3 ms·
First of all, the state of NM does not lay claim to all the water that falls here. Large parts of the state are federally owned, and other large parts are tribe
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
First of all, the state of NM does not lay claim to all the water that falls here. Large parts of the state are federally owned, and other large parts are tribe owned. As a result, the state only has claim to about 45% of the water that falls from the sky or flows across the land, the rest is already allocated.
The article in the ABQ Journal does not, in fact, state any of the things you've mentioned above. I appreciate that you cited the article, I just think it was poorly written.
What the article describes is this: a Court of Appeals judge said that because Congress was involved in the settlement between (at least) the Navajo and the state of NM, Congress is now in charge of water in NM and not the state (at least, this is one reasonable interpretation of the opinion). The SE Office appealed this on the basis that it contradicts decades of clear precedent. NMSC declined to hear the appeal, which potentially leaves the door to someone (potentially one of the tribes) forcing administrative action that forces Congress into active oversight of water allocation etc.
I said it was poorly written because it lacks sufficient context, uses short out-of-context quotes from the court's opinion, and because it completely fails to explain the relationship between the SE Office/State, the tribes and the US Congress. The article does not describe the settlement reached with the Navajo, for example, it does not describe the general situation with water in the state, it does not describe the context of the settlement.
In addition, I do not believe it is the true to say:
> The entities they are dealing with are soveirgn nations - entirely distinct countries
While the US (and to some extent, the Spanish) did grant significant sovereignty to (some of the) the nations already here during European colonization, the sovereignty of the tribes today is far more complex than is indicated by calling them "entirely distinct countries". Any serious challenge to the authority of the federal government would be harshly dealt with (challenges to state government, not so much). The Navajo and the Hopi utilized the federal government in their attempts to resolve their own disputes over land and access. While I believe that the tribes deserve more autonomy, more power and definitely more water, the actual legal situation is far more complex than the one that exists, for example, between the USA and Mexico or the USA and Canada.
> every single source of water to New Mexico flows through the land of either The Nuntzi, the Navajo, the Goshutes, the Shoshone, the Shivwits, or the Koosharem.
I think (but am not certain) that you're describing inflows to the area of the state. This does not describe the Pecos River, nor the rainfall nor the snow.
In general, I think you might be imagining that I'm not aware of or sympathetic to the tribes' arguments in this matter. Nothing could be further from the truth. I entirely agree with the terms of the settlement, and think it should likely go further.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThis is another example of what I mean by complex sovereignty, from the SFNM today: > Last month, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham signed 10-year intergovernmental agreements with the leaders of two pueblos — Picuris and Pojoaque — but other tribes are still not allowed by the federal government to grow marijuana.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoWhat you may not know is that none of those tribes honor that requirement, much like California for 30 years. There's no "complex soverignity" here. US marijuana law entrenches a great many casually illegal things because nobody's powerful enough to fix them through the DEA budget. Highlights include that marijuana is on the schedule 1 list under two different names, and extacy 3; that marijuana is also on the schedule 2 list, despite that nothing is permitted to be on multiple schedules ever; and that the entire prohibition was never legal in the first place, as it's just Nixon's extension of the illegal tax stamp scheme. You'll have a very hard time convincing anyone with even a passing familiarity with the law that American marijuana laws are a good example of a system working as expected. Also, since you seem to be holding yourself up as a knowledgeable expert, the state level requirement was stricken in 2020, and a pact with the tribes was signed a month and a half ago Not only is your example incorrect; it's also not true anymore
- JohnHaugeland 5y ago> the state of NM does not lay claim to all the water that falls here ... and other large parts are tribe owned. Yes. And when you finish reading the article you keep criticizing, you may learn that these are what the Navajo just successfully sued back from the state, after the state tried to lay claim to them. . > I said it was poorly written because I already told you once that you made me feel bad by trying to say this. I'm not interested. Thanks. . > > In addition, I do not believe it is the true to say: > The entities they are dealing with are soveirgn nations - entirely distinct countries That's nice. It is, though. . > > every single source of water to New Mexico flows through the land of either The Nuntzi, the Navajo, the Goshutes, the Shoshone, the Shivwits, or the Koosharem. > I think (but am not certain) that you're describing inflows to the area of the state. No, I meant the words I said . > I think you might be imagining that I'm not aware of ... the tribes' arguments in this matter. The things you are saying are directly contradictory to a correct understanding of the matter, so I don't believe "imagining" is actually the right word here. I think it's "discovering." . > I entirely agree with the terms of the settlement Sir, the settlement is what was overturned. The thing that we're discussing is a judgment, not a settlement. This is like someone suing someone for breach of contract, and in attempting to support them, saying "I agree with the contract." If you support the settlement, that's saying New Mexico is right, and the water should continue to be taken. It's very difficult to take legal discussions seriously with someone when they misuse basic concepts.