8 ms·
How can you be “libertarian” - ie keep government out of people’s lives and a modern day “conservative” that is all about pushing religious beliefs on people an
by scarface74 5y ago
How can you be “libertarian” - ie keep government out of people’s lives and a modern day “conservative” that is all about pushing religious beliefs on people and supporting corrupt law enforcement?
But he is not so “Libertarian” that he refuses to accept government subsidies.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> a modern day “conservative” that is all about pushing religious beliefs on people and supporting corrupt law enforcement There's no point saying this in a real discussion.
- 650REDHAIR 5y agoCan you highlight the part that isn’t true?
- scarface74 5y agoHow many “conservatives” would be in favor of giving police less power, stopping the war on drugs, legalizing weed, letting individual schools decide what to teach, letting individual cities decide not to allow religious institutions in areas zoned for residential properties (they increase traffic), getting rid of tax exemptions for religious institutions, etc? Those are all “Libertarian stances”.
- robertlagrant 5y agoIsn't the tax exemption for separation of church and state reasons? Remove them and religion will require political representation? (Source: vague memory of something from the West Wing.)
- nybble41 5y agoIf that was the intent then it isn't working very well. If anything, legal equality between religious organizations and similar secular organizations, whether for-profit or non-profit, would entail decreasing the influence of the former on politics. Personally I'd make the opposite change (everyone should be exempt) but religious organizations shouldn't get special treatment just because they're religious. The practice of having special rules which only come into play when religion is involved undermines the separation of church and state; it means that the state is discriminating between citizens on the basis of the presence of absence of a (recognized) religion.
- rayiner 5y agoExemptions for religious organizations are typically just part of a larger framework of exemptions for a wide variety of non-profit, civic activities: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/501 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/501 > Corporations, and any community chest, fund, or foundation, organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, testing for public safety, literary, or educational purposes, or to foster national or international amateur sports competition (but only if no part of its activities involve the provision of athletic facilities or equipment), or for the prevention of cruelty to children or animals Religious organizations are exempt from tax, but so are PETA and the ACLU. Against that background, efforts to strip tax exemptions from churches are a deliberate attack on religious organizations as compared to other civic organizations.
- nybble41 5y agoThe fact that "religious … purposes" are sufficient in and of themselves to claim tax-exempt status is part of the bias in favor of religious organizations. Yes, secular organizations can also be tax-exempt—but they have to earn it, and not all secular organizations will qualify (even ones without a profit motive), whereas churches automatically receive tax-exempt status. Stripping them of that status is practically unheard of so long as they avoid directly campaigning for or against specific political candidates. There are plenty of other areas where the government shows favoritism toward religious organizations besides 501(c)3 status. For example, ministers are exempt from federal income tax withholding, despite being classified as W-2 employees, and can opt out of Social Security taxes via Form 4361, which is available only to "An ordained, commissioned, or licensed minister of a church; A member of a religious order who has not taken a vow of poverty; or A Christian Science practitioner."[0] (That last one is oddly specific… and goes so far as to endorse a specific religious organization.) Membership in a "health care sharing ministry" also offers, or did offer while it was still in force, an exception to the individual insurance mandate under the Affordable Care Act (26 U.S. Code § 5000A(d)(2), "Religious Exemptions"[1]). [0] https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-4361 https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-4361 [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5000A https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5000A
- s1artibartfast 5y agono, because churches are considered non-profit entities and non-profit entities are tax exempt. Your local chess club could take advantage of basically all the advantages your local church does. There are some historical nuances about power dynamics and avoiding conflict between the church and state, but that is all long ago.
- the_only_law 5y agoThe ones that are willing to become Paraiahs.
- robertlagrant 5y agoI could, but this really isn't the place for it. Please just imagine that the constant emotional conditioning you have experienced from one-sided news and opinion pieces may not be the best way to understand half of the country.
- rayiner 5y agoLet's stipulate off the bat that many conservative causes are religious in nature: if you want schools to teach intelligent design instead of evolution, that falls within the scope of "imposing religious beliefs on people." But it's 2022, not 1992, and a lot of contemporary conservative causes are based on coding conservative positions as being based on "religious beliefs" and liberal positions as being based on some sort of "rational morality." But that distinction is fictitious. For example, liberals decry Mississippi's 15-week abortion ban as "imposing religious beliefs." So why do highly secular countries like France and Denmark draw the line at 13 or 14 weeks? In reality, the abortion debate rests on competing moral ideologies--one that emphasizes the importance of reproduction, and one that emphasizes the importance of individual choice. Neither position is based primarily on scientific facts or rigorous logic. Likewise, when it comes to teaching kids about sex and gender. "God created man and woman and told them to reproduce" is a religious gloss on the factual observation that humanity comprises two sexes which reproduce sexually, and any sustainable human population requires each woman on average to have 2.1 children. Any conclusions you want to draw on top of that are moral judgments, not based on science or logic. It's no different when it comes to law enforcement. Unless you're an anarcho-libertarian, you recognize that the state has a role in defending individual rights. Moreover, any system of law enforcement is going to produce problems and false positives at scale--especially when dealing with people at the margin of culpability. Leaving aside second-order effects for a moment, there is nothing inherently libertarian about asserting that we should err on the side of less aggressive policing to reduce the false positives, at the cost of allowing more wrong-doers to escape punishment. Likewise, there is nothing inherently libertarian about saying that destroying private property in riots is a justified reaction to police misconduct. These are all liberal moral judgments. None of this is to say that liberals are wrong about any of these things. It's okay to formulate positions based on moral ideology rather than logic. My point is simply that you can't stake out a bunch of positions based on moral ideology, while claiming the high ground of secular rationalism and attacking your political opponents as "imposing religion."
- scarface74 5y agoThe entire idea behind the Constitution is “innocent until proven guilty”. Not “you’re automatically going to be assumed to be guilty because you don’t look like you belong in the neighborhood.” Why does it always seem like the people who are on the “margin of culpability” always minorities? Like when Ving Rhames was suspiciously sitting in his own house (https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/28/ving-rhames-police-gunpoint-home https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/28/ving-rhames-...) There are plenty of statistics showing minorities are stopped at a higher rate, convicted more harshly, face higher bail, etc for the same crime when you control for everything else. So if you should only marry to reproduce, does that mean old people shouldn’t get married? Should we stop people who take steps not to reproduce? Conservatives use to fight to outlaw birth control and it is still the stance of many. None of these are “Libertarian” stances.
- kemiller 5y agoHe is openly pro-sensible-regulation in all of the industries he's a part of. If he's a libertarian he's certainly not our normal caricature of one.
- scarface74 5y agoAs long as the “pro sensible” regulation is about subsidizing his companies.
- kemiller 5y agoNo, he's been on the record admiring NASA and the FAA, even auto regulators, and has called for regulation of AI.
- nybble41 5y agoRegulation favors incumbents, and SpaceX and Tesla are the incumbents when it comes to private spaceflight and electric vehicles. Companies call for regulation on their own industries in order to influence the shapes of those regulations to their own advantage and put up barriers to future competition.
- scarface74 5y agoOf course he “admires NASA” that pours money into SpaceX.
- sfe22 5y agoYou can be libertarian and accept government subsidies. It’s not like he could have kept the recent $11B if he did not accept the subsidies. If he believes in libertarianism and would pick freedom over oppression given the choice, then he is a libertarian. He was given no choice.
- scarface74 5y agoLibertarianism is about letting the free market decide and the government not putting its thumb on one industries over the other.
- sfe22 5y agoGood definition. But we are not a free market country, so you gotta play by the current rules.
- rayiner 5y agoEasy—you recognize that there is no fundamental distinction, for purposes of government, between belief systems that are based on asserted moral axioms, whether or not they’re traditionally classified as “religion.” To use abortion as an archetypal example: a fetus’s right to life is traditionally coded as “religious” and a woman’s right to autonomy is traditionally coded as “secular” but they’re both just assertions in competing belief systems. Neither of those things are scientific truths that will turn up in an autopsy—much less any conclusions you draw about how to strike a balance between the two. Thus there is no necessarily libertarian take on abortion. In a free society that recognizes that morality may be the basis for law, there is no real way to keep the government out of abortion; only to ensure that competing moral views are reconciled democratically: https://reason.com/2015/08/14/sorry-rand-paul-haters-pro-life-libertar https://reason.com/2015/08/14/sorry-rand-paul-haters-pro-lif.... Likewise many contemporary conservative debates have to do with what public schools (the State) teach kids against the wishes of parents. These teachings, for the most part, are not scientific truths like evolution or climate change, but rather unfalsifiable moral assertions. The true libertarian solution here would be something like school vouchers, but taking public schools as a given, it’s wholly consistent for libertarians to side with religious parents against State schools that want to teach their kids a particular moral framework. Conservatives and libertarians are different. But it’s 2022, and the alignment of contemporary conservative political causes is different than in 1992.
- treeman79 5y agoWell said
- nybble41 5y ago> Thus there is no necessarily libertarian take on abortion. This does not follow. There are various ways to approach a libertarian position on the morality of abortion per se which don't devolve into "striking a balance" between conflicting rights (a decidedly non-libertarian concept; natural rights are all negative rights, which do not conflict), but in the end it doesn't matter because there is only one entity involved with both the ability and the standing to justly apply either defensive or retributive force in response to a threatened or actual infringement of their rights, and that is the woman having the abortion. Anyone else using violence to either stop the abortion or punish the woman for having it would be in violation of the Non-Aggression Principle, as they are neither directly harmed by it nor acting with the informed consent of, and under the direction of, any party who was harmed. > The true libertarian solution here would be something like school vouchers… The "true libertarian solution" here would be private schools, with 100% private funding. Though of course anything that allows for more choice in where students can receive their education and what they are allowed to learn represents a step in the right direction, all else being equal.
- the_only_law 5y ago> How can you be “libertarian” - ie keep government out of people’s lives and a modern day “conservative” that is all about pushing religious beliefs on people and supporting corrupt law enforcement? I’ve had this idea that many people who talk about libertarianism, but particularly in the US those who vocalize their alignment with the Libertarian Party are just republicans who don’t want to admit it. The famous “libertarian” Thiel going mask off and then helping build the surveillance state and military industrial context convinced me.
- dragonwriter 5y ago“Libertarians” are for limiting power of government institutions outside of protecting capitalist property rights. “Conservatives” are for maintaining the power of status quo elites (in most modern developed economies, that means capitalist elites), generally by marshalling traditional/religious justifications. These views fit together...rather well, actually.