3 ms·
None of these are censorship. Petty, retaliatory, and abusive, sure. but not censorship.
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
None of these are censorship. Petty, retaliatory, and abusive, sure. but not censorship.
- jjulius 5y agoFiring an employee for posting a video of a FSD beta-enabled Tesla is not only, as you said, retaliatory, but it is also censorship. He used that employee to set an example for others, effectively causing people to censor themselves in the future.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoSo is firing and even suing an employee for disseminating your proprietary code, but few would argue that that is censorship, in the free speech sense.
- fzeroracer 5y agoIf someone was a purported free speech absolutist, then yes that would be censorship. It would be a violation of copyright law, but copyright law and censorship can easily be argued to go hand in hand. Which is partly why free speech absolutists cannot exist. Eventually, everyone draws a line in the sand. In the case of Elon Musk, that line in the sand seems to move depending on whom does the censoring.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoWho ever said he is an absolutist? I have only seen that claim from critics making a no true Scott's an argument. At a minimum he said he will regulate illegal content.
- fzeroracer 5y agoHe's literally referred to himself as a free speech absolutist [1]. I don't know how much more explicit it can get here. Unless you want to argue that he's a hypocrite and his words have no meaning or something, in which case that's precisely the problem a lot of people have with him and his 'free speech' stance. [1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1499976967105433600?s=20&t=_fhxUkSnjC9ZNq_cDaGNVQ https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1499976967105433600?s=20...
- simondotau 5y agoIt could be argued that dissemination of someone else's speech isn't your speech, and thus there's no hypocrisy.
- revicon 5y agoIt’s examples of Elon taking any advantage he can find to retaliate against people that personally piss him off. There’s no reason this wouldn’t extend to Twitter
- jlawson 5y agoThe reason is because he has a stated principle that he would have to violate to do it through Twitter. He didn't violate any of his stated principles with his earlier actions. If he goes a year or two without taking such action, will you reverse your opinion?
- bagels 5y agoSure, and neither is Twitter banning people. The argument is that Musk will silence or get retribution against people through Twitter ownership, just as he does in other contexts.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThat's a more refined argument then I've heard. Yeah, I think it is possible that he might fire Twitter employees who are vocal critics of the company position. I think a lot of people still see this Petty personal retaliation as a step up from silencing people based on arbitrary politics. I am much more skeptical that he will be banning politicians from the platform or disagreeable positions
- tlear 5y agoHe should fire those people. In fact from day one for the first few month the objective should be cleaning house, hard. Reduce head count by 50%. In fact dig through who came up with idea to ban Babylon Bee and just fire everyone who saw that decision and was not opposed.
- bagels 5y agoPolitically motivated or not, he stands to dramatically increase profit margins, at least in the short term, by getting rid of people.