article but I thought it would be good food for thought The college wage premium is still wider than ever even after accounting for inflation and student loan debt and despite Covid and online learning. Most grads major in 'actionable' subjects, like business or nursing, econ, or STEM subjects, not the humanities or film. It’s worth taking a moment to reflect on the fathomless insanity of expecting teenagers to hatch decade-spanning plans intended to shape the course of their lives, while their brain’s prefrontal cortex, responsible for long-term planning, is seven years away from being fully developed. I don't buy the underdeveloped brain theory either. I don't think it's well understood what it means for a brain to be fully developed, and if so, what age or how this is related to impulse control or decision making. Plenty of older people, such as boomers, go into debt and are bad with money.
- jonahrd 5y agoThere's something extremely depressing about how popular this attitude of "college is a bad ROI, do something else with your time" is. For sure, in the US currently there aren't many alternatives, so this might be practical advice for the current situation. But that isn't how this argument is framed most of the time. Instead, it's often more akin to "poor suckers going to college, haha I beat the system!" as if skipping higher education altogether is something to be proud of. In other countries in the world, university is cheap or free, has flexible time commitments, and isn't necessarily pushed as something you have to do at 18 or you will miss out. But there still IS widespread access to higher education. I just find it depressing that we are turning to the idea of less education, not more, because the system sucks so bad that we can't envision change. (I'm an American who moved to Quebec for college-- where university is $2700/year and there is a growing movement to make it free for all-- and then stayed here)
- ylhert 5y agoI don’t think 4 year college will ever go away, especially for great academic students. That said, the argument is that the cultural pendulum has swung far too much towards pressuring everyone, regardless of their life goals, into attending a 4 year college. There are so many great alternatives, especially if you don’t want to be a doctor/lawyer/ etc. as a society, we should elevate blue collar jobs and career paths, and not elevate the cultural value placed on 4 year degrees (esp from random non prestigious private schools). Most blue collar jobs (plumbers/electricians) are interesting, enjoyable, and fruitful work (150k+), but in the US many people look down on these careers and steer their children away from them.
- adam_arthur 5y agoYou can do an 8 week coding bootcamp and make 6 figures afterwards, or you can spend 100k and 4 years to do the same. Seems obvious to me that the current college system is hugely antiquated and misaligned with student interests. The main thing perpetuating it is cultural attitudes, which does a huge disservice to the youth IMO
- kickout 5y agoIMO, that's why we're seeing these article. Going to college is/was pushed heavily by teachers/society/counselors as _the only_ way to 'make it'. Add that to the fact that college costs in the US have skyrocketed (thanks to bloated admins) on the backs of government backed loans, an economy that never recovered from the GFC, it's a tinder box waiting to explode. You can't promise people a better life--at great cost-- and then not deliver and expect no blowback. I regretted college while I was in college, but I was already on a debt treadmill. I am a vocal anti-college (in the US in its current form) advocate. Start a business instead. Fail. Learn.
- m348e912 5y ago>> The truth is, college isn’t for everyone. It’s a virtual requirement for fields like STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics), medicine, academia, and law. I would say it's true for academia and some other fields that a college degree is required. It has not been true in my experience with technology. Experience and demonstrable skills trump education. Certification also helps. This does vary from company to company, so I am sure there are some people on here that disagree with me based on their own experience.
- bikingbismuth 5y agoI agree with this. I have a trash bachelor’s degree from a for-profit school and it has never been more than a checkbox when applying for jobs. I’ve managed a couple dozen people, and with the exception of the couple of PHDs in that group, I couldn’t tell you if any of them even went to college. With that said, I work in InfoSec (as a dev/manager) so I suspect my experience might not be the typical one.
- fayten 5y agoI know in parts of the US there are community colleges starting to offer Bachelor's Degrees. I wonder how much that will add to the cost of those schools. Hopefully it will lower the barrier of entry for thousands of students. Also I am curious what HN's thoughts are on general education requirements in the US. It was something put in place in the 60's[1] in an attempt to prevent specialization[2] in education. I am wondering if it's time to reduce that requirement and go with more focused degrees similar to the UK. Also Gen Ed courses seem like a real money makers for US Universities since there is not scaled tuition. A human lit class costs the same as a STEM course that could require very expressive lab equipment. I am not trying to down play the importance of human literature in this scenario. It just seems odd that it would cost the same as a organic chemistry class that requires a multi million dollar lab, a wide assortment of chemicals, and a staff equipped to maintain it throughout the day. [1]. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1090127 https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1090127 [2]. https://www.encyclopedia.com/education/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/general-education-higher-education https://www.encyclopedia.com/education/encyclopedias-almanac...
- gilbetron 5y agoCollege is ridiculously expensive because of government backed student loans, and that's a problem needing fixed. However, beyond that, it is the expectations students have (created from a variety of sources) that really are the crux of the problem. The expectation is that if I study X in college I get to do X professionally after that. Which is utterly untrue. It is the fantasy the colleges sell you on, and it is important to help high school students understand this. Go study film in college if you want to know about film. Same with many, many other fields. It will transform your understanding of yourself and the world, and that is amazing. But just don't do it with the belief that you can study some obscure corner of history and then go make a living with that knowledge. If you want to get a job and support your life financially, then go into college with a different mindset. Be mercenary, figure out what you are good at that you can stand doing, and then compare that to the needs in the world, then develop the knowledge and skills in college that help you do that. And don't forget, it might be that college doesn't have what you need! Or only specific colleges. Notice I don't say "follow your passion" - I think that's generally cruddy advice. Most people will be far happier finding what they are good at that society values. Passion for it will come later. Being good at something feels really good, when that something is rewarded by our culture. If you are truly a "follow your passion" kind of person - you'll figure that out, because those kind of people can't not follow their passion. Their passion drives them, but they are exceedingly rare. Don't worry about it if you aren't that kind of person - many that I know that are like that often feel trapped by their passion. Especially if it is a passion that doesn't align with society's values. College is a tool, find out if it is a tool that matches your life, and find that out by talking to people that have been through it, not by consuming media and university propaganda! To be clear: I think going to college is awesome, and if you can afford it, study something you love, but with the understanding that you are doing it to make yourself a better human, not because of a financial benefit. I'd much rather work with someone that went to film school, and then learned coding online and is now a software developer and finds enjoyment in software where possible, and then uses the money to enjoy film in their own personal, idiosyncratic way. Then someone that went to school for CS, but really has no interest in the field, and is just another dull, unhappy drone.
- bluedino 5y ago>> When I was 18, I thought I wanted to be a filmmaker. I developed a passion for it in high school, and went on to study film at university. I stopped right there.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoThe idea that almost any 18-year old can take on large amounts of unsecured debt to go to film school is the problem. Making the debt non-defaultable isn't the solution. It's eliminating the credit.
- bluedino 5y agoPlenty of students still get their parents to co-sign.
- bingohbangoh 5y agoChiming in as a recent American college grad... One of the most disappointing aspects of American College life is how incurious everybody seemed to be. I had grown up with Reddit & Twitter and easily, many times over, had more interesting conversations, read more nuanced takes, and learned more about the world than I did in any of my college classes. Granted, I was a STEM major with very few humanities classes. But going to parties and clubs, nobody seemed to be curious about anything in the world. It seemed more a goal to "be a writer" than to "write," for instance. Most of the world is like this, for sure. But I spent some $30k a year to attend. What was that money for? What did I get out of it? I will say that in the STEM degrees people were far more curious than in the humanities. Kind of odd given the never-ending cries of "we need engineers to learn more ethics!" from journalists who themselves never bother to learn to code.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- abruzzi 5y ago> One of the most disappointing aspects of American College life is how incurious everybody seemed to be. This reflects the world as a whole. Most people aren't curious about things that don't directly affect them, so I'm not surprised to see it reflected in the college population. Many people in the US treat college as a vocational school, probably in large part because the US pushed hard to increase college attendance. So 75 years ago, someone would graduate high school and apprentice at a job and work their way up, today, they likely start at colloege then jump into the labor force, but they pick their major based on the job they want (just like apperenticing in a field.) Personnaly, I treated college as an instructor led encyclopedia, and just took classes I wanted to learn about. I have never earned a penny with the degrees I received, but I never intended to. Most of my college carreer was spend in tandem with working a full time job. I've only stopped college for a while because my job is sucking up too much of my time. Once I retire, I'll go back to college to get a PhD in math (probabilities, specifically) as background for what I want to study in philosophy (bayesian epistomology)
- mrtranscendence 5y ago> I will say that in the STEM degrees people were far more curious than in the humanities. I suspect this is a bias on your part. It's certainly been my experience that people into the humanities are curious about different things than STEM types; some people have no inclination towards building things, or learning about quantum mechanics, or solving problems in complex analysis. But they might be able to talk your ear off about Edith Wharton or Nazi themes to be found in Heidegger's Being and Time. At least where I went to school people studying the humanities were not appreciably less curious or more "here because I have to be" than engineers.
- platz 5y agoBut one of the special-sauce weapons of the West/US is all these people attempting to make a go of it at creative arts which benefits our economy in the long run compared to super-rigid societies that don't encourage experimentation. Throw enough darts at the board, and a bunch will turn out winners for the benefit of all. A bunch will turn out losers though (anecdote provided by OP). It's probably a losing wager for individuals, but it benefits the economy as a whole. For every 100 kids (insert your own preferred ratio) for whom film was just a phase, we generate a rockstar who changes the world for all of us. The amazing thing is that there are always more individuals that have the audacity to keep trying.
- ylhert 5y agoI agree for the most part, but I don’t think many of these creative endeavors are helped by college (and the costs/debt it brings). In fact, there is a counter argument that perhaps there would be more successful creatives if we did not push everyone to go to college and take on lots of debt; they would have more time, energy, and money that they could more directly apply towards the pursuit of those creative dreams
- platz 5y agoby what mechanism can they directly apply towards the pursuit
- michaelt 5y agoIn some creative fields you can just jump straight into doing it. For example, if your creative aspirations lie in youtube, or twitch, or instagram, or tiktok - mostly they just start doing it, self-educating about things like lighting and lenses.
- platz 5y agoI think people going to college for filmmaking is different from being a streamer.
- droobles 5y agoI used to think college was a complete waste in my 20's but rounding 30 I found the experience shaped who I am and contributed to my success – namely the social element and professors who cared. That said, financially it was too expensive. I hope certificate courses on campus gain more traction as a cheaper alternative to a Bachelor's and people can still form networks in person vs Zoom in the future. I also hope campuses stop forcing people to live on campus in their overpriced, shitty apartments...
- paulpauper 5y agoI think many parents pay for it because they want their kids gone
- carlmcqueen 5y agoIn 2008, I graduated at the same time as this guy, and I had two film grad friends who felt EXACTLY the same way. One started as a wire guy in television and worked his way up to a producer now, the other one I got a job in corporate banking and he moonlit in a wedding video company. He has his own wedding video company now. I wasted my college experience as an awkward introvert. I didn't take college to be a time to make connections with my professors, I didn't take the time to see it as a time of ecosystem of closeness you'd never have again. I was way to shell-shocked inwards. The becoming an adult wasn't something I was ready for yet. I look back at all the opportunities I had to really learn interesting things and network and grow and frown because I was still in my high school 'just survive school' mentality. I did as little as I could to get through each class.
- kingkawn 5y agoEverything is what you make of it.
- listless 5y agoYou went to college for a film degree and then found out you couldn't get a job with it. This should not be a revelation. We tell people to "follow their dreams". That's a nice sentiment, but it's just not how the real world plays out. If this guy had gotten a nursing degree, his experience getting a job would have been entirely different. I'm not saying higher education is perfect, but it's always been the case that some degrees do nothing to further your career or get you a job.
- efa 5y agoI find it hard to believe his degree was a hinderance to him getting a shelf stocker job. Seems like a little exaggeration to make a more colorful story.
- sircastor 5y ago> What matters are connections, professional experience, and the ability to raise large sums of money. I have yet to find a job where these things are not true. In fact, I very much doubt there’s a job where it is your diploma that gets you that job. It’s almost always your connections. Your diploma from Stanford is more l likely to get you a job because of the name than your success in studying there. I finished my degree 15 years into my career as a self-taught developer. I probably didn’t need to get it. I do think it made me a more well-rounded person. And I’m proud of myself for accomplishing something that was not easy, by any stretch.
- michaelt 5y agoIn fields with a lot of demand, like programming, loads of companies will go to recruitment fairs at universities and routinely hire people without any personal connections or professional experience. Fields like fashion and journalism, on the other hand? Unless Mom or Dad has someone who owes them a favour you'll find there are far more graduates than jobs. Compounded with a nigh-endless supply of people willing to work unpaid internships in the hopes of one day getting paid.
- drnonsense42 5y agoJust like much of the healthcare system, government jobs, military contracting, etc., college is a glorified welfare-jobs program for much of the staff and arguably entire departments and schools as well as a business for much of the vampire administrators. Too much welfare relies on the current college system and there have been too many “EdD”’s, MFAs, etc. awarded for us to meaningfully back out of this system. I think the bough will break on society as a whole before anything happens to the school system, considering all the other additional subsystems sucking out resources. These degrees in certain fields have always been a fine vacation for the rich, but unfortunately we’ve beguiled the poor into pursuing them as well. Might as well call it an MLM scheme at this point.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoI went to a state school and got B’s and C’s. I got a degree in Political Science, did NOT get into law school, and somehow still turned out successful. College taught me some responsibility, but mainly how to use my head to think through life instead of just reacting. Had I not gone to college I’m convinced I would be in jail, or worse. College doesn’t make success, it just gives you a set of tools. Ultimately you have to do the work. I am not convinced this author has really put in the work.
- nasir 5y agoI probably didn't learn much in the college but but it was possibly the biggest leverage I had to leave a declining country and come to Europe at a young age. The effect has been wildly life-changing.
- hnburnsy 5y agoThe WSJ had an article about how graduate film programs are even worse... >Recent film program graduates of Columbia University who took out federal student loans had a median debt of $181,000. Yet two years after earning their master’s degrees, half of the borrowers were making less than $30,000 a year. https://www.wsj.com/articles/financially-hobbled-for-life-the-elite-masters-degrees-that-dont-pay-off-11625752773 https://www.wsj.com/articles/financially-hobbled-for-life-th...
- sleepdreamy 5y agoI went to a no-name community college. I have zero debt, I make a livable wage. I work in IT. It can be done, you don't need to go the traditional route anymore unless you can get into a prestigious school. Prestigious schools are worth the connections/friends you will make. Always take it if you are offered to go to Harvard, Princeton, MIT etc; If you get into your regular state college etc then just do 2 years community first and save money. You won't make friends with wealthy/connected people in the same way you would at a prestigious university.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Prestigious schools are worth the connections/friends you will make. Always take it if you are offered to go to Harvard, Princeton, MIT etc; Are they? One of my good friends went to Harvard. He was of a rural blue collar background (he got his admissions file and it had some real gems in it). The only lasting connections he made there were the handful of other people of blue collar backgrounds he crossed paths with in his degree and he has stated he doesn't really think the network was worth the suffering of living in the Boston area for 4yr. It's not like he met a bunch of people who were going to go on to have rocket ship careers in high finance. He met a bunch of people who were going to parlay that Harvard piece of paper into a stable white collar existence.
- sleepdreamy 5y agoYour friends anecdotal experience doesn't trump what is known amongst practically everyone. They all congregate together at elite schools. Sorry your friend experienced that, maybe pick a pertinent degree involving finance next time
- paulpauper 5y agoIt's easy or fun to hate on college these days, and the critics have a lot of good points, but in spite of debt and indoctrination college is still the best path for the median talented person to attain a good standard of living. Yeah, if you have the necessary luck or connections or domain knowledge or rich parents, then maybe you can skip college or delay it to do something else, but most people do not have these luxuries.
- tomatowurst 5y agoI really don't get these type of articles. If you want to argue that college is a mistake, you will find reasons to justify it (student loans, non-translating academia to real world). IF you want to argue that college is not a mistake, you will find reasons as well (networks, lasting friends, potential life partner, social credit & new perspectives and fun: late night study group sessions building camraderie you can reminisce if you run into each other through alumni culture, social activities and so on). Who you were in college/university, what courses you took and how much it cost is missing the point is completely subjective. If you took STEM path but you felt like you could've leveraged your open source contributions to a job, yeah you might be inclined to view it as a transactional loss (which to me is quite predictable and telling of their outlook). IF you did not take traditional STEM path and do not translate into an acceptable level of intellectual challenge/livable wage you will also view it as transactional loss (also quite telling what sort of preferences and outlook this group has). Who you were in college/university, who you met, what sort of social experiences and relations you had will directly translate into how much you view it as worth it. What you get out of something is largely what you perceive as valuable and your current situation will play a large role in that. So it is perfectly acceptable to feel at different points, college/uni was worth it/not worth it. Just for me on a personal level, the friends I have gained through clubs, memories of working late in groups, socializing (pushed myself here), relationships more than made it worth it. My only regret was not pushing myself further to seek potential partner relationships because outside in the real world, there is a loss of innocence and naivete that you could only find in such environments. Everything feels transactional between adults with careers and strings attached although that isn't to say you won't find similar bonding-over-camraderie and aligned interests, you might find even more worth while relationships. It's just that intimate ones seem much harder to come by (at least for me) and that would be my biggest mistake, not exploring/pursuing those because of more problems I deemed more urgent: academia (impacts job), a job upon graduation ( a huge source of anxiety). In reality, I created these urgencies to avoid and limit myself when I should've been all out exploring. It actually might have made me more efficient at studies too. It's the inaction that kills me and I tried to justify it through PTSD, wounds, external things when the correct action would've been to aim to become wiser. I'm thankful for whatever relationships remain, and I feel lucky to say that I've gained friends for life due to college/university but was only possible because I pushed myself to the extremes of comfort zone. Something that I'm saddened to say, I increasingly avoid as I get older. I'm screwed but having friends lessen that dread more, although that isn't to say you can't find ways to do it yourself without external things. Rambled on here but seems tough to really limit this discussion without involving some personal anecdotes because the axiom highlighted in the article is completely irrelevant to anybody reading if they realize its wholly subjective.
- ubermonkey 5y agoYeah, that's not so much "college was a mistake" as "I made huge mistakes with how I went about college."
- nineplay 5y agoThis is a popular gripe during the current political discussions about college debt but I think it drastically undersells the benefits of college degrees that are non-STEM and drastically overestimates the quality of life for people who get trade certifications. You'd think with the popularity of 'antiwork' attitudes, people would notice that few people are inherently motivated to snake out clogged toilets. It's not for everyone. Look though the HR depts. of FAANGs and you'll find a lot of people with humanities degrees who are making good incomes. It's not the dead end field that's often suggested.
- SteveDR 5y agoClickbait title with boring content Everyone has known for a good few years that spending $100,000 on a film degree is not a high-ROI decision
- TxProgrammer 5y agoor Going to an expensive college for a field that has low job prospects was the biggest mistake of his life..
- mrtranscendence 5y ago> The truth is, college isn’t for everyone. It’s a virtual requirement for fields like STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics), medicine, academia, and law. I mean, it's a virtual requirement for more than that. If you want to work a white collar job of almost any type it's much harder if you don't have some kind of college degree. It may only barely be possible unless you're particularly skilled at something or good at finding and chasing opportunities. Accountants, social workers, therapists, teachers, middle managers, HR people, supply chain specialists, city planners ... low and high paid positions of all types ostensibly require a college degree in many cases. I'm sure there are people without degrees doing some of these things, but it's more of an uphill battle.
- Teknoman117 5y agoI graduated 6 years ago and finished paying off the ~$120k earlier this year. I went into tech so paying it off wasn't really a problem. I've wondered at times whether it was worth it or not. I'd been programming since I was 8 and for the most part I only felt like I learned something in a handful of the upper division CS classes (computer architecture set up my love of FPGAs, operating systems was another favorite). The math classes are something I'm happy I was exposed to. I do know that I matured significantly though. I also obtained a large group of friends that I stay in contact with to this day.
- motohagiography 5y agoIf college was indeed a mistake, I would encourage the author to renounce his degree and then A/B test leaving it off his CV, dating profiles, immigration forms, credit and insurance applications, story pitches, corporate bio, club and association membership applications, medical records, and arts or other grant applications, and share the results. Articles like these seem like middle class people knocking the ladder away behind them. If you don't think you need to go to university, you are precisely the person who should go to university, as unlike the long tail of people who actually go, your consideration and self-reflection alone means it's almost uniquely the right bet.
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoTangential: I don't believe college teaches critical thinking, because many students would be quitting college once they realized they were receiving a horrible deal (no evidence completing the degree would increase chances of getting the job). People say college (esp. liberal arts) teaches critical thinking, but in my experience, succeeding in liberal arts classes is about going to office hours and figuring out what the professor wants to hear in your essay. Related: My friend - smartest I've ever known - wasn't a great writer, but got a perfect score on the SAT writing section by memorizing the SAT word list and making an absolutely incomprehensible essay where almost every word was a bastardized thesaurus word for what word should have been used (and many just didn't make sense at all). Undoubtedly, it was a bad essay. But simply because they couldn't read it and it sounded smart, they awarded him the perfect score.
- macinjosh 5y agoI graduated high school in the mid 2000's. At the time I was really into audio tech and music and wanted to become an audio engineer. I had been playing music since second grade and I also clearly had a technical mind as I had a computer and web page building hobby/hustle as well. I ran the sound for my high school's theater department and for the large-ish church my family went to. I attended a college prep charter school and they had dedicated class time for researching and applying for scholarships or applying to colleges. When it was time to start looking at college I found several programs that interested me and I was really excited. Then I started looking at the prices. My family was lower middle class. My parents made ends meet and worked their asses off to do that. There was no way they could have saved for my college. I filled out FASFA and they had nothing to offer me because my parents made too much money (~40k at the time) and also probably because I only had a B+ GPA and I biffed the ACT and received a mediocre score. I had a choice to take out loans and if I was lucky end up in an entry-level position making a quarter of my loan totals a year. I chose to make my computer hobby a career and my music/audio career a hobby. I taught myself web development and eventually back end development. I never went to college and I didn't spend my twenties paying off debts. I am eternally grateful for the choice 17 year old me made. Since then, when something is purported to be a silver bullet or something _everyone_ must do I tend to look for a different direction.
- ldiracdelta 5y agoDepending on the program, college is a filter for higher IQ and attention to detail. There's a cheaper filter called an IQ test, but they are illegal in the US. There is no compelling reason why s/w engineering couldn't be taught on an apprenticeship model after passing some cheap psychology tests. Can you hold 11 variables in your head vs the standard 3 of normal humans? You may be good at s/w. Do you have a high G score? You may be good at software. Too bad we have to encumber kids with crushing debt instead.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> There's a cheaper filter called an IQ test, but they are illegal in the US. Tech people have been repeating this bullshit since the days when Slashdot was the HN. Maybe earlier. It's always been 99% false and 0% true, with 1% "it depends" (please spare us that bullshit). IQ and IQ-like employment proficiency testing is literally an entire cottage industry. > There is no compelling reason why s/w engineering couldn't be taught on an apprenticeship model Two reasons, without thinking particularly hard: 1. Why internalize a cost that can be externalized? 2. Who's doing the mentoring? Senior Engineers make $300K-$600K. Professors make $60K-$200K. Most CS educators make less than their students' first year offers. So, even if you internalized the cost, you'd run it as a stand-alone training program as opposed to embedded apprenticeships. Which, btw, is what companies with "learn to code career pathways"tend to do. > Do you have a high G score? You may be good at software. I know lots of geniuses -- in the sense of high Putnam scores even -- who are clever programmers but couldn't SWE their way out of a wet paper bag. I also know a lot of folks who are not particularly bright but who are really fantastic SWEs. It's not clear to me that IQ is a good predictor of SWE performance for most SWE roles, any more than it's a good predictor for literally any job (including checkout clerk or fry cook, btw). IME certain types of Software folks massively over-estimate their own intelligence and also the importance of IQ-like intelligence required to be excellent in 99% of software development roles.
- WkndTriathlete 5y ago20% of good software engineering is knowing the computer science aspect of software. 80% of good software engineering is being able to translate the problem domain into software and back, as well as communication. IQ tests do not test for the latter, which is arguably the most important part. My ability as a software engineer to effortlessly shift between industries is directly due to the broad college education I received. Software apprenticeships would only lead to a largely immobile workforce stuck in one or two particular technologies. There seems to be this perception in some circles that software engineering is a handful of senior or principal software engineers tediously writing very detailed stories with specifications for hundreds of junior software engineers to crunch out without thinking. This is, without a doubt, one of the most expensive and least efficient means of software development. It's also what an apprenticeship system without college gets you.
- francisofascii 5y agoMy first roommate was a TV/Film major, so I often hung out with people in that major. Many went into the field because they liked movies, a lot. They had some cool classes about camera angles, editing, etc. One or two got jobs at TV stations, but most of them didn't end up in the field.
- bsuvc 5y agoJust because it didn’t work out for you, doesn’t mean it won’t for someone else. Not many 18 year olds would have the ability to jump right into an industry, film in your example. So for them, I can imagine the benefits to going to college being learning/refining their skills, creating a portfolio, and building a network. That’s not mentioning extra things like making friends, learning about other subjects, and other social aspects. Of course if you think you already have all that, then maybe college isn’t for you.
- starwind 5y agoIf you don’t know what you want to do at 18, major in economics at a state school. It’s pretty broad so you can do as much math, writing, and finance as you want. It’s a respectable degree, says you’re smart and practical. Minor or double major in whatever else you think you might want to do. A guy I went to school with did econ and acting. He was working as a producer for a while, and I heard he's going to be in a Netflix show
- throwaway98223 5y agoUndergraduate curriculum is disappointing, college doesn't allow you to jump to graduate level courses even if you are at that level. They don't care what prior knowledge you bring. They want you to pay for years of useless prerequisites that offer you nothing but steal your time and money.
- skeeter2020 5y ago> It’s worth taking a moment to reflect on the fathomless insanity of expecting teenagers to hatch decade-spanning plans intended to shape the course of their lives But this sounds like the exact opposite of what the OP did; there was no long-term planning involved in their decision, they just did what was expected of them. We can argue the huge impact of the established norm "Thou shall attend College" but that's not what happened here. It sounds like they could have studied anything but choose film, then were suprised that immediately out of school were not handed the keys to a multi-million dollar enterprise. Hey, me too, and everyone else regardless of industry or domain.
- iamben 5y agoI had this discussion with a friend a few days ago. We both did CS in the late 90s/early 00s. He said he was telling his kids not to bother with University if they didn't want to (as opposed to being pushed by our parents/teachers as we were - "University is the only route to success"). I was a young 18. 3 years of University helped me grow up in a (relatively!) safe environment, grow a bit more into 'me', make 'adult' friends etc etc. But now I'm not sure I'd recommend it for anyone on 'education' alone. The costs (and subsequent debt) is unreal, and for 85% of the careers my friends went into, University (honestly) wasn't really needed (tech, planning, office work, 'business' things, finance, etc...) - you could definitely get away learning on the job and arguably get further faster. Of course you should probably still go if you want to operate on people or pets, or practice law or something... The experience was definitely fun, if you want to do it for that, I understand it. Whether that experience would be worth paying for now of course - that's debatable. But the world has definitely changed since I went. University was sold as the path to a comfortable living. Now you can make a better than solid living selling diet pills on Instagram, or be a troubled teen on Dr. Phil, go viral and earn $53m on OnlyFans 5 years later (https://news.yahoo.com/bhad-bhabie-shares-receipts-claims-225638171.html https://news.yahoo.com/bhad-bhabie-shares-receipts-claims-22...). Funny old world.
- kbrisso 5y agoI hated school and didn't go to college for a BA in the 80's like everybody else did. I went and took four courses at the community college - electronics, CS 101 and two VB programming classes. The VB programming were taught by a guy who was a contractor during the day. We built this client server pizza order system. I thought it was so cool to build and the teacher must have a really awesome job. Hard work and some luck got me a job with an older guy who used to program by punch cards, it was part time and I did it at nigh why I worked days. He had a lot of patience with me and it paid off for me because I know have been in the industry 22 years. Why did I hate school? I'm dyslexic enough that remembering what I read is hard. I still have a hard time remembering phone numbers. I always did poor in school and disliked it. What I think college doesn't teach you is how to be an entrepreneur or how to use your degree to get a job and now it's so expensive. Is it worth it? It used to be in the 1980's get a four year degree and boom yo have a great entry level job, it was true, I could have had jobs back then with a BA, my friends all did it and it would have been easy to pay off college debt. Not the case today. To the OP - if yo want to get into films please don't give up - hard work does pay off, I took that route instead of school.
- 0x500x79 5y agoThe college system should not be destroyed but be re-thought. I think that the following conditions should be put-in-place: 1. We should stop focusing on universities for any jobs that don't require it. Open up community college degrees to be 4 year for professions that don't need university-level depth. 2. Any profession that is "civic service" should have the debts paid for by the state/federal government after X-years of service. 3. Limit the number of loans available for certain degrees. The article talks about film degrees being not very useful long-term. This should not be something that requires taking 100k of debt out of and we should not push teenagers to take on these loans. For civic professions like teachers, librarians, medicine (nursing): These are jobs that are required for a functioning society. We should not push 100k of debt for a 40k/yr job. Wipe out the debt after a number of years of service. I am not at all disappointed with my decision to attend university, I make plenty of money to pay loans due to being in an affluent career (software engineering). The article calls out that STEM, Doctors, etc should have university-level education and I agree. Let's get away from having students rack up 100's of thousands of dollars on debt for degrees that don't provide that value over 10-20 years to the receiver.
- ameixaseca 5y agoThis is not an argument against college, this is an argument against how college works in the US. There are universities - and I mean well-renowned universities - all across the globe where people can get a degree without necessarily having to go into an obscene amount of debt. A degree may not be for everyone indeed, but we don't have to assume these issues have to necessarily be part of the process.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AcerbicZero 5y agoI loved the ~1.5 years I got to spend at college in between deployments. Not the finest educational experience ever, but I got exactly what I paid for/expected I suppose.
- riazrizvi 5y ago> A degree in film is absolutely worthless for obtaining work in the film industry. What matters are connections, professional experience, and the ability to raise large sums of money. Those aren’t things film school can teach you. Well you're very unlikely to get a job with any degree without writing a resume, attending job fairs, networking etc., the degree is helpful but not sufficient. Film school is a place where you've got the equipment, you've got people there who want to work on projects with similar profiles to yourself, and you've got experienced faculty who have been paid to teach you stuff and who are on the lookout themselves for really good students to refer to their industry friends. It's a place you go to to create a fucking awesome portfolio, so that you can be taken seriously when you network. Of course schools don't put that in the brochure, because they are businesses in a competitive field, so they try to talk up what you can get if you go to their place in particular. You have to figure this out for yourself.
- akamia 5y agoThis is a really great point. My brother-in-law went to film school and did exactly what you described. He networked with his professors and peers, worked on lots of projects, used the software and equipment available through the school, and graduated with a strong portfolio. He has been consistently working in the field since graduating. Obviously this is just a single anecdote but I think it does show that it is possible to succeed if you really take advantage of the resources that are available to you in school.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- killingmehardly 5y ago
- t0bia_s 5y agoI have similar story. Studied film animation at university for 4 years, last year working in game industry... Most skills I learned that last year at work. At uni first 3 semesters was actually for learning something new - mostly in working with software, but the rest not worth it. In art industry diploma doesn't mean much. Portfolio and contacts are everything you need.