4 ms·
> Every time they get close, he does something in the media that raises the stock price by 200% This is not really the case at all. Why are you just making stu
by panick21_ 5y ago
> Every time they get close, he does something in the media that raises the stock price by 200%
This is not really the case at all. Why are you just making stuff up?
Go look at between 2016 and 2018, by far the closest Tesla came to bankruptcy then at any time sine 2008.
So I'm looking at that data and there is no magical 200% stock price raise based on media.
What actually happened it Tesla managed to execute and bring a mass market vehicle market successfully.
> like with the absurd touchscreen console
Man somebody should have told the 1.5 million vehicles they will sell this year for 30% magin how stupid that is.
> no-LIDAR self-driving
That's why you can now anywhere in the US can jump on a self-driving LIDAR tax and buy a LIDAR self-driving car at your local dealer.
> and the "lights-off" factory idea
And now Tesla has some of the most advanced factories in the car industry where literally the CEO of VW said that VW was not able to produce vehicles as fast. What an idiot he is ...
> Musk is an amazing marketer and he deserves credit for that, but not for engineering work.
That is literally the opposite impression you get when you actually investigate anything other then twitter opinion.
Pretty much everybody who got to spend any time at Tesla or SpaceX comes away with the opposite impression. Musk literally spends the waste majority of his time in detailed engineering review meetings.
Tesla had a gigantic amount of negative press, more then any other company I can think of. But Musk made the company successful with marketing?
What are you even talking about, what marketing? His twitter account and a TED interview or something every could of months? The viewer numbers on those things are far to low to explain Tesla value.
- hef19898 5y ago>> where literally the CEO of VW said that VW was not able to produce vehicles as fast Source for that? And not the drone footage of one of Tesla's factories please. >> Tesla had a gigantic amount of negative press But this is still press, isn't it? And it is Musk that gets the negative press, not Tesla.
- InTheArena 5y agohttps://www.motorbiscuit.com/tesla-electric-vehicle-10-hours-volkswagen-production-ceo-unable-keep/ https://www.motorbiscuit.com/tesla-electric-vehicle-10-hours... A lot of people are spouting short-seller crap from 2018. I suggest that they honestly look at where tesla is now, not when they last paid attention.
- hef19898 5y agoFrom the article: At the nearby Gruenheide factory outside of Berlin, Tesla is currently trucking along and set to achieve the goal of making an electric vehicle in under 10 hours. At this time, Volkswagen’s main Zwickau plant requires 30 hours per vehicle. Diess hopes to reduce that to 20 hours per vehicle by next year. Conclusion: Neither Tesla nor VW are producing EVs in ten hours. And Zwickau is not a dedicated EV plant and needs rebuilding to become one. Interesting that we only get concrete numbers from VW, so. I have to admit, it is funny to see VW, which was the most marketing dependent car maker I know up until Tesla showed up, and Tesla to slug it out in a PR and marketing war! EDIT: Zwickau wasn't a EV plant until 2020.
- panick21_ 5y agoEven if you want to make the most pessimistic possible attitude. Tesla went from a company who had never manufactures anything in large quantity, 5 years later they are seriously comparing to VW a company that has been a globally dominate automaker for decades. So look at Tesla in 2017 and say 'Musk is an idiot he thinks he can automate production' and then look at how Tesla produces cars in 2022 and tell me he is an idiot.
- hef19898 5y agoMusk still is an idiot when it comes to car manufacturing. Why? Because he gives a fuck about first pass yield and those things. Plus, Tesla is still almost a factor 10 away from production volumes of VW, Toyota and the like. From publicly available footage, a Tesla factory looks not any more impressive, even less so from commentary that knows much about automotive manufacturing than I do, than state of the art factories from legacy coomoanues. Tesla and SpaceX are impressive feats, I don't get the urge to pass Tesla and Musk as all encompassing geniusus that know everything better than encumbents.
- InTheArena 5y agoFord is on track to deliver 1.6 million cars this year. Tesla is doing 300k a quarter with two factories and about to open two more factories. Volkswagen is targeting 2.4 million this year. Consensus from the street (not provided by Tesla) is that Tesla will deliver around 1.5 million as it works through the Germany and Texas ramp up. You may want to true up your perceptions.
- FireBeyond 5y agoHe did say that, but see my sister comment. It was actually a disparaging remark about Tesla QC, and how even VW's plans to improve their line productivity would still see their vehicles spend twice as long as a Tesla on the line (but hey, you would at least feel pretty confident your car would be delivered with four brake pads, so that's a bonus).
- hef19898 5y agoFour brake pads? Sounds like something from the options list.
- FireBeyond 5y ago"Dinosaurs nickel and dime you for everything!"
- pclmulqdq 5y agoLook at the events that saved Tesla: - 2016 - model 3 preorders with no backing except a drawing. - 2018 - cybertruck, semi, and full-self-driving preorders with one single prototype of the vehicles. - And after each one of these, there is a huge bump in stock price. 200% is hyperbole. These are feats of marketing, not feats of engineering. A CEO spending a lot of time in detailed engineering reviews doesn't make you an engineer, it means you enjoy doing detailed engineering reviews. It is undeniable that Tesla is successful in large part because of the cult of personality that Musk has built, largely on Twitter. That has bought his company the good grace to do preorders with ridiculous turnaround times and to lose money year over year on the stock market while keeping an astronomical valuation. The rest of Tesla-the actual car making thing-is something that an organization of several thousand engineers could have certainly done without Elon Musk given the amount of cash they had, and probably could have done better without Elon Musk. They just needed Elon Musk to raise the cash. He is exactly like Steve Jobs: a briliant marketer with a cult of personality, who people think of as an "inventor" because he likes to spend time doing that.
- sixQuarks 5y agoVery common mistake to assume he is exactly like Steve Jobs. Jobs was not technical, he had great design awareness and marketing skills. Musk is an engineer at heart AND a great marketer.
- panick21_ 5y ago> - And after each one of these, there is a huge bump in stock price. 200% is hyperbole. Its not hyperbool is literally just false. The stock price in 2018 was essentially flat. The stock price in 2016 is flat. You made an argument about 200% and at best its like a few %, meaning your argument is total nonsense. Literally made up with nothing to back it up. And even if the stock went up a bit based on announcement, that doesn't even remotely prove that that stock raised 'saved' the company. > These are feats of marketing, not feats of engineering. No what are actually feats of engineering, and actually had impact on the stock price is when Tesla from 2017 to 2018 made the first EV that was produced over 5000 times a weak and had significantly possessive margin. And when they turned a mud field in China in to a working factory in about a year. That is when the stock ACTUALLY started to go up. When Tesla proved they could produce cars at very high volume and good margin. So you are just flat out factually wrong on this and I don't know why you are trying to hold on to your take. The data is right their anybody can look up the data and instantly know that you are wrong about this. > It is undeniable that Tesla is successful in large part because of the cult of personality that Musk has built, largely on Twitter. That is just total nonsense. Tesla successful brought the first modern Li-Ion EV to market before Musk was famous. Even when the Model S came out Musk was not very well known. Actually releasing the Model S successfully and getting car of the year is part of why Musk did get more famous. So Tesla already had like 5 years of growth before Musk got all that well known. Also, you vastly overrated, twitter, far fewer user, use it then you might think. People were attacked to Tesla because they made actual real EV that you could buy, that had a charging network. Tesla had a message about EV saving the environment and that message reached 100x wider then Musk twitter. People don't spend 50k+ on items because of a guy on twitter. > That has bought his company the good grace to do preorders with ridiculous turnaround times and to lose money year over year on the stock market while keeping an astronomical valuation. Well turns out they very actually undervalued not overvalued. And they didn't actually lose that much money, and didn't raise that much money. They showed they were profitable with the Model S and they were a sustainable company. Then they went into Model 3 and everybody knew this was capital intensive and they guided for loses for a few years. Do yourself a favor and compare how much money Tesla raised and what their evaluation is compared to companies that are in this space now, Rivian, Lucid and so on. Tesla actually operated handled their cash very well and did a lot with not that much money. > The rest of Tesla-the actual car making thing-is something that an organization of several thousand engineers could have certainly done without Elon Musk given the amount of cash they had, and probably could have done better without Elon Musk. They just needed Elon Musk to raise the cash. And who heirs the engineers? Who defines strategy? Who decides what people should have leadership positions and so on. Tesla was not a company with 1000s of engineers when Tesla became CEO, its was a company about to go bust who had not delivered a single car. This is HN, building a company from tiny to gigantic is a huge achievement that doesn't just 'happen'. There were Tesla competitors many had just as much or more cash then Tesla, but they failed. Why? I thought if company just had money they would magically start mass produce cars. > He is exactly like Steve Jobs: a briliant marketer with a cult of personality, who people think of as an "inventor" because he likes to spend time doing that. That you think they are the same just proves that you have not really been paying attention beyond surface level. They are very different in their approach. And with both its not actually marketing.
- FireBeyond 5y ago> where literally the CEO of VW said that VW was not able to produce vehicles as fast Musk's RDF in full effect here. That quotation was about quality control - and Tesla's relatively abysmal QC compared to other production lines. VW's CEO said that an average VW took nearly 30 hours to come off the line, versus approximately 10 for Tesla. He also said that they're targetting 20 hours in the next decade. Huh. They're not even trying to beat Tesla, there. Wonder why? Maybe it's so they don't deliver cars with mismatched tires, leaking sunroofs, _missing brakepads_, and so on. I think it's hilarious that people like you believe with a straight face that a $250B/year production line hasn't fired up a spreadsheet and done the numbers on costs of "implement another line, so we can spend more time on each car and push more out in parallel" (VAG manufactured 8.4M vehicles in 2021 versus 900K for TMC), than "hey, if we just cut some more corners, and deal with things after the fact, it'll be cheaper".
- panick21_ 5y agoSo what? If they target 20 or 10h doesn't matter. The fundamental point is that they clearly outperform VW there their CEO admits it and they are doing major investments to catch up. And the claim that you need 10h for quality control is utterly ridiculous. The reason they likely are not targeting a lower number is because their production centers are far more distrusted and they don't have full vertical integration from battery cells to cars in one building. There are other possible explanation. You can't just assert whatever you want without any evidence at all. If VW has a higher quality standard then Tesla (questionable) then that fine. That literally changes nothing about my argument about production argument. And Tesla quality issues have been far less in Shanghai were they have faster production then in Fremont. We have yet to see if Berlin will have production issues. And outside of VW or whatever. Its unquestionable that Tesla made major gains in manufcaturing that is a competitive advantage. So the claim that Musk is dumb because he wanted to increase automation or simply wrong. The idea that they cut 20h of production by 'cutting corners' is just a delusional take. Sorry. If that was possible do you think GM would not have done that in the 2000s. Do you think Nissan wouldn't have done it? Tesla first attempt at that automation was wrong, but they adjusted and actually did make real innovations. Denying that is just making you look silly and uninformed.