5 ms·
On intellectually interesting thing about the current NATO-Russia conflict is it suggests that the overarching strategy is to figure out whether the stove is ho
by roenxi 5y ago
On intellectually interesting thing about the current NATO-Russia conflict is it suggests that the overarching strategy is to figure out whether the stove is hot by touching it. Obviously neither Russia nor the US see a diplomatic solution, but it is happening on Russia's border so at some point someone will escalate too far. And everyone is on edge and tetchy after the the COVID response. The current world superpower is run by people who are pretty sure that the answer to economic problems involves printing money. Obviously this'll end well.
Energy use is also approaching a critical point. The experiments in Europe indicate that the closing of the fossil fuel age will be unpleasant. The electricity production figures out of the UK are jaw dropping, last I saw they seem to have regressed to 1970s levels.
In this environment, it is easy to see why people are ramping up military training. If it wasn't for the fact that a serious war will be apocalyptic regardless of spending I imagine they'd be ramping up faster and more enthusiastically.
- chinathrow 5y ago> NATO-Russia conflict Can you explain your framing?
- throwaway4good 5y agoI believe that is what it looks like from a Russian perspective.
- WJW 5y agoTo be fair, without the several billion USD in free high-tech weapons from the Western countries (mostly though not exclusively NATO members) Ukraine would probably have lost the war by now. It's an open secret that NATO has been passing on intelligence from AWACS and spy satellites to the Ukrainian forces as well. There might be no NATO troops on the ground but it's a bit of a stretch to say that it is purely Ukraine vs Russia.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> without the several billion USD in free high-tech weapons from the Western countries (mostly though not exclusively NATO members) Ukraine would probably have lost the war by now And without the navy Russia annexed [1], or it’s Soviet military kit, much of which was designed and built in Ukraine, Russia wouldn’t have much of a start. Ukraine repelled Putin’s forces on its own in the early days of the war, when Western intelligence was predicting another Kabul. That it later attracted sympathy is further testament to its diplomatic strength (and the Kremlin’s isolation). [1] https://tass.com/russia/724901 https://tass.com/russia/724901
- somenameforme 5y agoOut of curiosity, where did you read that? I assumed Wiki had been trolled, but even they add the rather important follow up you seem to be unaware of [1]. Just quoting Wiki as it is accurate on this note (you can also search anywhere to confirm): "On 8 April 2014 an agreement was reached between Russia and Ukraine to return Ukrainian Navy materials to Ukraine proper. The greater portion of the Ukrainian naval ships and vessels were then returned to Ukraine but Russia suspended this process after Ukraine did not renew its unilaterally declared ceasefire on 1 July 2014 in the conflict in the Donbas." [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Sea_Fleet#Russian_annexation_of_Crimea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Sea_Fleet#Russian_annexa...
- _djo_ 5y agoIt's still only Ukraine vs Russia, even if Ukraine is using weapons acquired from elsewhere and getting intelligence information from other countries. That's a pretty basic idea in international politics, having been developed over decades of similar proxy wars. Same reason the US didn't consider itself at war with the USSR in Korea or Vietnam.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CapricornNoble 5y ago
- pmyteh 5y agoIt's totally a NATO proxy war. We're doing everything we can short of sending in our own troops with the intent of defending Ukraine and weakening Russia. It's also totally a Russian war of aggression. The two are not in any way incompatible.
- danbruc 5y agoNot OP, but there are - to a first approximation - two explanations for the Russian aggression. The more popular one in the West is that Putin is nostalgic about past Soviet powers and wants to restore those. The other and rather unpopular explanation is that Putin is afraid of NATO and wants a buffer between Russia and NATO members, hence Ukraine moving towards a NATO membership is considered a threat, diplomatic solutions were not reached - I am not going to assign blame here - so war it is. This is of course a much less popular opinion because it might imply that NATO actions might have contributed to the escalation, but all things considered I also think that this is the more probable explanation or at least the dominant contributing factor. This in turn makes Ukraine the victim of a conflict between Russia and NATO.
- reducesuffering 5y agoIf Putin is afraid of NATO, then why did he create the scenario where Sweden and Finland are now joining NATO? Do you think he's stupid? Why would he be afraid of a NATO offense on Russia when NATO won't do defense to protect an invasion against Ukraine?
- danbruc 5y agoThe early 1960s, the United States are afraid of Soviet influence spreading from Cuba. They support the Bay of Pigs Invasion [1] in hope to get rid of the pro-Soviet government but this fails. So the CIA starts Operation Mongoose [2] hoping to achieve the goal with terrorist attacks, assassinations, sabotage, and so on. In order to deter the United States from further interference, Cuba asks the Soviet Union to station missiles in Cuba which results in the Cuban Missile Crisis [3] bringing the world closer to nuclear war than ever before or since. What were they thinking? Were they stupid? Why would they risk worsening the situation by messing with Cuba? And while we are at it, why do the United States have any say in whether or not the Soviet Union stations missiles in Cuba? Cuba is a sovereign state, if they want Soviet missiles, they should be allowed to have them, right? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_of_Pigs_Invasion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_of_Pigs_Invasion [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mongoose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mongoose [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis
- speeder 5y agoNote: I am from Brazil, and live nowhere near Russia. That said... I believe Russia see the invasion on Ukraine as a necessity to block Ukraine from joining NATO. A lot of people thinking Russia wants to just conquer Ukraine risk a massive escalation. Ukraine did a lot of things that pissed Russia off after it started to get closer ties to USA... Among them: 1. Ban on Russian Language 2. Threatening to close Sevastapol base (before Russia claimed Crimea back) 3. Accepting Azov battalion as part of the official army. 4. Allowing army members use SS symbols on their uniform (to be more specific, Galizen) and so on. But the most important one was: Adding in the constitution that they will join NATO, and accepting billions in military aid from USA (yes, USA was pumping a ton of weapons in Ukraine BEFORE the war, USA itself said so!) Ukraine joining NATO is a risk Russia can't take, yes NATO is defensive but Russia has beef with NATO members already, if Ukraine joins NATO for example it becomes way riskier for Russia to defend Armenia as ally if Turkey attacks them for example, and there is the fact NATO members been actually on the offensive a couple times now, and the whole NATO bombed the shit out of Serbia officially in the past (Russia was helping Serbia in that conflict) So why I said this risk massive escalation? Well, if you understand your enemy wrong you will make wrong decisions. Russia doesn't want to conquer Ukraine, they want to keep NATO away from that border, and there are two ways of doing that: 1. Convince Ukraine to not join NATO (what they are trying to do now). 2. Just bomb Ukraine until there is nothing left to join NATO in first place. A lot of people are thinking Russia won't try the second option because they want to conquer Ukraine, they are wrong about this, Russia knows very well they don't have right now the capability to conquer Ukraine, the only rational decision to go about this is try a "diplomatic" victory, and if that fails, then the real "War" comes (I suspect this is why Russia don't call this a war yet), where Russia will finally use all their equipment, including a large amount of strategic bombers and intermediate range missiles to utterly destroy everything in Ukraine, this way they don't have to bother with occupation and will still win regardless of how much NATO weapons are inside Ukraine (in fact the more NATO fills Ukraine with weapons, the bigger target it becomes for indiscriminate destruction, when else Russia will have opportunity to wipe out all the equipment of enemies like that?) EDIT: I hope all downvotes aren't because people are believing I am wrong in claiming Russia WILL flatten Ukraine if they feel the need to do so and support more war...
- 5y ago
- jurip 5y agoIt is not happening on Russia's border, it is happening in Ukraine. And "someone" already escalated too far when they invaded Ukraine.
- jotm 5y agoAh yes, NATO-Russian conflict. Russia can't possibly be losing to "insignificant Ukraine", which only exists because of the grace of Lenin or whatever. No, clearly Russia is having trouble because it's NATO fighting them. Yeah, yeah. It's OK, after this is over and Russians learn more of the truth, Ukrainians will be just as respected by them as the Chechens and Germans.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoWhat NATO-Russia conflict? Russia invaded Ukraine which isn't a NATO country. As far as I'm aware there's no open conflict between NATO and Russia; tension, sure, but that's because Russia decided to invade another country both this year and in 2014. They're showing aggression, and instead of seeking better relationships with the rest of the world via e.g. trade deals they decided to try and flex, and look pretty shoddy in the process.
- roenxi 5y agoIn Ukraine Russia is fighting people armed with NATO arms (appearing to be largely donated), guided by NATO military advisers and aided by a sanctions program and rhetoric from NATO countries. Hence the hot stove comment. The US is planning to figure out where Russia's red line is between for being at war with NATO by stepping slightly over it. If the US military were actually worried about how this is turning out they wouldn't have let the situation evolve like this.
- rowanajmarshall 5y ago> The electricity production figures out of the UK are jaw dropping, last I saw they seem to have regressed to 1970s levels. UK energy production/usage figures have been decreasing since about 2005[1]. It's not a sign of energy poverty (aside for the past year I suppose). [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/322874/electricity-consumption-from-all-electricity-suppliers-in-the-united-kingdom/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/322874/electricity-consu...
- roenxi 5y agoI don't follow why you think that argument is enough. Surely a persistent, long term trend of worsening energy availability would be exactly the sign of energy poverty? There are only two possible signs of energy poverty - a trend of stable low numbers and a trend of dropping numbers! You might disagree for great reasons, I'm just stumped by what you wrote.
- ParksNet 5y agoA fairly significant portion of Europe's GDP is dedicated to the healthcare and welfare for non-productive groups: the Retired, and non-Western migrants. Pensions in Italy are 17% of GDP, for example. Europe will need to cut those two groups loose and unleash massive tax reforms if it wishes to craft a better future.
- pmyteh 5y ago"Non-Western migrants" are net contributors to the state budget essentially everywhere. They're disproportionately young and employed. In any case, 'non-productive' people like retirees still need income. They could be living off rents and investment returns, or off state pensions. Both are unearned and don't reflect productivity.
- oneoff786 5y agoIf by the end of fossil fuels you mean tripling down on coal instead of oil then surr