3 ms·
> If there's no data, you're just "lost in math" and not doing productive work. I don't think that's her position, from what I've seen in many other videos. Sh
by tsimionescu 5y ago
> If there's no data, you're just "lost in math" and not doing productive work.
I don't think that's her position, from what I've seen in many other videos. She is a theoretical physicist, after all, not an experimentalist.
I think her position can better be summed up as "if there is no data, and no realistic possibility of getting data, then you're just 'lost in the math' and not doing productive work".
Of course, "realistic" here is both subjective and a matter of degrees, but at least it means it should be a consideration you decide for yourself before investigating a field.
Additionally, I think, though I haven't necessarily seen her be explicit about this, that she would only apply this test to working on new theories, not to exploring the consequences of already-tested theories. Of course, even if I am right that she would make this distinction, the line between "new theories" and "exploring the boundaries of existing theories" can be pretty thin and subjective in places as well.