3 ms·
Signal is a chat app (a very good one!), not a generic application layer like HTTP. When we're talking about the breadth of the services available on the web, t
by woodruffw 5y ago
Signal is a chat app (a very good one!), not a generic application layer like HTTP. When we're talking about the breadth of the services available on the web, there are plenty of contexts in which TLS is an E2E scheme. Not every use of TLS is E2E, but I didn't claim that.
- rektide 5y agoI dont know what case you are trying to make? Should we not create cryptographic storage on the web? Is that not ok? Do you think there's anything that would keep us from using secure keys for encrypting storage? Is there some barrier you perceieve to why the web couldnt make use of such a capability? I have no clue why you are building a case out for the web being something special & different & weird & hard to expect basic common sense secure cryptography from. Nitrokey had a pretty basic simple sensible early draft spec. Having some storage & a key that alone cam decrypt it seems trivially obvious. Not sure what kind of smoke you are attempting to blow on this idea. TLS has absolutely nothing to do with this. The idea of e2e messaging usually is that you could send the message over untrusted links just fine. The other party could validate & decrypt it. Discussion on TLS seems wildly off topic/tangenti to the kind of e2e storage that messaging apps do, and that secure end to end storage entails. Edit: to your credit, the MLS link you have above is indeed relevant.
- raggi 5y agohttps://github.com/w3c/webauthn/issues/1462 https://github.com/w3c/webauthn/issues/1462