3 ms·
> I think that's what a lot of engineers get hung up on. Music is taught as rules. That's not what I see (as the author of a cross-platform DAW for the last 22
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> I think that's what a lot of engineers get hung up on. Music is taught as rules.
That's not what I see (as the author of a cross-platform DAW for the last 22 years).
Engineers get hung up on the fact that despite the reality that almost all western (and, realistically) almost all of the world's musical tradition(s) are in fact rooted in clear rules and numerical relationships, music culture wants to use terminology and practice that pretend that it's not.
The simplest example: the major scale. Like all scales, it's just a pattern of intervals. What intervals? Why is the scale not named after the interval series, which would allow you to see how similar it is to the minor scale, and precisely how it differs (ditto for comparisons between any other scale).
Another example: ordinal naming of scale degrees, "the third" etc. These have no consistent meaning other than when you write out the notes of the scale, you count through them. But the third of a minor scale is a different interval from the root than the third of a major scale. If they were named by interval, you'd have consistent naming no matter what the scale is.
There are dozens more examples like this, where consistency in naming would ease many a musician-engineer's mind.
- dagmx 5y agoI think your argument is conflating music theory rules with consistency and accessibility. I agree that the naming and accessibility could be significantly easier. That's just the nature of language though, and music theory is a language. One that's a cumulation of many cultures. However the rules (in western theory) are very consistent and clear if you've learned your foundations. This is no different than programming too. If you know the circle of fifths, and the WWHWWWH series of modes, there's a very strong consistency. Now if we're arguing about why fifths, and why we name our modes after Greek groups rather than something numerical, that's valid. But it's just like the names of the days of the week. Once you know them, it's just an arbitrary term that you internalize. The rules I'm bemoaning in my post are things like sticking to a fixed time signature or scale, playing perfectly aligned notes. Versus things like polyrhythms and drunk drumming, exploring disharmony or using alternates to octaves.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoyes, I understood what you meant by rules. I just don't come across many people complaining about those "rules of practice". If you've listened to reasonable amount of music, you already know that those rules are made to be broken (once learned, maybe). The problem with the day of the week comparison is that, yes, they are arbitrary and you just learn them and be done with it, but with music the names are just the building blocks for a vocabulary/dialog about a creative process, and so you just don't throw down "play the 5th" the way you might say "it's Wednesday". Instead, that language is interacting with a conceptual process which the language doesn't mirror. If the four components of music are rhythm, timbre, melody and harmony, the last two are all about intervals, and almost none of the music terminology in the west reflects that.
- ohthehugemanate 5y agoTHANK YOU for the difficult work you do working on a DAW. I have enormous respect for your domain, you are "doing god's work" (or noodles' work, or whatever floats your boat) for sure! I think it's a common mistake, especially in classical music, to think about musical traditions as "rooted in clear rules and numerical relationships." It's analogous to thinking that language is rooted in clear rules and structures. The truth is just the reverse, the rules, numbers, and structures are rooted in music. They exist to describe an organic, emergent cultural mechanism that is continuously changing. Ask yourself: which came first, music or theory? Language or grammar? There are plenty of musical styles with no formalized structure or numeric relationships, just as there are plenty of languages with no formalized structure or even spelling. Grammar and music theory/notation are fingers pointing at the moon, and we are looking at the finger. And when we try to engineer systems to help people point at the moon, we should be focused on the finger. Musical structure and numeric relationships are the way people communicate about music, and the tools should speak their language. Unfortunately they have to grapple with the painful inconsistencies in that language and those structures. Computer music comprehension has problems analogous to computer language comprehension - emergent complexity so high it took neural nets to finally achieve real utility. PS - it's true that Western music has, near the bottom, some relationships that were mathematically derived by none other than Pythagoras, among others. Relationships of fourths, fifths, octaves, and equal temperment all had numeric justification... But that justification was still only there to describe the practice which had already become common, an explanation of "why this sounds harmonious" as well as a proscription for "how to sound harmonious". That some rules are internalized by some generations and broken by others illustrates exactly the problem with the system.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThanks for your thanks. However, I disagree quite a lot with what you've written above. Not really as a matter of historiography - yes, of course, I agree that the history of musical cultures is not the same as the history of mathematics. I agree that musical practice is not rooted in an understanding of numerical relationships. I also agree that the higher level elements of musical composition/improvisation/performance are not sensibly described with math. However, one half of what defines music as a sensory experience (melody and harmony, the other half being timbre and rhythm/time) is totally, fundamentally, absolutely embedded in the nature of the intervals between pitches. The intervals we use (regardless of any actual absolute pitch selection) and how we use them seem to me to be almost indisputably rooted in the physics/mathematics of the harmonic series even if the development of the musical practice surrounding intervals had been done in complete ignorance of this. Western musical culture uses a set of terminology and even concepts that obscure the fundamental importance of intervals. The use of scale degrees rather than intervalic terminology means that there is a lack of consistency in naming that isn't necessary (it's really a historical accident), but also a lack of focus on the most important concept for understanding the nature of melody and harmony. I was really impressed to discover last year that Byzantine musical culture doesn't notate pitch, only intervals. Song melodies are remembered and notated as a series of intervals between the pitches, so that you can start from any note and play something that almost every human being alive will recognize as the same melody (they also do not have octave equivalence, but that's a nother story), even though the actual pitches are totally different. Of course, western musicians can do this too, but consider how much more cognitive load there is in understanding the process when you consider a melody to be made up of specific set of pitches, or a specific set of scale degrees, rather than just a set of intervals. > But that justification was still only there to describe the practice which had already become common, an explanation of "why this sounds harmonious" Yes, I agree that the historical ordering is as you describe. We do, however, change our terminology and practice in many other fields as we gain new insight or come to understand better ways of approaching things. I would argue that we could learn from both other musical cultures, and from the numerical/physical understanding of intervals to get to much more rational, consistent terminology and practice when it comes to melody and harmony.