3 ms·
Easy—you recognize that there is no fundamental distinction, for purposes of government, between belief systems that are based on asserted moral axioms, whether
by rayiner 5y ago
Easy—you recognize that there is no fundamental distinction, for purposes of government, between belief systems that are based on asserted moral axioms, whether or not they’re traditionally classified as “religion.”
To use abortion as an archetypal example: a fetus’s right to life is traditionally coded as “religious” and a woman’s right to autonomy is traditionally coded as “secular” but they’re both just assertions in competing belief systems. Neither of those things are scientific truths that will turn up in an autopsy—much less any conclusions you draw about how to strike a balance between the two. Thus there is no necessarily libertarian take on abortion. In a free society that recognizes that morality may be the basis for law, there is no real way to keep the government out of abortion; only to ensure that competing moral views are reconciled democratically: https://reason.com/2015/08/14/sorry-rand-paul-haters-pro-life-libertar https://reason.com/2015/08/14/sorry-rand-paul-haters-pro-lif....
Likewise many contemporary conservative debates have to do with what public schools (the State) teach kids against the wishes of parents. These teachings, for the most part, are not scientific truths like evolution or climate change, but rather unfalsifiable moral assertions. The true libertarian solution here would be something like school vouchers, but taking public schools as a given, it’s wholly consistent for libertarians to side with religious parents against State schools that want to teach their kids a particular moral framework.
Conservatives and libertarians are different. But it’s 2022, and the alignment of contemporary conservative political causes is different than in 1992.
- treeman79 5y agoWell said
- nybble41 5y ago> Thus there is no necessarily libertarian take on abortion. This does not follow. There are various ways to approach a libertarian position on the morality of abortion per se which don't devolve into "striking a balance" between conflicting rights (a decidedly non-libertarian concept; natural rights are all negative rights, which do not conflict), but in the end it doesn't matter because there is only one entity involved with both the ability and the standing to justly apply either defensive or retributive force in response to a threatened or actual infringement of their rights, and that is the woman having the abortion. Anyone else using violence to either stop the abortion or punish the woman for having it would be in violation of the Non-Aggression Principle, as they are neither directly harmed by it nor acting with the informed consent of, and under the direction of, any party who was harmed. > The true libertarian solution here would be something like school vouchers… The "true libertarian solution" here would be private schools, with 100% private funding. Though of course anything that allows for more choice in where students can receive their education and what they are allowed to learn represents a step in the right direction, all else being equal.
- akavi 5y agoAs someone who is strongly pro-choice, this strikes me as begging the question. > There is only one entity involved with both the ability and the standing to justly apply either defensive or retributive force in response to a threatened or actual infringement of their rights Presumably your stance here is that the fetus does not have the ability to apply defensive or retributive force, and therefore has no right to it. This seems to suggest you hold a "might makes right" morality: If someone isn't able to defend themselves, then they have no right to. Taken to its logical end, wouldn't this imply that any murder would not be immoral, since if someone was not able to defend themself from murder, then there is no violation of the Non-Aggression Principle?
- nybble41 5y ago> Presumably your stance here is that the fetus does not have the ability to apply defensive or retributive force, and therefore has no right to it. No, that "therefore" does not follow. One does not lose a right just because one lacks the power to exercise it. The fetus would not be wrong to employ violence to resist any attempt to kill it—though even putting it in those terms presumes a degree of conscious decision-making and self-ownership which is not in evidence. > Taken to its logical end, wouldn't this imply that any murder would not be immoral…? No. To begin with, I never said that abortion wasn't immoral or a violation of the Non-Aggression Principle. Both of those are debatable; from a libertarian point of view the answer to the latter question hinges on whether the fetus can claim self-ownership, which presumes a degree of conscious control and responsibility for the effect of one's actions on others. That is all quite abstract, however, because in practical terms it would be a violation of the NAP for anyone else to intervene. An adult, or even a young child, who found themselves harmed or threatened with harm could consent to allow someone else to fight on their behalf; or, just as importantly, could withhold that consent. (For example, they could be a pacifist and believe that fighting back would be immoral.) In the case of a murder one could look to a will or the like as evidence of the victim's wishes. For an abortion, however, there is no such evidence. Anyone responding to it with force is doing so entirely on their own, and not in self-defense, which makes them the aggressor.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago
- scarface74 5y agoI purposefully left abortion out off the list because I agree with you, the entire idea of when life begins is a moral stance and everyone believes in the “right for someone not to take someone’s else’s life”. It’s just a matter of how you define “life”. I can argue both sides. But every position I argued in my original post is about giving the government less power over people that objectively doesn’t affect someone else.
- scarface74 5y agoWhat Conservatives are against school’s teaching is that gay people exist and they want to teach the “Lost Cause” version of the Civil War among other things. The version of the history of the founding of the US is very much a sugar coated version of what actually happened.
- _-david-_ 5y agoThere are no conservative teachers who teach gay people do not exist. There are very few conservative teachers who teach the Lost Cause version of the civil war. There are some debates within the historical community so it isn't really fully settled though. Many in the North were talking about the federal government trampling state's rights and they weren't talking about slavery so it isn't quite as simple as you make it out to be. I assume you are talking about slavery when it comes to your last point? If that is the case there are no conservative teachers denying slavery happening in the US including the fact that some of the founding fathers had slaves.
- scarface74 5y agoI’m more referring to how the history taught in class about the initial settlement of Europeans to America glosses over all of the atrocities that were committed. As far as the “Lost Cause” not being taught.., https://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/story/news/education/2020/12/03/southern-history-textbooks-long-history-deception/6327359002/ https://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/story/news/education/20...
- xyzzyz 5y agoThe article you’re linking in fact says they the Lost Cause is not being taught. It is talking how it was being taught 40+ years ago.
- rayiner 5y ago> they want to teach the “Lost Cause” version of the Civil War among other things Are we in 1992 or 2022? Because I learned the "real history" of the civil war growing up in Virginia in the early 1990s back when it was solidly Republican. It takes immense willful blindness not to acknowledge that the opposition to "CRT" in schools arose at the same time as school districts began paying folks like Ibram Kendi to come lecture to teachers: https://www.fox5dc.com/news/fairfax-county-schools-defending-20k-presentation-from-anti-racism-scholar https://www.fox5dc.com/news/fairfax-county-schools-defending.... If you're a parent whose school sent them a reading list including Kendi, who writes in his latest book: > The only remedy to racist discrimination is antiracist discrimination. The only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination. The only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination. Maybe, just maybe, you might have objections that while not supporting "Lost Cause" narratives of the Civil War?