5 ms·
I get the feeling that the bean counters are taking over Google and slashing off everything that doesn't have obvious monetization potential. I mean, I know gr
by zdw 15y ago
I get the feeling that the bean counters are taking over Google and slashing off everything that doesn't have obvious monetization potential.
I mean, I know great people who work there, but overall it seems like they're turning into Microsoft circa 2000 - they own the industry, they buy startups and kill the products made by about half of them. Some of their products are great, but a lot of it is just an obvious monopoly enabled money grab.
I wish this wasn't the case.
- kennystone 15y agoYou would never seen something like "Labs" from Apple, and everyone applauds them for "focus".
- rdouble 15y agoApple did have "labs." One of the first thing Steve Jobs did when he returned was shut it down. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Technology_Group http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Technology_Group
- viscanti 15y agoThat explanation misses a lot of context. It comes across as a criticism, as if Jobs just didn't see the benefit of research. That's not the case. He wanted to shrink the things they focused on, so they could put their 'A' team on every project (which required less projects). The end result was having a bunch of really talented guys focusing on things that drove business value.
- rdouble 15y agoI didn't intend it to be a criticism, just a factual remark. Then again, I shouldn't have really compared the two. Google labs wasn't really a dedicated research wing at Google, more like cool stuff people from various teams worked on in their spare time.
- msbarnett 15y agoOf course, Apple shut the ATG down in the context of the company bleeding money and having maybe 90 days of life in it at then-current spending levels. The optics in this case are somewhat different.
- zdw 15y agoAnyone who has been to WWDC and seen their engineering staff present will know that they're given a bit of leeway in the design of the products they work on. Real artists ship - the expansion and creation of new API's in their software shows this. Just because they can't work on whatever with 20% of their time doesn't mean it's a no-creativity nose to the grindstone environment.
- georgemcbay 15y agoI'm about as much of a Google fanboy as you can be and unfortunately zdw's words ring true. Also, in spite of Apple's success I'm not sure Google would do well to emulate them. I (and I would guess many others) have loved Google because they aren't Apple, though unfortunately they do seem to be inching that way at an increasing rate.
- mkr-hn 15y agoAre you talking about their recent UX trend of turning everything into a minimalist interface with a lot of whitespace?
- georgemcbay 15y agoNo, I was talking more about their business side -- killing off everything that isn't a direct profit center and moves towards unopenness (no Honeycomb source code, etc). In regards to UI, I wouldn't mind if they copied Apple more there but only if they copied the good (great defaults) without copying the bad (no ability for power users to modify the defaults).
- _frog 15y agoApple certainly does a lot of experimentation, but their approach differs greatly from Google's. The main reasoning behind Google Labs as far as I can determine is to expose projects to the broader world and determine which are best through some form of natural selection. A form of market research if you will. Apple on the other hand has been very much against market research, preferring to experiment internally, killing of bad ideas before the world even hears about them and presenting a polished final product to the outside world when it's done and ready. Both approaches certainly work, Google's works great for improving their existing suite of products whereas Apple's works better for incubating new products that consumers don't even realise they want yet.
- shareme 15y agoApple has never been against market research, its only done internally with internal employees as the volunteers under NDA so we never see those workings..
- dingle_thunk 15y agoHardware requires focus. Software requires experimentation.
- dpe82 15y agoSteve Jobs said it himself several times: Apple is, at it's core, a software company. It just puts it in a really pretty box.
- asto 15y agoYeah, I always thought Labs was a part of Google's identity. What next, no doodles because it's a waste of time? :-(
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pajju 15y agoDoodles won't. Doodles have become a strong reason for Google search to be used in their homepage. ("Locking in a category of users"). Btw, Orkut may be the next.
- cracell 15y agoRunning Orkut and Google Plus doesn't really make sense unless Orkut still has a large South American userbase that would be hard to transfer over (not sure if that is the case still).
- 2muchcoffeeman 15y agoDoodles is a successful bit of marketing though. Everyone knows what it is and maybe even look forward to them on special occasions. What did Labs do successfully?
- smoyer 15y agoYes ... it's a sad day. And a further indication of how little big-G's management cares about engineering is how poorly they made this change. As of 1200 EST on 10/15, Labs is still available on the "even more >>" page (http://www.google.com/intl/en/about/products/index.html http://www.google.com/intl/en/about/products/index.html).
- wizzard 15y agoI feel like they almost get bored with projects and then just let them stagnate. It seems like once they launch something, that is pretty much the final state of that project. I am not sad to see them narrowing their focus a bit if it means they'll continue to improve on and advance their current offerings instead of launching a new initiative every week. However, the way that they can just toss projects aside like this makes me wonder once again why I should bother becoming invested in Google Plus... how long will it be before I get an email telling me Plus is being shut down and I should go download all my content?