5 ms·
> I think you would find few people in the art community who agree with this. I happen to know some successful artists (you'd recognize their names), and they
by WalterBright 5y ago
> I think you would find few people in the art community who agree with this.
I happen to know some successful artists (you'd recognize their names), and they are very much in it for the big bucks.
You will find many who say they are in it for the purity, but their actions belie it.
BTW, your ideal society has a name, it's called a "commune". Communes have been tried over and over in history. Something like 10,000 have been set up in the US. The result? 100% failure.
One hundred percent.
You don't have to believe me. It's perfectly legal to set up a commune in the US. Set one up with your like-minded friends. Throw your hat in the ring. Prove me wrong.
AFAIK, 0% of them have produced any art anyone considered great.
- kaba0 5y agoA commune in isolation can not protect itself. Another more aggressive group will overtake them given time. That's why I don't believe that end-goal communism or anarchism could ever work (where the former is contrary to many people's idea, is about small communes, not some Big Government). But with a necessarily strong government it is absolutely not impossible to scale a small commune to a whole country. Pair it with the best kind of democracy (as that is an entirely different axis) we have and I also on the opinion that many of today's problems could be solved. But even in today's capitalist system UBI could be implemented relatively easily paid for by tax money.
- WalterBright 5y agoA commune in isolation can not protect itself. The US ones did not fail because some more aggressive group overtook them. They failed because they did not work and eventually the members tired of it and left. The state-sponsored kibbutzen in Israel also fail, because they can't exist without massive government subsidy. Communism has been tried many times on a nation scale. 100% failure. Your ideas are not new and they have been tried, again and again. They just don't work. They don't work on a small scale, they don't work on a large scale. They don't work when voluntary, they don't work by force. There is just something about communism that is fundamentally anti-ethical to human nature.
- kaba0 5y agoDid you even get my point that communism is different from socialism? I very much stated exactly that communism (in my opinion can’t work either). But socialism as a spectrum of ideas has plenty of working aspects included in basically every Western democracy.
- WalterBright 5y agoSocialism produces mediocre works, and can't compete with free market operations. This is why socialist operations tend to be heavily subsidized or they simply make free market competitors illegal. It's most obvious when agriculture is socialized, because it's impossible for people to believe the lie that they aren't starving. Yes, I know that communism is supposed to be without a government.
- kaba0 5y agoFree market is not inherently incompatible with socialism. Hell, free market only works properly (according to its very creator, Adam Smith) when it is confined to a well-regulated market. The only entity capable of creating such a market is the government itself. Also, don’t forget that plenty of areas simply don’t operate on a supply-demand basis — e.g. healthcare.
- WalterBright 5y agoSocialism isn't defined in terms of a "well-regulated market". Socialism is when the government provides goods and services. > don’t forget that plenty of areas simply don’t operate on a supply-demand basis — e.g. healthcare Supply-demand is in play even under socialism. But here's a simple example. Take your corner drugstore. It has a couple aisles of all sorts of healthcare products, from aspirin to toothbrushes to athlete's foot cream to cold remedies. There are multiple brands with multiple formulations at various price points. How does supply & demand not apply there? More generally, pick any health care issue. For each, there are a multiple of options available, with varying costs, efficacies, risks, and pain. Including doing nothing (by far most diseases disappear on their own). How is that not supply & demand?
- revolvingocelot 5y agoWhat a repulsive argumentative style. >>>I also expect that making money is a prime motivator for artists, and also drives the quality of their work. is a much less hostile claim than >I happen to know some successful artists (you'd recognize their names), and they are very much in it for the big bucks. which could have been made in the initial comment, but then parent wouldn't be able to Other the grandparent for the heretical belief that people can work together at scale. The parent simply knows better. Even when the grandparent cites what Sikh society verifiably does, which is simply a cultural reorganization of existing resources, not a remodel of the human heart, and certainly within the power of much richer European and North American societies as they now stand, let alone what at-scale automation could provide -- it's never addressed because that's ackshually a commune. Which, as the astute reader will learn by reading further, doesn't work, 100% of the time. In fact, they're "anti-ethical". [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31148652 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31148652
- WalterBright 5y agoI didn't argue that people cannot work together at scale. My argument, admittedly heavyhanded, is that organizing this work based on altruism does not work. It may work here and there, for a period of time, but it is not sustainable. Organizations that work are ones where people are paid for the work they do, not ones that pay people regardless of the work they do. By the way, anti-ethical does not mean unethical. It means contrary to, in this case, contrary to human nature. I did not write that communes were anti-ethical. I wrote that they were anti-ethical to human nature, meaning they are contrary to human nature. There's nothing unethical about voluntary communes, but there's plenty unethical about forcible ones.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoThe Sikhs have been doing their thing for 400 years.
- WalterBright 5y agoI presume you mean the Langar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Langar_(Sikhism) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Langar_(Sikhism) As I noted in another post here, while an admirable endeavor, it has not managed to serve free meals to a significant percentage of India's population. There are apparently limits to selfless volunteerism.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoYou seem to have ignored the point where I cited my sources of what I am talking about working successfully in India right now. It’s not a failure in fact it is a major success. Seriously, watch the video is it heart warming! It’s also very real!
- WalterBright 5y agoI did watch the video. It was a little thin on details, but appears to be a charity, run by volunteers, funded by donations. Like a scaled up soup kitchen in America. It's a nice setup, I wish them well with it. I noticed the host did not chip in to wash dishes or make a donation, though he may have off camera. They serve 50,000 meals a day in a country with 1,380,000,000 people. That's a long way to go to demonstrate it will work for society.