3 ms·
I think there's a lot of people who view homeownership as an investment strategy but that has never been the case it is a lifestyle. Investing in real estate i
by elmerfud 5y ago
I think there's a lot of people who view homeownership as an investment strategy but that has never been the case it is a lifestyle. Investing in real estate is an investment strategy but that's separate from homeownership. Even moderate market investments have risen at a pace that meets or exceeds the growth that we've seen in home prices.
The one benefit that homeownership does provide as far as an investing strategy is that it inadvertently locks you into this investment in a way that other investments don't. If you were to measure renting versus owning and taking the difference in cost and applying it to investments renting is a much more attractive option over the long term. There is a definite sacrifice in lifestyle because owning a home provides a big lifestyle benefit that a lot of people want. The real problem with renting versus owning as far as investment goes people in general especially the lower middle class and below who are sold on this idea of home ownership as an investment are poor at investing over the long term. So when they rent they tend to spend most of the rest of their disposable income instead of putting a portion of it away in a long-term investment. The ownership of the house automatically causes them to have a long-term investment that they can realize in 10 or 20 years.
So while I agree with the author that real estate will not continue to rise at the pace that it's risen in the past percent gain is not really the measure of an investment or a capital asset like this. What I do believe will continue to take place with real estate is that as an inflation in adjusted investment vehicle it will continue to maintain pace. So that does mean that home ownership real estate will continue to maintain pace and grow as an investment compared to inflation. And over the long term homeownership as an investment vehicle does not tend to outpace inflation except in very limited jumps.
The key to any real investment is finding one that will outpace inflation by a decent margin that is the only way to see growth. That is possible to do with investment in real estate but very difficult to do with home ownership.
- TimPC 5y agoHow is investment in real estate going to outpace inflation when it comes up against the income barrier? I’d argue we are going to see that it won’t. The future isn’t like the past and when real estate gets too expensive for even the wealthier members of the working class to afford we are going to see stagnation or extremely limited growth. A large portion of the real estate market is homeownership and having that slice of the market disappear would have extreme downward pressure on prices.
- elmerfud 5y agoBecause you're confusing home ownership and real estate investing. Real estate investment is investing in rental properties of some form or fashion and this can be for business rentals it can be personal rentals any number of things. Because that form of investment does not rely on the buying and selling of the property to realize the gain in the investment.
- TimPC 5y agoYou still have a problem with people affording rent if you are buying rental properties at 128x average income. Rent is going to be an inconsequential portion of the interest on the mortgage if someone making average income or even 3x average income has to afford it.
- warrenm 5y agoHome ownership is not an investment - because you "have" to have a place to live, it's just a cost of living somewhere It might happen to grow in value during your stay, but the home you live in is not an investment: it's just a house