5 ms·
It’s interesting to read these (plausible, far from absurd) analyses from the Anglosphere when we have an alternative to compare, to whit the northern European
by gumby 5y ago
It’s interesting to read these (plausible, far from absurd) analyses from the Anglosphere when we have an alternative to compare, to whit the northern European democracies where marriage is in steep decline across all social classes yet the societies are more successful (at least if your metrics are things like poverty rates, lifetimes, nutrition, stress, etc).
- nottorp 5y agoUS thinkers have no idea what a social safety net is so they draw their conclusions without taking that option into account.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago"US thinkers" is a ridiculously broad term. There are plenty of Americans who think and know what a social safety net is. Some of them know about it because they read, some because they think, some because they've travelled, some because they've lived in countries with a stronger social safety net than the USA. What is true in the USA is that there are people who know what a social safety net is and are adamant that we should not have one, and who are willing to get much closer to actually say that than most of their equivalents in Europe (though this has been changing a bit in recent years).
- Ensorceled 5y ago> "US thinkers" is a ridiculously broad term. It's a pretty good generalization, however. I see it over and over again in US political discussions a total, and possibly (probably?) deliberate, blindness to the idea that health card could be socialized, UI and welfare could be better, access to education could be universal and things like job training or maternity leave could exist, etc.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThen you're not connecting with the US "left" (probably not a coincidence). The Nation is both the oldest continuously published weekly magazine in the US (founded in 1865) and consistently represents different parts of the US left. Jacobin is another good example. It is true that if you watch network or cable TV from the US, you will not find the actual left represented, other than perhaps Bernie Sanders. What they will call "the left" is mostly centrist Democrats whose position can be summarized as "things as basically OK but we need to be nicer in a few specific ways".
- nottorp 5y ago> Then you're not connecting with the US "left" (probably not a coincidence). I doubt the US left knows what left is :)
- Ensorceled 5y ago> Then you're not connecting with the US "left" (probably not a coincidence). Interesting assumption. I'm far to the left of most Canadians, let alone Americans. > It is true that if you watch network or cable TV from the US, you will not find the actual left represented, other than perhaps Bernie Sanders. That was my point, albeit poorly expressed; very few actual leftist thinkers get any kind of mainstream exposure so all "US thinkers" are right of centre unless you specifically go looking for the left leaning ones.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIf you had said "US people", I'd have agreed with you (at least to a greater extent". But I took "US thinkers" to be a subset of "US people", differentiated by ... well, thinking :) This is not meant to be patronizing - a lot of people just don't think much about politics, policy, philosophy, ethics, for whatever reason. However if someone is in that subset that does, the chances are much better that they are aware of left-ish ideas.
- refurb 5y agoIt’s also fun seeing US thinkers explain what life is like in Europe but clearly never lived there and are actually wrong about a lot of it.
- Ensorceled 5y agoI've always found it interesting that Americans who could literally see Canadian flags across the St. Lawrence River or live in border states such as Minnesota or Michigan, have such bizarre views on the quality of Canadian health care and other social services.
- vinay427 5y agoI don’t find it fun. It’s about as fun as seeing “European thinkers” do the same about the US, as someone who has lived in both regions, although one direction is perhaps more vocal than the other. Whether it’s a positive or negative misconception, I find it more frustrating than amusing when one’s confidence is mismatched with the quality or reliability of information (i.e. ignorance).
- dasudasu 5y agoTo think that the US has no social safety is also a common trope. Food stamps, medicaid, public & section 8 housing, SSDI, EI, etc. in combination with the unique opportunities allowed by American society to get back on your feet (low unemployment and barrier to entry). Americans in general have no idea how "humble" life can be for the European lower classes. Fun fact: Canada and the US have about the same homelessness rates on a per capita basis.
- nottorp 5y ago> Americans in general have no idea how "humble" life can be for the European lower classes. Don't think said lower classes live in fear of a "major health event".
- dasudasu 5y agoMy understanding is that the poorest people are covered by medicare or get their fees waved (hospitals won't refuse to treat someone needing critical care). That is not "zero social net". Nobody is in fact jealous of the American healthcare system though. Meanwhile, in most countries in Europe, people live in fear of having to be put on wait lists that extend from months to years, or just plain being unable to access any care at all due to said systems being overloaded at times due to having much less overall slack (for example during covid).
- gumby 5y agoWaitlists can be visibly bad in the UK but if you read German or French papers you’ll see complaints about “wait lists” that seem laughable by US standards. I live in SV so can afford a level of health care well above the usual middle class. Yet I have a literal A/B test: my kid broke his arm in Germany and also in the US and the ordinary treatment he got In Germany was significantly superior to that at Stanford Hospital — ant at a fraction of the cost.
- nottorp 5y agoYou know, there's an interesting point here. Did you get travel health insurance for DE? Did you even think of getting it? I always get that for holidays, it costs peanuts. Sometimes you don't even have to pay upfront if you use it, sometimes the treatment gets refunded.
- endisneigh 5y agoCurious to see the source showing European democracies are more successful, controlling for socioeconomic status.
- karpierz 5y agoWhat does it mean to be "successful, controlling for socioeconomic status"? Their success is defined by their peoples' socioeconomic status.
- endisneigh 5y agoIf that's the case then the USA is superior to all but a few European democracies per capita and all of them nominally? Even Massachusetts would be superior than every European country per capita.
- gumby 5y agoI don’t understand: are you talking about PPP GDP per capita? I agree that the US optimizes for that, but it doesn’t translate into higher quality of life by metrics like life expectancy, literacy, leisure time, malnutrition, proportion of “precariat” etc.
- endisneigh 5y agoYes, hence my original question.
- karpierz 5y agoIf you define socioeconomic status narrowly (gender, race, age, net wealth), then I was wrong to say that the success of European countries is rooted in their socioeconomic status. I'm happy to take that point back, and focus on why I don't think controlling for socioeconomic status is the right analysis. However, even if the US shows better outcomes when controlling for socioeconomic status, the distribution of people within socioeconomic status is relevant. If the US has 1000 impoverished people and 10 middle class people, and Germany has 10 impoverished people and 1000 middle class people, the relevant comparison is the German middle class to the US impoverished class. In other words, you'd want to compare outcomes based on percentiles regardless of socioeconomic status.
- refurb 5y agoFirst off the article says nothing about marriage it speaks of “two parent households”, so an unmarried couple raising kids would fit the author’s thesis entirely. Second, pretty sure I’d argue the recent riots in Sweden would back up exactly the author’s theory around poorly behaved young males. But hey, your nutritional rate is high!
- AvocadoPanic 5y agoOr 'migrants' exhibiting the typical behavior of their homeland. See Vienna 1683.
- selimthegrim 5y agoThe Lipka Tatars would like a word.
- AvocadoPanic 5y agoThey assimilated, and fought against the Turks at the battle of Vienna.
- engineeringwoke 5y ago> Second, pretty sure I’d argue the recent riots in Sweden would back up exactly the author’s theory around poorly behaved young males. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- rendall 5y agoThe article repeatedly talks about marriage. From the article, a quote: even those who cohabit, believe that as long as they are not married, it is acceptable for either partner to walk away at any time, and for virtually any reason.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoI think missing from this comparison is that while the US is quite different from Finland, New Hampshire when taken on its own is quite similar. But we never ask, “how could we make the whole US like New Hampshire?” and probably for good reason! I don’t think we’d want the whole US to be that way. The US is big and diverse and that’s a good thing.
- hotpotamus 5y agoI like the diversity of accents and cuisine, but the difference in maternal mortality not so much.
- altairprime 5y agoUS diversity is not uniformly a good thing. It may be a good thing when it comes to positive examples of successful communities, but breakdowns in education, low income support, and wilderness management systems are apparent in all of our states and territories. The US should absolutely be adopting competent successful approaches from its union members at the federal level, even if it makes us all a little less distinctive and a little more New Hampshire.
- eastbound 5y agoBeing expert in male/female statistics, the EU is generally only 4% far from USA gender statistics, and closing in on a 10-year delay. The only difference between USA and EU is that it is exaggerated in the media, while the trends which happen in EU have already been experienced in USA so people have already had time to get used to it, therefore news are less sensationalist. In other words, your impression that EU culture, statistics or law are different from USA is not verifiable in measurements. I agree however, that we think we are immune to USA problems when we live in EU.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt still seems like a moment of temporary stability though, especially as their social structure starts to stress from the old:worker ratio going from >5 to <2. I.e. unless they accept 30% immigration over the next 50 years, the system will be extremely stressed and may fracture.
- gumby 5y ago> unless they accept 30% immigration over the next 50 years, the system will be extremely stressed and may fracture. There’s no reason to expect that not to happen. Countries like Germany already been have a higher immigration rate than the US, and once had a much higher rate when they needed workers post war. European political decision making is primarily bullshit muddle and and absurd “compromise” yet in the end is surprisingly pragmatic. Unfortunately for the US it’s become high conflict rather than vapid muddle, which makes it harder for people to move their positions.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAbout 19% of the US is immigrant compared to like 17% in Germany, so they are fairly similar. Can they bring the rest of Europe along though? It’s a huge challenge…
- gumby 5y agoAccording to the UN, in 2019 Germany had 15.7% foreign born and USA 15.4%. And the AfD notwithstanding, Germany has the pragmatic Gastarbeiter precedent. The larger precedent, for all cultures, is that idealistic views (immigrants good! Immigrants bad!) fade dramatically and rapidly when pragmatic issues emerge.
- DeathArrow 5y agoSuicide rate in Norway is 11.8,while in Greece (a more traditional society) is 3.6. By metric of happiness and self fulfillment, it seems Greece is much better than Norway.
- wickedsickeune 5y agoWhy are suicides a metric of happiness?
- Veelox 5y agoSuicides are an informal measure of how unhappiness. The thinking is that if people reach a certain level of unhappiness they opt out of life. The implication is that there is a lot less unhappiness in Greece.