3 ms·
Weird that 'elite' has become a right-wing term recently. Is that a good thing? Have reactionary forces lost control of the elites after centuries? Are they no
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Weird that 'elite' has become a right-wing term recently.
Is that a good thing? Have reactionary forces lost control of the elites after centuries? Are they now at least having to pretend they care about data rather than raw power? That meritocracy wasn't working after all?
Or is this just the latest variation on "the Jews who claim to want democracy and human rights are really going to eat your children" and it doesn't really need to be internally consistent?
- dontlaugh 5y agoI think definitely a variation of the latter. The bourgeoisie have their own disagreements and factions, which show up more clearly during periods of crisis.
- thriftwy 5y ago[flagged]
- mnd999 5y agoI would define it as “someone I disagree with and I would like you to disagree with too because they are not like us”. Essentially another approach to trying to create division and tribalism in discourse where it suits the person using it to do so.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIn this specific case, the argument seems to be we should disagree with them because they are too like us (US educated UN Ambassadors), and that the whole concept of human rights is cultural imperialism. Which is one of many recent right-wing stances I’d applaud as very 'woke' and sophisticated takes on complex issues if I didn't think they were just lying about caring about it in order to justify something horrible they do actually want to do.
- zozbot234 5y agoAre you saying that the UN has come up with a novel "human right" to having dysfunctional families around? I wasn't aware of that, but it makes a lot of sense now! The UN itself is certainly dysfunctional enough.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe UN Human Rights Charter explicitly includes the right to marriage and the fair treatment of people entering, during and at the breakup of marriage.
- gruez 5y ago> I would define it as “someone I disagree with and I would like you to disagree with too because they are not like us”. Yeah but if you disagreed with appalachian coal miners, you wouldn't call them "elite".
- mnd999 5y agoWould it matter if I did? It’s essentially meaningless. There’s not really any logic involved.
- krapp 5y ago>Or is this just the latest variation on "the Jews who claim to want democracy and human rights are really going to eat your children" and it doesn't really need to be internally consistent? Yes. There is a direct line of inference in right-wing dialogue between "The Elites" -> "The Liberals" -> "The Leftists" -> "The Democratic Party" -> "The Socialists" -> "The Marxists" -> "The Cultural Marxists" -> "The Globalists" -> "The Bankers" -> "The Jews." There are no right-wing elites in their parlance, because by definition all elites are part of the above framework.
- hef19898 5y agoI never thought I would see this framework in real life myself, but there it is again... I hoped that line of thought died in the mid 40s...
- jfengel 5y agoIt's just projection. Anybody else's prominent people are "elite". Your own prominent people are just fine and only have your best interest at heart. And yeah, for a lot of people that means Jews. There's a reason we've seen actual literal Nazis supporting the right. They know exactly what "elite" means to them.
- danaris 5y ago> Have reactionary forces lost control of the elites after centuries? Not at all. They've discovered that by casting their enemies as "elites", even though they themselves still control a lot of the actual elites, it's easier for them to get support among the disaffected lower classes they're actively oppressing.