6 ms·
The Mysteries of Lisp (2015)
- fallat 5y agoGod damn I love Arxiv. Ever since I started using miniflux, I have a stream of open papers that comes right to me. It's like being on the bleeding edge of human knowledge.
- celeritascelery 5y agoIs there an Arxiv RSS feed or something that you subscribe to?
- Jtsummers 5y agohttps://arxiv.org/help/rss https://arxiv.org/help/rss - Talks about the feeds and how to get to specific categories or subject areas within categories.
- arbitrandomuser 5y agoWhat is miniflux ? miniflux arxiv didn't return anything about a application,
- Jtsummers 5y agohttps://miniflux.app/ https://miniflux.app/ It’s an rss reader.
- netfortius 5y agoMy odd "entry" into this space, way before robotics (in a later second round of college), was via AutoLISP (the reduced use for AutoCAD). Lost touch with such for over 25+ years, but it was very fun at the time (a time when my other most used programming language was TurboPASCAL :-))
- Gollapalli 5y agoHas the author confused M-Expressions and F-Expressions or am I misreading this?
- Jtsummers 5y agoSee footnote 6 on page 4: > ‘F-expression’ [McCarthy 1959, p. 13] was the original name of M-expressions (for Meta- expressions) [McCarthy 1960, p. 187]. We choose the old name for two reasons: (1) meta is relative, the name M-expression becomes misleading once F-expressions are taken to the level of object language; (2) the term F-expression clearly indicates that functional [expressions] describe functions of S-expressions, which McCarthy called S-functions [1959, p. 1]. Nevertheless, in directly quoted text, we will keep the terms used in the source. [edited to remove hyphenated words]
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 5y agoF-expressions are functions taking unevaluated arguments, sort of a mixture of a macro and a function. It executes at runtime, whereas a macro executes at compile time(technically macro-expansion time). They were abandoned in mainstream LISP early on. However, John Shutt ironed out some of the issues with fexprs in his PhD thesis, which is a good read if you're interested in lisp internals[1]. He also designed a scheme like lisp dialect incorporating fexprs, called Kernel. [1]: https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-090110-124904/ https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-090110-124904/
- kazinator 5y agoThe F-expressions in this paper are not the same thing as FEXPRs. This was an internal, implementation terminology. Early Lisp has EXPR and SUBR routines: SUBR were written in machine language, and EXPR were interpreted functions. So EXPR doesn't mean "expression", but "function made of expressions that require code walking evaluation, rather than a straight machine-code subroutine ("SUBR") that can be called. The F prefix denoted functions that implemented special forms. That may be where the F comes from: FEXPR and FSUBR. These F variants receive the unevaluated forms. So COND might be implemented as a FSUBR, which interprets it: walks the cond pairs, evaluates the test expressions, and so on. Whereas CAR and CDR would be SUBRS (no "F").
- ktpsns 5y agoThis is a nice piece on "computer archeology". Given the academic nature of language design (I don't want to say "functional programing" or "LISP" here), it is obvious why it was written in the form of a scientific paper. If this was about the language C, I guess this would have been a blog post! Note how ArXiV can be used for blogging: This paper is not peer reviewed but "only" uploaded to ArXiV. The site has some credibility barrieres which require invitation, but otherwise anybody can upload. I find this nice, but you should keep in mind this is just some academic variant of blogger.com ;-)
- gjvc 5y ago2015 in the title, 2018 in the linked .pdf file at https://arxiv.org/pdf/1505.07375.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1505.07375.pdf If you're going to be OCD about dates, please have them correct.
- vindarel 5y agoDisclaimer: if you read the following, mysteries will disappear O_o - how to get started? https://lispcookbook.github.io/cl-cookbook/getting-started.html https://lispcookbook.github.io/cl-cookbook/getting-started.h... - is this mystery used in production©? quick look: https://lisp-journey.gitlab.io/who/ https://lisp-journey.gitlab.io/who/ - is this mystery used by people for today's needs? https://github.com/CodyReichert/awesome-cl https://github.com/CodyReichert/awesome-cl
- ngcc_hk 5y agoNot very interesting. Paip, lisp 1 game a time, even lisp in vim is more interesting. Or the paper about the beginning of lisp.