5 ms·
if and only if you want to use twitter to discuss politics I'm noticing A) twitter users that interest me and don't discuss politics are usually pretty great
by colechristensen 5y ago
if and only if you want to use twitter to discuss politics
I'm noticing
A) twitter users that interest me and don't discuss politics are usually pretty great
B) I generally don't want to read anybody's political opinions on Twitter or most places... people who want to talk about politics mostly seem to be in to fighting a culture war, there might be people who aren't but I don't see them and it isn't the platform's fault or a moderation issue
- throwaway894345 5y ago> twitter users that interest me and don't discuss politics are usually pretty great It seems to be falling out of fashion, but a few years ago a lot of prominent Silicon Valley technologists started intermingling overtly racist and otherwise hateful political Tweets among their otherwise interesting and insightful tech Tweets. I think Twitter and other ideologically-aligned media radicalized them, which is to say that avoiding political accounts is a fine thing except (1) sometimes Twitter turns accounts political and (2) avoiding accounts that Tweet about politics at all is swimming against the current and (3) it sucks to have the all-or-nothing choice between following/not-following an account (rather than being able to follow interesting tech Tweets but uninteresting political Tweets, for example).
- colechristensen 5y agoI guess I don't think a person owes me a politics-free experience, if they say things I don't like then I don't like what they say and don't want to follow them. No amount of moderation is going to stop people from expressing themselves in ways I don't like and I don't really blame the platform for people turning toxic, it's on the people themselves.
- throwaway894345 5y agoNo one is arguing that they owe you a politics free experience, but one obvious solution is to allow people to have “channels” so I can subscribe to your tech opinions or your politics opinions distinctly. There are lots of other things that moderation could improve, like not centering the most toxic versions of each viewpoint.
- snikeris 5y ago> a few years ago a lot of prominent Silicon Valley technologists started intermingling overtly racist and otherwise hateful political Tweets among their otherwise interesting and insightful tech Tweets. Example?
- ralusek 5y agoIt will be something like "I don't think California should repeal civil rights legislation in order to allow overt hiring on the basis of race and gender." "I think we should perhaps reconsider our non-enforcement of property crimes due to the fact that nobody can park on the street, the stores across from me are boarded up, and two pharmacies in my relatively affluent neighborhood just closed due to theft." "I didn't find it appropriate for the protestors to tear down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant or rename a school from Abraham Lincoln." "I don't think it should be part of the school curriculum to be talking to preschoolers about gender and sexuality." "Asians are disproportionally denied access to schools and employment due to arbitrary ethic and racial targets." Other such hateful things.
- nullc 5y agoI don't think the sarcastic response really contributes to the discussion. There is enough toxicity on twitter that if someone digs hard enough they could find examples that aren't twitter-political-bubble-strawmen.
- switchbak 5y agoI disagree. I find their examples a good collection of the kind of viewpoints that get caught in the crossfire and disallowed when content moderation goes too far. To be clear: there is often a lot of gray area and some middle ground to be taken in complex debates. When one side (eg: far-right American trollish behaviour) goes too hard in to the paint, the (over?) reaction by the opposing side(s) often loses perspective and it's the more reasonable opinions in the middle that get squashed in the well meaning attempts to supress troll like extremist influence. I think the above post highlights exactly these kind of opinions that get steamrolled away, even though many of them are within the realm of sensible debate.
- data-ottawa 5y ago(4) discussing politics can be very transient. Things happen that bring politics to you, it’s not simply an opt-in discussion. These things need to be discussed, but it’s best left for the people with their skin in it to discuss.
- mjhagen 5y agoThe Internet has always been a terrible place to discuss politics and Twitter is even worse because of the short format.