4 ms·
The poison pill was intended to prevent a takeover without the board’s approval (buying 51% on the open market) The board is negotiating an approved takeover w
by colechristensen 5y ago
The poison pill was intended to prevent a takeover without the board’s approval (buying 51% on the open market)
The board is negotiating an approved takeover which is entirely different
I.e. the board was saying “you can only buy Twitter if we say so”
There was no reversal of intentions
- jszymborski 5y agoDoes anyone know if the terms were made more favourable to Twitter since the adoption of the Poison Pill?
- warning26 5y agoThe key change was that funding is now secured; the initial bid was contingent on securing funding.
- delecti 5y agoI think that, as far as the public is aware, there weren't terms prior to the adoption of the poison pill. Musk bought a bunch of shares, and was looking to buy more. The poison pill was the board preemptively saying "we see what you're doing, and you have to go through us to accomplish it".
- dahfizz 5y agoThis is not true. The poison pill was in response to Musk's original offer. > Twitter adopted a limited duration shareholder rights plan, often called a “poison pill,” a day after billionaire Elon Musk offered to buy the company for $43 billion, the company announced Friday. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/15/twitter-board-adopts-poison-pill-after-musks-43-billion-offer-to-buy-company.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/15/twitter-board-adopts-poison-...
- csa 5y agoAccording to Matt Levine’s column today, the poison pill may have just been a tactical move to guarantee time for negotiations while preventing the possibility of a hostile takeover (a potential BATNA for Musk). This seems to be what happened.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe price is the same. Matt Levine's coverage so far has implied that the effect of the poison pill was to force Musk to be more concrete and less hypothetical, which happened.
- qiskit 5y agoThis is simply wrong. The board outright rejected musk's offer and instituted a poison pill to prevent a hostile takeover of twitter by musk. So elon simply bypassed the board of directors and went to the major shareholders. It is the major shareholders who has final say, not the board of directors. Elon convinced enough of the major shareholders to accept his deal and once that happened, the board of directors has no real say. They have to do what the major shareholders say since the major shareholders are the ones who hire and fire the board of directors. > I.e. the board was saying “you can only buy Twitter if we say so” The board say "you can't buy twitter". So elon just talked to the board's bosses ( major shareholders ) and the board's bosses said "elon can buy twitter".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jalonso510 5y agoThis is not correct. The board negotiated a deal with Elon after putting the poison pill into effect. If Elon had made a deal directly with the stockholders, that would have triggered the poison pill. He surely spoke with and lobbied the stockholders for support, but the deal he agreed to was approved by the board.
- bigiain 5y ago> but the deal he agreed to was approved by the board. Yeah, probably as qiskit suggested, because the major shareholders told the board to pull their heads in and take the money.
- dundarious 5y agoGiven the context of this discussion is a question about why the poison pill didn’t prevent this bid from succeeding, I think it doesn’t matter whether the board accepted because of negotiations with Musk (willingly) or because of shareholder pressure (through gritted teeth). The point is, the board approved the deal so the poison pill didn’t trigger. If they rejected the deal, the poison pill would still be a factor. At least that’s my understanding.