2 ms·
It still seems like a moment of temporary stability though, especially as their social structure starts to stress from the old:worker ratio going from >5 to <2.
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
It still seems like a moment of temporary stability though, especially as their social structure starts to stress from the old:worker ratio going from >5 to <2.
I.e. unless they accept 30% immigration over the next 50 years, the system will be extremely stressed and may fracture.
- gumby 5y ago> unless they accept 30% immigration over the next 50 years, the system will be extremely stressed and may fracture. There’s no reason to expect that not to happen. Countries like Germany already been have a higher immigration rate than the US, and once had a much higher rate when they needed workers post war. European political decision making is primarily bullshit muddle and and absurd “compromise” yet in the end is surprisingly pragmatic. Unfortunately for the US it’s become high conflict rather than vapid muddle, which makes it harder for people to move their positions.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAbout 19% of the US is immigrant compared to like 17% in Germany, so they are fairly similar. Can they bring the rest of Europe along though? It’s a huge challenge…
- gumby 5y agoAccording to the UN, in 2019 Germany had 15.7% foreign born and USA 15.4%. And the AfD notwithstanding, Germany has the pragmatic Gastarbeiter precedent. The larger precedent, for all cultures, is that idealistic views (immigrants good! Immigrants bad!) fade dramatically and rapidly when pragmatic issues emerge.