4 ms·
what? in the history of England, the United Kingdom and the whole Commonwealth there has not been a single instance of a king or queen being anything other tha
by baq 5y ago
what?
in the history of England, the United Kingdom and the whole Commonwealth there has not been a single instance of a king or queen being anything other than - here comes the dreaded word - white.
what's the point of making them black?
coming from Eastern Europe, it's like you made John Paul II black - or any of the patriarchs of Eastern Christian Churches. you can do it, but it's so far offbeat it isn't even funny.
in the US, I guess you could make Lincoln, Washington and Reagan black. they just weren't.
- PascLeRasc 5y agoIt's a modern reimagining of the regency environment. If you pay attention you'll notice that most of the soundtrack are covers of pop songs.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> in the history of England, the United Kingdom and the whole Commonwealth there has not been a single instance of a king or queen being anything other than - here comes the dreaded word - white. This is, in fact, (while completely beside the point) wrong. There are several non-white Kings and Queens in the history of the Commonwealth; e.g., Mswati III of the Kingdom of Eswatini. > what's the point of making them black? What's the point of alternate history and historically-inspired fantasy? That's a kind of big question. Do you literally think every film or show should simply depict life literally exactly how it actually occurred at some time in the past? > in the US, I guess you could make Lincoln, Washington and Reagan black. Or make Lincoln a vampire hunter. (Of course, there isn't a long history of rumors that Lincoln actually was a vampire hunter taking as their starting point a too-literal reading of contemporary descriptions probably meant as throw-away insults.) The complaints about Bridgerton seem to be highly-selective blindness to the entire concept that overtly fictional entertainment is typically something other than an exact recreation of history. (And/or assertion that race is somehow a uniquely unacceptable thing to fictionalize for unspecified reasons.)
- MrMan 5y agoOr that terrible woke Hamilton play