3 ms·
> What's a good storage medium where I can keep and load again in the future? USB flash? HDD? SSD? > must keep for at least 3 decades Most storage mediums wo
by smoldesu 5y ago
> What's a good storage medium where I can keep and load again in the future?
USB flash? HDD? SSD?
> must keep for at least 3 decades
Most storage mediums won't have problems lasting that long if they're stored well. Particularly flash and SSD storage shouldn't take issue: tape and HDD has a small chance of mechanical failure even if you don't use them.
> must be easily transportable (for moves between houses and such) and can sit on a shelf
I mean, I think most of our current formats do just fine in that regard.
> Bonus points for suggestions on an equally stable storage type that some computer will still be able to understand in the future.
Almost everyone is still using SATA. There is unlikely to be a world in the future that is unable to "understand" serial ATA storage.
- wmf 5y agoAn IDE or SCSI hard disk from 1992 would technically be easily accessible using adapters but mechanically it probably wouldn't spin up. Removable storage from that era like magneto-optical or SyQuest would require a rare and very obsolete drive that may also have mechanical problems. I expect similar problems looking forward. Hard disks made today aren't rated for 30 years, NAND flash retention is much less than 30 years, and Blu-ray drives may be hard to find.
- a9h74j 5y ago> NAND flash retention is much less than 30 years Hard failures aside, I assume very slow charge decay might be somewhat mitigated by periodically copying files flash-to-same-flash (let alone another) -- or perhaps even rewriting them in place.
- willis936 5y agoHonestly the best answer is to this question is one that requires more effort than "burn once, sit on shelf". The best answer is "host a NAS that you actively maintain and has an offsite mirror". I personally host an all-flash NAS for the performance and MTTF benefits over HDD. Since it's always on and performs regular scrubs there is no concern of bit-rot. The data I put there will be there as long as I'm around to take care of the box and pay the B2 bill.
- daviddever23box 5y agoThis is ultimately the best option - checksummed in-flight data has a higher likelihood of being verified at both read-source and write-drain endpoints. That said - I'm at a loss to understand what software is ultimately worth using without modification after 30y....
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> I'm at a loss to understand what software is ultimately worth using without modification after 30y I wrote a video game for my child’s birthday. Does that count?
- RonaldOlzheim 5y ago(I wrote a video game for my child’s birthday. Does that count?) For your child 100% so if that´s the goal why not? Modification is a big word. Old cars can still be valueble in capital and make you feel much more alive then a brand new car.
- don-code 5y agoI had an experience a few years ago, retrieving old data from SyQuest drives. I was unsuccessful getting even a single bit recovered: several drives and several disks ultimately produced zero overlap in readability.
- technothrasher 5y ago> but mechanically it probably wouldn't spin up might not spin up. I recently booted a Sun 3/80 from 1990 and while the battery backed RAM that told it how to boot was long dead, the HD was not a problem at all. Once I replaced and re-coded the RAM, the machine booted right up. And this isn't just a one off story. I've got a bunch of machines from that era, and the HDs are not usually an issue (although occasionally they are).
- _tom_ 5y agoI recently tried to boot and read a number of drives from 10 to 40(?) years old. (Pandemic. Was bored). About half of them still spun up and were readable. Probably could have gotten more with heroic measures. Most 3.5 floppies were likewise readable.
- BackBlast 5y ago>> must keep for at least 3 decades > Most storage mediums won't have problems lasting that long if they're stored well. Particularly flash and SSD storage shouldn't take issue: tape and HDD has a small chance of mechanical failure even if you don't use them. I think you're overstating the durability of these systems. I saved most every HDD I've used dating back to the early 90s. I wanted to get rid of the box of drives, so I got an adapter and tried to see what I could salvage from them before throwing them out. Ages varied from about 8 to 28 years. None of the ancient drives (>15 years) worked. I could usually hear them spin up, but I couldn't get anything off them. Several had the dreaded click of death present. I got some of the newer (<12 year old drives) to work. Even the newer 8 year old drives had really high failure rates. They were all working when I pull them out of service. My old USB flash drives have also had high failure rates for me. From my experience, expecting an HDD that isn't in use, to go for more than ~5 years totally idle is asking to lose the data on it. The data might still technically be there, but the mechanical+electrical system that makes up an HDD does not have high longevity. To the original question. I actually just researched this topic extensively to make purchases for my back up systems and my conclusion is: If I really want data to go 30+ years. I'm using archive grade Blu-ray discs (M-disc and LTH). I burn multiple of the data I want, and I store them in dark places at separate locations.
- hedora 5y agoFlash is a terrible idea. NAND cells are basically little capacitors, and they leak electrons over time. Current TLC drives actually rewrite themselves every month or so to keep read error rates low. If you leave them unplugged, they can't do that. If you must use flash, keep it cool. We have some deer cameras in direct sunlight. After six months or so, the SD cards become unmountable due to media read errors.