3 ms·
The Programmable GPU Core (2011) [pdf]
- skavi 5y agoThis is a great set of slides. Love how they built up to a modern-ish design.
- yonixw 5y agoIt might be an outdated note, but when I tried the same approach in 2015, I was limited not only by the GPU but also by the OpenGL version on the Linux I used. You had to enable some "extensions" in order to read back raw pixel data/buffers back from the GPU. Hope people have it easier these days.
- kevingadd 5y agoPart of the reason for this is that the "raw" buffers you're reading back are not actually raw buffers. If you have raw access to the hardware (for example, using the graphics APIs on a game console) it turns out that they are typically using custom compressed representations and if you just want a buffer with pixels in it, the real buffer has to be decompressed, either in-place or into a temporary buffer. So when you are using that extension to read back raw data, what you're actually doing is kicking off a conversion operation on the GPU, then waiting and reading the contents of the buffer via DMA.
- einpoklum 5y agoAn excellent slide-set for the uninitiated - although if the first several slides assume a 3D graphics processing background. I especially like the perspective-switch from SIMD to NVIDIA/AMD-speak regarding threads and warps/wavefronts.
- gmueckl 5y agoThe slides mention that the SGI RealityEngine had a programmable geometry engine. That geometry engine board alone held multiple (six or so?) Intel i860XP processors. Now I'm curious how much that whole thing must have cost new. The amount of hardware SGI threw at accelerated raster graphics was massive.
- brianpaul 5y agoI have an SGI price sheet from July 1993. A 4xR4400/150Mhz, 64MB Onyx RealityEngine2 went for $199,999. Adding 64MB RAM cost another $11,000. The GE board had 12 i860 processors. The big rack-based system w/ 24 CPUs was $634,900. And people complain about the prices of GPUs nowadays...
- gsempe 5y agoI think internet deserves a scan of this price sheet. It would be amazing to see it
- rjsw 5y agoThe slides could have mentioned the TMS34010 [1] as well as the SGI RealityEngine. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TMS34010 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TMS34010
- gmueckl 5y agoNo, I don't think so. The TMS34010 is nothing like the 3D accelerators that these slides are about. The TI chip is a 2D graphics accelerator at heart, like a lot of the graphics hardware of the 80s. The SGI RealityEngine is noteworthy because it is an early hardware implementation of a 3D rasterization pipeline. The individual hardware boards of that system correspond almost exactly to the conceptual boxes you see in an introduction to the 3D rasterization pipeline.
- p_l 5y agoConsidering that libGL, and thus OpenGL, grew out of the SGI RealityEngine pipeline, that's not surprising at all
- sylware 5y agoPPL have to keep in mind that GPUs are all about extreme 3D performance, namely pushing the silicon really hard, then ASIC is probably the only reasonable way.
- samhw 5y agoA GPU is an ASIC designed exactly for that. I'm not quite sure what you're suggesting?