6 ms·
Why would manganese be able to dodge the insincere environmental accusations that are aimed at lithium mines? Manganese is mostly produced using destructive ope
by jeffbee 5y ago
Why would manganese be able to dodge the insincere environmental accusations that are aimed at lithium mines? Manganese is mostly produced using destructive open-cut pits in poor African nations. The number and size of said pits absolutely dwarfs all lithium mines put together. So why would it be OK to increase manganese production when there are organizations opposed to lithium production?
Honestly, same question about iron. Why is lithium such a bogeyman when iron ore production is 1000s of times larger?
- mrpopo 5y agoObviously, unless we manage to somehow get usable sea-water based batteries, any mass-market battery technology will have a tremendous impact on the environment. The problem is not manganese or lithium, it is the mass production and consumption, unregulated vehicle growth (in size and weight), all of this encouraged by pro-cars regulations, the US being the worst offender.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> Why is lithium such a bogeyman when iron ore production is 1000s of times larger? Because the people making the argument aren't being genuine. They don't care. They want a "gotcha" and to feel like they "owned" the "libtard" driving the "eco-warrior-mobile." When the Toyota Prius came out two decades ago, people boo-hooed about the environmental impact of the battery - either the carbon impact or the environmental impacts of the mining. You could show them the numbers, tell them that the packs are highly recyclable and thus we're only pulling the ore out of the earth once and then get to re-use it numerous times...versus fossil fuels where they're useful once. Point to the huge gas and emissions reduction over the life of the vehicle. They don't care. Your facts get dismissed as Fake News. Same with solar panels. Doomsayers were predicting landfills full of panels and boo-hooing about the environmental cost. Part of the problem there is that people think "lifetime of 20 years" means "20 years and then phbbbtttt, dead" but reality is "20 years and now only 80% capacity." As solar gets more common, there will be more infrastructure It's also fascinating that "set up an entirely new distribution infrastructure around hydrogen" or "create nuclear-waste-recycling reactors" isn't a problem, but apparently "a used market for solar panels will crop up all on its own" is inconceivable. The same people would likely be stunned, stunned I tell you, that there are many shops out there rebuilding Prius battery packs and all manner of EV battery packs are valuable on the used market.
- mbg721 5y agoThere were skeptical people who got burned hard by being forced into using squiggly light bulbs that were supposed to last forever and that you can't throw away because they're full of mercury. Now, I have a box of burnt-out ones that I'm saving for a disposal day, and I've had two repairmen from separate companies bash their heads into an overhead one at the bottom of my basement stairs, shattering it. Pile that on top of various experiences with phone and laptop batteries...is it "different this time", or were the previous promises just lies?
- seoaeu 5y agoWho ever claimed that CFL light bulbs were going to last forever? I've never seen any marketing for any light bulb that said they would never burn out
- _ph_ 5y agoI used CFL light bulbs for like 2 decades and they were extremely long-lasting. I got rid of the last one some months ago, it wasn't dead yet but got a bit weak. I had installed it like 15 years ago.
- oldsecondhand 5y agoWhen CFLs were new, I had cheap CFLs that wouldn't last even half as much as an incandescent bulb while still costing 4-5 times as much.
- _ph_ 5y agoI never had this experience. My first CFL lasted at least 10 years of daily usage as my desk lamp - I think I got rid of it not because it was broken but truly outdated. It is possible that the quality of the grid plays a role as voltage fluctuations might reduce their life time.
- marssaxman 5y ago
- ajuc 5y agoI don't know about manganese vs lithium, but with potential iron batteries the fact that iron ore production is already 1000s of times larger means that the impact of adding battery production won't be as big. If you have to do 1% more of something it's probably not a problem. If you have to do 900% more of something - it will likely become a problem.
- DennisP 5y agoAlso, different elements will have different impacts per kilogram, just because they have different concentrations, are found in different environments, etc. If X is 30% of its ore and Y is 0.03%, then you can dig up a thousand times as much X as Y and get the same environmental impact for each.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThis logic makes no sence whatsoever. So of we had to increase production of moss, would that be a prohlem? No, because it has no impact - we just never needed to produce it in quantity. Same goes for lithium. The only thong that matters is the absolute ecological impact per kilo produced.
- ajuc 5y ago> So of we had to increase production of moss, would that be a prohlem? By 900%? Sure. > No, because it has no impact You don't see the impact because it's too small for now. It will become obvious when you scale up by orders of magnitude. Cars were seen as the solution to pollution in cities once.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo you think there is an impact, but you cant point out what it is because about farming moss is just as mysterious to a 21st century man as climate change was to 19th century man?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]