3 ms·
It would be good to make a Joel Test for employment contracts. I don't really know why most employment contracts are not from a standard source anyway: we will
by robertlagrant 5y ago
It would be good to make a Joel Test for employment contracts.
I don't really know why most employment contracts are not from a standard source anyway: we will pay you this much, this often, for this many hours' work during that period. You don't take or destroy our equipment or represent us badly in public. When you leave you give us our equipment back, and don't solicit our employees for 6 months after. You get a bonus on these terms, and share options on these terms. Only things you make at work OR using our equipment belongs to us.
- bruce511 5y agoThe problem with this approach are the edge cases. Over a couple hundred years there have been lots of those, now taught about enthusiastically in law school. Every time there's an unfavorable edge case to (any) employer, then another clause gets added to the "standard contract". So with reusable contracts (like employee contracts) you end up with very asymmetric goals, and a very asymmetric contract. Yes, push back is important, and it's valuable to the company to hear that push-back. Speaking as an employer, I would not be prejudiced against an employee questioning or rejecting terms in the contract. Some changes might be deal-breakers, some might not. But clearly we can negotiate and assuming we don't find any mutual deal breakers we'll both be happy. I would personally also see this as a positive, not negative, interaction with an employee, not something for them to fear. But of course, being new, they don't know that, and I understand the asymmetry of power in this situation.
- saagarjha 5y ago> don't solicit our employees for 6 months after This is unenforceable in California.
- robertlagrant 5y agoSure :) But I'd rather have a standard contract that's modulated by local employment law than a bespoke contract that's modulated by local employment law. Or have optional blocks included or not (that makes a Joel Test for contracts almost self-documenting).