4 ms·
The article's title seems very misleading. Even a magically zero-weight airliner hydrogen tank will be physically huge. Just compare cross-section diagrams fo
by bell-cot 5y ago
The article's title seems very misleading.
Even a magically zero-weight airliner hydrogen tank will be physically huge. Just compare cross-section diagrams for rockets running kerosene/oxygen engines with rockets running hydrogen/oxygen engines. (Use the oxygen tank sizes as your reference standard.) Now recall that jet fuel is basically kerosene, most of which is stored in tanks in the wings - where cylindrical liquid hydrogen tanks would be a poor fit. Huge cylinders added to an aircraft will also add huge drag, or eat up much of your passenger/cargo space.
EDIT - OOPS, I didn't spot the article's emphasis on cryogenic (liquid, at 20 K, −253 °C or −423 °F) hydrogen. Ask a rocket scientist how safe, easy, and cheap that stuff is to handle. Current rockets mostly use kerosene instead, in spite of kerosene's far-worse efficiency in $millions-per-launch rocket engines, to avoid dealing with liquid hydrogen.
- audunw 5y agoYeah, as always, they forget to mention volumetric energy density. Big red flag. There's some concepts that may work around that, like a blended-wing design. Airbus seems to think it's viable. https://www.airbus.com/en/innovation/zero-emission/hydrogen/zeroe https://www.airbus.com/en/innovation/zero-emission/hydrogen/... Also, a hydrogen fuel cell based plane could be designed to fly much more efficiently than a regular turbofan plane. For instance, something like the Maxwell X-57 where you have very thin, low-drag wings, and use small electric propellers to provide the extra lift needed during take-off and landing. Electric propulsion enables new designs that wasn't possible with turbofans, and I'm sure electric planes will end up looking quite different from todays planes. But it'll take a couple of decades to figure it out.
- bell-cot 5y agoFrom some quick searches, it sounds like modern jet engines are up to ~40% energy efficient, measuring kerosene ==> thrust. I'll guess that production-aircraft-grade hydrogen fuel cells won't get past 85% efficient (hydrogen ==> electricity). Then you have the inefficiencies of the electric motor, and the propeller. Maybe 60% total efficiency could be achieved? (So 1.5x the current-generation commercial jet engine efficiency.) My point: Your "much more efficient" looks correct, as language to use among informed engineers. But risky to use around managers, customers, etc. - who'll quickly develop fantasies of around-the-world jumbo jet flights, powered by the hydrogen tank in their carry-on duffel bag.
- xoa 5y agoI don't agree. Yeah there are definitely a multitude of factors at play. But overall electric is definitely more efficient, reliable, and opens up a range of new designs. That's a very important part of the picture in general because it's part of why electric aircraft may start becoming viable earlier than would be indicated by the abysmal energy density of storage. Electric motors can be extremely efficient at their optimal load [0], that's not really a limiting factor. They're also much simpler and more reliable with excellent performance per volume themselves. But one of the biggest advantages GP was getting at is plumbing. Moving fuel around an aircraft is non-trivial and heavy. It's just not feasible to slap a dozen engines of various sizes on each wing. Running a power line to an electric motor is a lot more doable to put it mildly. That has massive implications for aircraft design and opens up a lot of further more efficient wing designs for example. Long haul aircraft will definitely be last if ever (it's perfectly possible to make green synthetic hydrocarbon fuel directly from atmospheric CO2 which in turn is carbon neutral, for niche applications where it's worth it we can move from fossil fuels without moving from hydrocarbons). For short/medium haul though the volumetric energy density of hydrocarbons doesn't necessarily need to be remotely matched. Although all that said, I don't think hydrogen is going to play a role there long term anymore than I think it will anywhere else. Batteries have the ceiling and have too many network effects at this point, and syngas is close to as green as hydrogen (more non-global warming pollutants in use) while being what we're already use to working with. Only place I really see hydrogen having a niche is space, but even there it's not clear the ISP advantages will ultimately be worth it vs the vastly easier to store/refuel methane. ---- 0: https://new.abb.com/news/detail/1789/ABB-motor-sets-world-record-in-energy-efficiency-saves-half-a-million-dollars https://new.abb.com/news/detail/1789/ABB-motor-sets-world-re...
- krisoft 5y ago> I'll guess that production-aircraft-grade hydrogen fuel cells won't get past 85% efficient (hydrogen ==> electricity). Why would you convert the hydrogen to electricity instead of burning it in the jet engine?
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoBurning it in our nitrogen- rich atmosphere creates NOx which is bad
- torginus 5y agoI remember doing some back of the envelope calculations, and hydrogen fuel cells offer somewhat better volumetric energy density than current batteries do - and it's no contest with regards to weight. I'm not super familiar with cargo aviation, so I'm not sure how often are aircraft weight limited, as opposed to volume limited. In the former case, the low density of hydrogen would probably be less of an issue.
- Veedrac 5y ago> Current rockets mostly use kerosene instead, in spite of kerosene's far-worse efficiency in $millions-per-launch rocket engines, to avoid dealing with liquid hydrogen. Kerosene is used because it's better, moreso than the difficulty of handling. Kerosene is basically ideal for the first stage, and is a great second stage choice if you aren't going to very high energy orbits. Hydrogen's economics are mostly terrible.
- namlem 5y agoKerosene is pretty good, but these days it seems like methane is all the rage.
- Veedrac 5y agoThat's because of reuse, as kerosene burns slightly sooty, which can be cleaned but takes maintainance, whereas methane burns clean. You wouldn't use methane for a single use engine unless you were buying off the shelf like Vulcan IMO, since its harder to use and doesn't perform better.