2 ms·
We seem to be reading different lawsuits. Here's the ABQ Journal again in 2018, describing an earlier phase of the legal process that was (almost certainly) set
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
We seem to be reading different lawsuits. Here's the ABQ Journal again in 2018, describing an earlier phase of the legal process that was (almost certainly) settled in 2021:
https://www.abqjournal.com/1186369/state-appealing-navajo-water-rights-ruling-although-it-favors-the-result.html https://www.abqjournal.com/1186369/state-appealing-navajo-wa...
> State government recently got a big legal victory when the New Mexico Court of Appeals upheld a landmark water rights settlement with the Navajo Nation.
[ ... ] Although the “result” of the April appeals court decision authored by Judge Pro Tem Bruce Black was correctly in favor of settlement, Black’s opinion held incorrectly that water in the San Juan River through New Mexico “is ultimately subject” to federal government control and “denies the State’s jurisdiction over its own waters,” says the petition filed Friday at the high court.
From the 2021 article that you cited:
> The New Mexico Supreme Court recently decided to let stand a Court of Appeals decision that the Engineer’s Office says would rob the state of its ability to regulate water rights in New Mexico.
Here's you, just now:
> Sir, the settlement is what was overturned. The thing that we're discussing is a judgment, not a settlement.
I do not see to square the reporting in the ABQ Journal with your claim that the settlement was overturned.
Do you have some links to the suit you're saying was brought by the Navajo Nation? I have been unable to find anything about such a suit. The only one I can see is the suit against the federal government regarding access to water from the Colorado
https://www.knau.org/knau-and-arizona-news/2021-04-29/navajo-nation-wins-court-victory-over-access-to-colorado-river-water https://www.knau.org/knau-and-arizona-news/2021-04-29/navajo...
Note the paragraph at the end of the piece also:
> It’s the second recent court victory for Navajo Nation water rights. Last month, all challenges were dropped from a settlement over the tribe’s access to the San Juan River.
which, like the ABQ Journal pieces, suggests that the settlement was upheld, and the challenges to the settlement were denied.
Separately, if you literally meant this:
> every single source of water to New Mexico flows through the land of either The Nuntzi, the Navajo, the Goshutes, the Shoshone, the Shivwits, or the Koosharem.
then I'd appreciate gaining an understanding of which of the tribal nations you've named, or any that you haven't named, lay claim to the source or basin of the Pecos. In my research on this, I couldn't see any sign of those tribes holding claims on that land. The same question would apply to the other rivers that flow out of the Sangre de Cristo. If any native people had a claim to that, I would expect it to be some/all of the Puebloans.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoEven with it spelled out in your own quote, you can't admit the mistake This is not good faith and I have no interest in arguing with your most recent use of a search engine If you had no web browser you wouldn't be able to write a word about this You haven't read the articles about the lawsuit, much less the lawsuit itself No understanding is coming for you, because you'll just argue with it then ask for more until someone gives up, so that you can feel like you were right all along The quotation literally verbatim agrees with what I said about your error, word for word, and you're still pushing
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI asked you for a single reference to the lawsuit you're referring to. It seems that's too much for you. My quote from the ABQ Journal said "upheld a landmark water rights settlement with the Navajo Nation". You said "Sir, the settlement is what was overturned". Then you avoid explaining this by claiming bad faith. Having now read a good chunk of your comment history on HN, I think it's time to bow out of any attempt to discuss this with you. A persistent failure to provide citations, frequent bad-faith style of discussion, hand-waving assertion-from-self-invented authority seem common. That said, if there actually is a lawuit by the Navajo Nation that overturns the settlement reached with NM, I would actually like to know more about it.