2 ms·
> But such checks are inherently less thorough than instead having another group replicate the results, in a separate environment, just working from the publish
by jacques_chester 15y ago
> But such checks are inherently less thorough than instead having another group replicate the results, in a separate environment, just working from the published paper details.
Not so. Research into "N-version programming" shows that independent implementations tend to have bugs clustered in the same subsystems.
Besides, if scientists can invent a way to reliably communicate requirements in a 12-page paper in Nature then I have a requirements document in Brooklyn I'd like to sell them.