4 ms·
> So if you should only marry to reproduce, does that mean old people shouldn’t get married? Should we stop people who take steps not to reproduce? Except the
by rayiner 5y ago
> So if you should only marry to reproduce, does that mean old people shouldn’t get married? Should we stop people who take steps not to reproduce?
Except the current debate isn't about marriage law, it's about what kids should be taught in school, and when. It's one thing to have marriage law accommodate different groups with different beliefs about the basis of marriage. It's a different thing to teach any particular view or set of moral judgments to kids in public schools.
> Conservatives use to fight to outlaw birth control and it is still the stance of many.
As I noted in my post, it's 2022, not 1992. Today, 90% of conservatives agree with 93% of liberals that birth control is morally acceptable. https://news.gallup.com/poll/257858/birth-control-tops-list-morally-acceptable-issues.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/257858/birth-control-tops-list-....
Conservatives and libertarians were on opposite sides of this issue in the 1960s. But today, the political dispute is over privately owned companies being forced to pay for birth control for employees. And on the contemporary issue, libertarians and conservatives are on the same side.
- scarface74 5y agoNo one is trying to “turn your kids gay”. But it’s clearly factual that some people prefer their mates to be of the same sex and I don’t see any reason to try to shelter kids from that.
- rayiner 5y agoOf course not, because it’s biologically determined. But that doesn’t mean that conservatives—even the majority that support same sex marriage and the overwhelming majority that support equal civil rights—trust generally liberal teachers to address these issues with young kids. In particular, to address the facts without getting into a broader discussion of sex, or exposing kids to liberal views of sexuality, non-conformity, or self expression. For example, the significant majority of Americans think that sex between teenagers is not morally acceptable (54-42). Do the teachers who want to teach these facts believe that? Will they use materials that depict sexual interactions between teenagers—as in many of the books that have become controversial recently? Conservatives—and many moderates, given the Florida law has strong public support—view this as a “tip of the iceberg” situation.
- scarface74 5y agoWouldn’t “liberal” teachers be teaching kids about it’s okay to choose the gender of your partner, it’s okay not to conform to what other people say “should be” your sexuality , and it’s okay to express yourself however you like? Isn’t the entire idea behind “libertarianism” that you can do whatever the hell you want to do as long as it doesn’t affect others? Shouldn’t Libertarianism be more concerned about teaching that you should conform to the standards of a religious institution? > For example, the significant majority of Americans think that sex between teenagers is not morally acceptable (54-42). Do the teachers who want to teach these facts believe that? Will they use materials that depict sexual interactions between teenagers (as in many of the books that have become controversial recently)? Yes because “abstinence education” has shown to be really effective. I’m sure if teachers have all of their students take “abstinence pledges” it’s going to stop them from having sex just like the “Just Say No” campaigns stopped teenagers from smoking weed.
- rayiner 5y ago> Wouldn’t “liberal” teachers be teaching kids about it’s okay to choose the gender of your partner, it’s okay not to conform to what other people say “should be” your sexuality , and it’s okay to express yourself however you like? I can’t help but notice how you’ve framed this in terms of “choice” and “self expression.” Do you see why even parents who want their kids to learn to be accepting of these biologically-determined differences might be wary of how the message will be delivered in practice? > Isn’t the entire idea behind “libertarianism” that you can do whatever the hell you want to do as long as it doesn’t affect others? That applies to adults, who are fully developed persons. But the moral socialization of your own children—dependent humans with underdeveloped brains—is within the ambit of what the State shouldn’t mess with. Aversion to social engineering is a key distinction between liberals and libertarians on this front. > Shouldn’t Libertarianism be more concerned about teaching that you should conform to the standards of a religious institution? You’re not allowed to teach that in public schools either. And libertarians should be concerned about the State trying to socialize children in the opposite ideology too. > Yes because “abstinence education” has shown to be really effective. I’m sure if teachers have all of their students take “abstinence pledges” it’s going to stop them from having sex Teenagers will draw outside the lines. All the more reason to draw those lines rigidly. And again you confirm what ideologies will come in through the door of these discussions. > just like the “Just Say No” campaigns stopped teenagers from smoking weed. Legalization of weed seems to have resulted in a significant uptick in smoking of marijuana.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]