12 ms·
Electronics Explained: Fundamentals for engineers, technicians and makers (2018)
- fxtentacle 5y agoI found that electronics are very difficult to learn from books, but easy to learn as an apprentice. Maybe just visit your local hackerspace, they'll have the tools around and ideas for easy starter projects.
- lbriner 5y agoAs an electronics teacher, I don't think it is specifically that learning from books is difficult but that it is hard to strike the balance between theory and practice, the high level and the low level. My approach has been to ignore a lot of detail until it is needed to understand what is happening on the macro level. For example, you don't need to understand electrons especially travelling opposite to current, which can be especially challenging, until we might discuss why some components have a higher rated power than others or why we cannot control a large motor with a small transistor, at which point we can introduce current.
- andi999 5y agoThats why 'the art of electronics' has a lab companion book.
- mindcrime 5y agoAs an electronics teacher, I don't think it is specifically that learning from books is difficult but that it is hard to strike the balance between theory and practice, the high level and the low level. As a hobby electronics enthusiast who has been dabbling with this stuff basically my whole life, and is currently lodged firmly somewhere in the gap between "total n00b" and "advanced beginner", I would absolutely agree. The gap between practice and theory in this field is so large, and so many books are all the way at one end of the spectrum or the other, that it's very hard (in my experience) to find material in the "sweet spot" between theory and practice. The reality is, you can learn a lot, and do a lot, with a moderately superficial knowledge of the underlying theory. But at the same time, there's a lot you can't do, or a lot of mistakes you can make unknowingly, without knowing the theory. Learning it incrementally, piece-meal as needed, is somewhat doable, but it's a slog. I wish I had a good answer for people who want to "do some electronics" but don't want to go get an E.E. degree.
- tuatoru 5y agoI'm in the same position more or less. I recently discovered a book that looks to be a good "intermediate" theory text: Passive Circuit Analysis with LTSpice: an Interactive Approach. Only have the kindle sample at present, as it's a fair chunk of money for my budget.
- 6c737133 5y agoYou can pump for-profit books on HN?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- youeseh 5y agoYes, just like you can pump other for-profit services and products on HN, you can pump for-profit books too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jacknews 5y agoDo you have to buy it chapter-by-chapter? Pfft. If they really want to extract maximum profit, they should consider selling word-by-word. Perhaps more important words could be auctioned, there are endless possibilities.
- bsder 5y agoFor anyone who really wants to get into electronics, skip this and go pick up anything written by Forrest Mims. Practically anything he's ever written is gold. And since they were so common there's a lot of them floating around used.
- stephen_g 5y agoYou can find scans of a lot of them online, e.g. https://worldradiohistory.com/Archive-Company-Publications/Radio-Shack/Engineer%27s%20Mini-Notebook%20-%20Communications%20Projects.pdf https://worldradiohistory.com/Archive-Company-Publications/R...
- iammjm 5y agoThank you, this looks amazing!
- DaveExeter 5y agohttps://worldradiohistory.com/Archive-Company-Publications/Radio-Shack/ https://worldradiohistory.com/Archive-Company-Publications/R...
- uuyi 5y agoThey have legendary status but they aren’t very good books. In some cases they are quite misleading. Unfortunately I don’t think there’s anything better out there yet at that level. I remember having to unlearn stuff when I progressed past the very limited explanations. Electronics as a subject is one of those things that’s really difficult to explain without a basic understanding of maths and he skirts well around that where possible. If you know how to juggle numbers, probably better to start with The Art of Electronics.
- buescher 5y agoAgreed. In defense of Forrest Mims, though, his circuits generally work and are simple, to-the-point approaches.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoOK so the book is not bad. But since it touches so many subjects, I'd say most have been treated a bit superficially. Mind you, I don't think it's bad. You have most important concept explained in an accessible way, without the math getting in the way, and I'd say accurately enough. But if you want to go deeper into any of the many subjects presented in the book, you'll do much better buying a separate book (and there's no way around math). All in, I think many people would benefit from it, especially most beginners who have no idea how things work. I'm not sure about the HN crowd.
- uuyi 5y agoOk found a PDF and scanned through it. This appears to be a rehash of older material, going back as far as the 90s, as I recognise some of the graphics and explanations. Newnes seem to make a great effort to retitle and reuse stuff in this capacity. It doesn’t look like a terrible book to be fair but limited in explanation and use. Worthy of the title perhaps. If I was at ground zero now I’d probably buy that, then do Khan Academy algebra and calculus, then pick up Art of Electronics and then Sedra/Smith. Art of Electronics is really important as it discusses applied theory rather than just theory. The real world is a lot less ideal and has edge cases and problems galore in it and concerns which don’t even appear in theoretical texts. I honestly wish I had all this stuff as a kid. Had to put up with local library contents which were full of garbage.
- lbriner 5y agoIt depends what you want to do and at what level. There are many Makers in the world who don't have and don't need the AoE, it is a tome written a while back before lots of circuits came pre-packaged and which in many cases people don't care about how they work, as long as they just work. Remember back in the day, to make a high powered audio amp, you needed a tonne of components and now you can get a 150W amp on a chip with a couple of external components. Some people will be interested in how each section works but many just want an audio amp! If you were learning formally/professionally, that would be very different and the narrative in the AoE is very useful, especially around improving transistor characteristics by building up supporting components.
- uuyi 5y agoThe problem is that line of thinking only scales to when things work using the very basic level of abstraction presented. A 150W audio amplifier is a surprisingly difficult thing to get working right, even with an off the shelf IC. You have to consider grounding, trace impedances, current density, power supply quality, filtering and parasitics really otherwise you end up with wildly oscillating nightmares or exploding amplifier ICs.
- Terry_Roll 5y ago> Remember back in the day, to make a high powered audio amp, you needed a tonne of components and now you can get a 150W amp on a chip with a couple of external components. Some people will be interested in how each section works but many just want an audio amp! Careful you might get Audiophiles arguing that an IC doesnt cut the mustard.
- lysp 5y agoOne book I saw mentioned a lot in relation to learning electronics is this one: https://artofelectronics.net/ https://artofelectronics.net/ Reviews state it's basically an encyclopedia of knowledge.
- atoav 5y agoI have the physical copy of the last edition. It is good. For total beginners it might be a notch to fast tho. The introduction has been rewritten completely from former editions as far as I can tell, and to my judgment has a better pacing and a friendlier tone. For those who already have a little bit of knowledge from tinkering around and seek to deepen their understanding it is definitly very much recommended.
- formerly_proven 5y agoIf you use it like a calculus textbook I can see it working for first contact. But most people won't do that, which makes it not suitable for a "first contact" introduction. It's superb for people who have some prior experience and can read it in a choose-your-own-adventure way.
- lbriner 5y agoYeah, it's a pretty hardcore book and would only work for most people after High School unless they are super committed. It is good in that it develops why using transistors as switches doesn't work in many scenarios but then basically says, "Op Amps" are better for everything and the rest of the circuits use those instead so you could argue that many people don't need to learn about the underpinning theory. It also weighs in 1000+ pages and doesn't work well as a reference for most things because the info often builds on previous chapters.
- Gracana 5y agoI felt it worked as a reference. Yeah, it might explain something using concepts you don't understand, but you can backtrack as far as necessary, then start working your way back to where you started.
- progre 5y agoAn alternative, even if you are not into modular synths, is Moritz Klein's videos https://youtube.com/c/MoritzKlein0 https://youtube.com/c/MoritzKlein0 The basics are very well explained.
- recuter 5y agoThis is very good but before throwing people off the deep end I'd suggest this overview (origin of the dx7 & fm synthesis): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXt_NXjc7oY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXt_NXjc7oY And then some bigclivedotcom to get going: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Maq5IyHSuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Maq5IyHSuc EEVblog for intermediate beginner stuff / home gamer lab gear: https://www.youtube.com/c/EevblogDave/videos?view=0&sort=p&flow=grid https://www.youtube.com/c/EevblogDave/videos?view=0&sort=p&f... And finally some Marco Reps for advanced beginners: https://www.youtube.com/c/MarcoReps/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/MarcoReps/videos Just to dip your toe in.
- progre 5y agoWouldn't say Moritz videos are the deep end. He is explaining resistors by comparing them to water pipes with narrow parts. He is also very good at pointing out where such comparisons don't work.
- torginus 5y agoWhy is this interesting? An intro to electronics book locked behind a paywall...
- blippage 5y agoI find the problem with a lot of electronics books is that they are either too deep, or too shallow. Gerry Sussman (yes, that Sussman) explained that the way electronics is taught, and the way engineers think about problems are two separate things. So teaching material tends to fall into two camps: 1) detailed explanations that cover great depth, but are difficult to know how to apply to practical circuits, or 2) circuits that are presented as a fait accompli. They work, but I have no real idea why. It reminds of statistics, in a way. I've seen biologists, undergrads and industry apply statistics like it was some kind of talisman. "Cargo Cult Statistics", as it were. They don't really "understand" the data that they're looking at.
- tinco 5y agoAt university one of the mandatory courses was Computer Organisation, which teaches how computers are built electronically. Two weeks of that course covered DRAM timings. Recently (almost 15 years later) I was trying to design a simple automation system for my home's ventilation system, and for it I needed to pull my logic signal up to 10v using a FET. I had absolutely no idea how to do that. It's absolutely crazy that at some point I was able to (crudely) design a computer logically to the level of detail of DRAM timings, but at the same time I've never had a deep enough understanding of current to design a circuit that uses a logical signal to switch a 10v line using a FET. (this is how you do it btw: https://tinyurl.com/ydsgmdvh https://tinyurl.com/ydsgmdvh)
- cushychicken 5y agoThere is a real case where someone could go a whole career in EE knowing a ton about DRAM timings and nothing about pulling up FET switches to the proper voltage. I know - I've met them!
- mcnugget 5y agoReal world effects of parasitics are underated. Found out the hard way that there's a whole lot of pain involved with hot plugging a battery into a board when there's a modular switch mode power supply onboard. Oh, you have a low esr ceramic cap on the input? Lol, the parasitic inductances of your wire and traces have formed a tank circuit and pushed the input voltage well above the unhappy voltage of something. K, you fixed that part, nope, lol, your inrush current is actually 15A because you had 68uF on the output of the smps and somehow you burnt out the internal fet of the smps module. Goddam nearly flipped a table.
- baybal2 5y agoI am doing electronics since my first job in 2007, and I never managed to get a university education in it. I greatly regret. Even 15 years later, I still can't do things every uni grad should be able to through practice, and drill. You will never be as good as an engineer with university education, if you self-study.
- hnthrowaway0315 5y agoI'm wondering if there is a minimum book of analog electronics for embedded electronics (and especially the hacking of). I dabbed into a Tiva launchpad from last Dec to Feb and went through a beginner textbook, but put the project to suspend as I failed to bit bang a few peripherals so got discouraged. Nevertheless I noticed that I only need a minimum amount of analog electronics, basically: 1. Resistors (of course, for voltage divider mostly) 2. Capacitors (to be connected to power pins to filter, and usually pF/uF for different places. I forgot the "rules" since I haven't touched it for a few months) 3. Diodes (to protect against backward flow) And that's pretty much it. From my understanding, the pins are also transistors but there is no need to go down that level (only need to know voltage tolerance, output signal strength and such). And even transistors are pretty easy to understand for TTL gates. To go a bit further, I never read much about Op Amp, but considering you can build logic gates with Op Amps, maybe it not that difficult if I do not need to look into the details? I found anything that can be abstracted into logic gates to be easier to digest, but of course actually building a computer from Op Amp or TTL is still a feat beyond my reach (Ben Eater has a very good series).
- igorkraw 5y agoThere is: Horowitz celebrated "art of electronics" https://artofelectronics.net/ https://artofelectronics.net/
- hnthrowaway0315 5y agoI think this is an encyclopedia?
- auxym 5y agoHeard some good from this book: https://www.mheducation.ca/practical-electronics-for-inventors-fourth-edition-9781259587542-can https://www.mheducation.ca/practical-electronics-for-invento... Also a free one: https://www.analog.com/en/education/education-library/linear-circuit-design-handbook.html https://www.analog.com/en/education/education-library/linear...
- 5y ago
- Sporktacular 5y agoA lot of these guys start with the function they need a circuit to fulfil and learn just enough to select and integrate it into the project, so at the block diagram level. In those cases learning circuit design is overkill when learning how to select one (from a circuit cookbook) by understanding functional and integration parameters, customising and modifying it after reverse engineering are sufficient. Akin to a course in driving rather than car design. Not sure how many books approach it that way but for a lot of people building fully customised electronic circuits is too much effort.
- rnouse 5y agoI mean, if we're shilling books and intro electronics is the topic, here's a fun one: https://nostarch.com/hardwarehacking https://nostarch.com/hardwarehacking (Published Nov 2021).
- donthellbanme 5y agoThis is advice for hobbyists. Guys who want to tinker, wire their home, and fix their car, and maybe fix that broken radio. I have found most people are rusty when it comes to Electronics, and electricity. The Art of Electronics, and it's lab, is very long. I was shocked when I heard Harvard Students completed it in 1 semester. It's recommended here a lot though. There's nothing wrong with it other than being written years ago. I don't like the part on computers, and solid state electronics. (I'm too lazy to pull out my copy, but would love to know how it's possible by a ex student. Maybe it's a two semester course? It's in the foreword to anyone interested.) If you just want a decent understanding of electricity, I like the "Make" publications. Throw in the Dummies whatever on Electronics. The US navy also has a decent books too. They are free. If wiring a house/building pick up a copy of Ugly's, and Dewalt Electrical code reference. Make sure you know how a 3 way switch works before putting the books down. For some reason a three way switch is Greek to a lot of people. If you are really suppose to know this stuff, but feel like a fraud, pick up Electricial Engineering 101 Everything you should have learned in school but didn't. I don't have a recommendation for working on automobiles though. Even though the basics of electronics will get you through most problems you will encounter when working on your vechicle, I am still looking for an in-depth manual. Something that goes deep into the computers of our vechicles. The books recommended to mechanics just skim over a lot of the complicated stuff. There's a need for an in-depth book on electric vehicles. I'm always looking for anything Tesla, but it's all priority? Or, very high priced information. Elon if you ever read this; we love, and respect you. Us shade tree mechanics are salivating over your engineer's repair info. There are a lot of hot rod types that want to get your salvaged vechices back on the road. And no you don't inside info to get a crashed Tesla up and running, but it would be nice. We might remember the favor when there's more competition? It's all about manipulating OHM's law. Again--it's all about OHM's law for the theory. Don't make it more complicated than needed. Learning about resistors, caps, potentiometers, etc. is pretty basic. Oh yea, a nice DVOM, like Fluke 88, and a power source, will make your life easier. You don't need a Fluke 88 with all the attachments. I got one in Reno for $75.00, and just love the quality of the instrument. I truly feel if a guy likes their tooling it just makes solving a problem less of a hassle.
- buescher 5y ago
- jpm_sd 5y agoNot great. I'd recommend "Practical Electronics for Inventors" by Paul Scherz, it strikes a good balance between theory and practice.
- troydavis 5y agoIf anyone else wants to read this book, it's available as an ebook through O'Reilly Complete Public Library (formerly Safari Books Online). In the US and Canada, many public libraries include access to O'Reilly's service as part of having a library card. Cincinnati, Denver, Edmonton, Kansas City, and Seattle are among those libraries: https://www.libraryjournal.com/story/public-libraries-workforce-development https://www.libraryjournal.com/story/public-libraries-workfo... . Search your local library for this title and see what you find.