7 ms·
I apologize if this just comes off as "jaded old man", but I have gotten warier as I've gotten older of the real harms of first world countries dumping all this
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I apologize if this just comes off as "jaded old man", but I have gotten warier as I've gotten older of the real harms of first world countries dumping all this "aid" on the third world and calling it charity. It's not hard to see how tons of free food, 2nd hand clothing, and even things like recycled soap could undercut any native producers in these third world countries, making them perpetually dependent on aid.
- dotancohen 5y agoThat dependency was a large part of Nestle's strategy in providing baby formulae in Africa. They would supply each new mother with - if I'm not mistaken - one month or three month's worth of formulae. Just enough so that she would stop lactating, but require them to now purchase many month's worth of formulae at prices that they really could not afford.
- alsetmusic 5y agoExcellent podcast ep about it here: https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236323/episode/how-nestle-starved-a-bunch-of-85687280/ https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236...
- mayankkaizen 5y agoHoly shit! I didn't know about that. If true, this is pure evil. Any source for further reading? Edit - never mind. I have just gone through 2 articles and now my blood is boiling.
- jrochkind1 5y agoWhat imperialism and neo-colonialism controlled by european-descended cultures have done to exploit the rest of the world is so terrible that it almost sounds like science fiction, and we in the countries on the taking end mostly manage to avoid knowing about it. It is ongoing.
- wahern 5y agoNestle used the same marketing techniques in every country. In the United States today approx. 70% of babies are fed entirely or partially using formula. If that number surprises you, then maybe that's a hint to check your privilege. Don't forget that one of the major exports of "European cultures"--including European-educated people from elsewhere--is manufactured outrage. Making a buck off of poor people is hardly unique to European culture.
- jrochkind1 5y agoOh no, it's certainly not unique to European culture. The rich of Europe, and of other settler-colonies set up by Europe like the USA, have just been the most successful at it for the past few hundred years, including at extracting profit from most other parts of the planet to the benefit of the European (and European-founded/dominated) parts. phenomenally successful.
- lupire 5y agoCheck my lactation privilege?
- ryan_lane 5y agoIt shouldn't lessen your outrage that Nestle is being horrible everywhere. This is the strangest form of whataboutism I've seen.
- dahfizz 5y agoThe comment being replied to is specifically about "imperialism and neo-colonialism". How nestle acts in different countries, in that context, is not whataboutism.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> If that number surprises you, then maybe that's a hint to check your privilege. Has "check your privilege" become so cliché that it's just spewed out where it doesn't make sense? I'm honestly trying to understand what kind of "privilege" leads to one being unaware of baby formula statistics.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoFWIW there were widespread, decades-long boycotts of Nestle due to their baby formula marketing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Nestl%C3%A9_boycott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Nestl%C3%A9_boycott
- tablespoon 5y ago>>> That dependency was a large part of Nestle's strategy in providing baby formulae in Africa. They would supply each new mother with - if I'm not mistaken - one month or three month's worth of formulae. Just enough so that she would stop lactating, but require them to now purchase many month's worth of formulae at prices that they really could not afford. > FWIW there were widespread, decades-long boycotts of Nestle due to their baby formula marketing: > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Nestl%C3%A9_boycott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Nestl%C3%A9_boycott So this has been known for 50 years? I'd always assumed this was a much more recent controversy. What's the situation with Nestle's marketing now?
- ttfkam 5y agoNot just in Africa. There was a huge ad campaign in the US a few decades ago implying that Enfamil and Similac were healthier options than breast feeding. This was pushed especially hard in economically depressed areas that could least afford it. Not altogether unlike the ad campaigns convincing folks that (free) water with a meal was vaguely wrong. "By they way," they said, "we've got some special brown water with a fukton of added sugar and CO2 for sale instead!"
- rootusrootus 5y ago> This was pushed especially hard in economically depressed areas that could least afford it. An interesting choice for a company trying to maximize profits.
- Cerium 5y agoLikely the campaign was found to be most effective against a less educated population that wants to give their children opportunity they didn't have.
- azemetre 5y agoIt's not hard for these companies to bribe politicians to allow welfare recipients to buy their products through snap/food stamps/ebt by getting exemptions. It's very devious and wrong.
- selcuka 5y agoAlso the most logical choice given that it's a hard sell for wealthy, stay-at-home moms rather than women who need to work and don't have the necessary time to breastfeed.
- anamax 5y agoHmm. W1 uses 1/N of the free formula and sells the remainder to W2-N. Next month, she's still lactating AND has enough money to buy 1/N for N-1 months. Note that the prices in this scheme are independent of Nestle's prices. However, high Nestle prices are a big incentive for someone to be W0.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThat is seriously disgusting. They're sacrificing a baby's health for profit. Do they have no limits?
- golergka 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoBecause they're straight up lying when they say it's better than breast feeding. Encouraging mothers to breast feed is hard enough as it is, we really don't need some idiotic company spending millions in deceptive marketing designed to get them to stop lactating and become dependent on their products. This caliber of sociopathy is unacceptable no matter how they spin it.
- lbrito 5y agoWow, this is Peak HN 2022. Why blame England for the Opium Wars? Couldn't the Chinese just take less opium? Why blame big pharma for the opioid epidemic? Couldn't people not take opioids? Why blame cigarette advertisement for lung cancer? Can't people not smoke?
- dotancohen 5y agoAs someone who stopped smoking in my twenties and has thus far refrained from Whatsapp/Facebook and does not watch superpower movies, really, I don't see why people cannot make the choice. As a collective population, some percentage is in fact expected to make the choice. But why do you explicitly imply that they don't have a choice? Honestly interested, not trolling.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> really, I don't see why people cannot make the choice Because of the millions spent in advertising to induce people to choose what the corporations want. Tobacco ads were banned for a reason.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Also, do not attribute to malice what can be attributed to negligence. I was about to blow the outrage horn but decided to do some reading. After going over the entire wiki, i could not find any single shred of evidence that could even suggest outright malice or worse, criminality, from nestle. I remain open minded, but I'd like to see evidence that justifies the claims. Currently, the accusations seem based on selective facts & theory, used to form a narrative that is questionable at best. However, nowhere in the article did i see any mention of any of the positive effects by nestle donations. Here are some counterfactuals: 1- most men do not realize that women may not produce milk for several days despite lactating nonstop during this time. Newborns in such cases will be inmediately be given formula before jaundice sets in. Nestle probably (unintentionally) saved countless children from death this way. 2- formula and breatsfeeding are not mutually exclusive. The notion that free formula would impair the ability of women to continue breastfeeding is not true, as many dads will attest. 3- Africa life expectancy / health outcomes are poor. In any emergency, you do want to have formula as a fallback option 4- this article presents african women as naive with zero proof. Is there a smoking gun that i missed somewhere?
- zelon88 5y agoOn the other side of the coin then you would have African STEM working on trying to find enough recycled soap. That would probably be problematic because the ratio of supply from hospitality can't touch the backlog of demand caused by poverty. So you provide them the soap and that's one less obstacle standing in their way as they tackle more actionable problems.
- zelon88 5y agoI can't stop thinking about this because on surface it sounds reasonable, but there's something off about the logic. So don't offer aid because it will stop capital investment. But there is no capital to invest because people spend their days trying to stay alive rather than obtaining capital. So the logic is flawed. You want to promote investment in a place with nothing to invest by not investing in that place. But furthermore, you want to do it in the name of fairness. You want to give Africa the same market opportunity that exists in America. That logic is also flawed, because there is no opportunity in Africa. So you're just letting companies with preexisting status hoarde all the opportunity.
- jrochkind1 5y agoYou can offer aid/investment in a different way that builds up local capacity instead of dependence. Which isn't always easy or straightforward, but the first step is the intention. It will often be less beneficial for the fortunes of the "developed world" based institutions behind the philanthropy though, which is why the unconsidered default is often in the other direction (even without actual malicious intent which sometimes exists too), and it takes extra intention and commitment and willingness to sacrifice some self-interest.
- easytiger 5y ago> So the logic is flawed. You want to promote investment in a place with nothing to invest by not investing in that place. Why do you think they don't have anything to invest?
- zelon88 5y agoBecause the concept of capital was already created elsewhere in the world and now they have to obtain something that they never had to begin with. How do you compete with something you didn't know existed until it showed up on your beaches and started stealing people?
- easytiger 5y agoI'm not sure it is possible to have a more flawed understanding of capitalism or Africa than this. Have you ever even been to an African country?
- mrmattyboy 5y agoSo what about something like: * US charity that recycles US-hotel used soap * The recycled soap is resold in US as a charitable item * Profits from recycled soap sales are used to help fund/grow 3rd world soap manufacturers, or to help them lower the cost to make it, or subsidise the cost to more available to citizens of their country I see your point and, I know it seems a little roundabout, but could this solve the issue?
- jrochkind1 5y agoI think it would be worth a try!
- DocTomoe 5y agoDepends on whether you want the people to have soap, or their local strongman to have a soap-money-financed golden AK47.
- mr_beans 5y agoIf it brings the price of gold AK47s down for average Americans I’ll take option 2
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kiliantics 5y agoYeah, it would be better if instead the first world countries stopped destabilising governments and stealing natural resources in the third world. They might have a decent chance at developing independently then.
- interpenetrate 5y agoBingo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Europe_Underdeveloped_Africa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Europe_Underdeveloped_Afri...
- chrischen 5y agoThe worst is that a country like China does regular business with them (for better or for worse) and we (US) criticize them for political reasons with no regard to whether it's good for Africa or not, just whether it's good for us (politically that is—to criticize Chinese influence/power).
- woodruffw 5y agoI think it's more complicated than that: a country can't become self-sufficient in the long term if the majority of its population either flees or starves to death in the aftermath of an ecological disaster. You need foreign food and medical aid in that sort of situation, because your domestic capacity can't possibly grow to fit the needs. Similarly for little things like soap: they're essential for basic health, but economically they fall into the "discretionary purchases" bucket. If the people being supplied by this nonprofit don't have the discretionary income to purchase locally-manufactured soap in the first place, then you're not curtailing any amount of domestic industry by providing it to them for free. Counterintuitively, you're promoting long-term domestic economic security by ensuring that more children make it to productive adulthood. (All of this not to say that things like clothes donation's can't hurt the recipient's economy, which they certainly can. But I don't think that cynicism is warranted in this case.)
- naravara 5y agoIndeed. It is wildly counterproductive over the long term. The things we dump on them are largely things they’re well able to make for themselves. If we wanted to dump stuff that would have real, long term impacts we’d be sending cutting edge technology or capital goods that enable more development, like solar panels or biogas setups. Shipping free, cheap commodity products that they could just as easily have jobs making themselves just means fewer jobs producing those commodities.