4 ms·
There isn't surplus water in the Mississippi or its tributaries. This is an illusion caused by seeing the river and not understanding the way it works and the e
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
There isn't surplus water in the Mississippi or its tributaries. This is an illusion caused by seeing the river and not understanding the way it works and the ecosystems around it.
Piping water long distances isn't particularly hard, true. But ... piping water uphill consumes extraordinary amounts of energy. Where I live in NM (between 6000 and 7000'), it seems to me exceedingly unlikely that we'd ever see water pumped from within a few hundred feet of sea level up here.
- Retric 5y ago> There isn’t surplus water in the Mississippi Thus “pump water from the east coast into a tributary of the Mississippi” The way these kind of projects work is to divert water at the border between multiple catchment basins. You might need to pump water up a minimal distance or even simply cut a channel at one end which lets you extract the same amount of water without negativity impacting anyones water rights. As to pumping water up, users downstream of the Mississippi don’t care where their water comes from as long as they can get it. Thus you can now move water upstream on the western edge of the Mississippi to Nevada because that’s been offset but adding water to the eastern edge of the Mississippi catchment basin. Of course the more water you want to move to Nevada the more complicated this gets. Also, it would be much more convenient to start from the Great Lakes than the east coast but the basic principle works.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI can't pretend to know enough about this to really comment on such a scheme. However, I do read https://www.inkstain.com/jfleck https://www.inkstain.com/jfleck and view him as an authority on southwestern water. He appears to me to be very skeptical that long distance pipelines make sense and/or are possible given the requirements at each end.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ttyprintk 5y agoFixed link is http://www.inkstain.net/fleck/ http://www.inkstain.net/fleck/
- no-s 5y ago> The way these kind of projects work is to divert water at the border between multiple catchment basins. Interestingly Colorado river water is diverted to the east side of the continental divide this way, e.g. for Denver water supply (and others). Which ultimately deprives Los Angeles, which is also diverting water from the Colorado river in much the same way. Actually to be fair it’s ultimately depriving the Mexicans of a Colorado river....