4 ms·
Is it south of some reference point (here in Maryland it looks like I’m south of Turkey and around the same as Beijing). Is Australia excluded? Or is it just a
by rayiner 5y ago
Is it south of some reference point (here in Maryland it looks like I’m south of Turkey and around the same as Beijing). Is Australia excluded? Or is it just a euphemism for developing nation.
- tptacek 5y agoI don't know, I just Googled it. I've definitely heard the term before, though.
- ggpsv 5y agoThere is not as it does not refer to a geographical designation. I wouldn't say it is a euphemism, but closer to what people actually refer to when they misuse the term "third-world". The closest geographical designation was the Brandt line drawn in the 80s showing a north and south divide in terms of global wealth distribution [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South#/media/File:The_Brandt_Line.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South#...
- rayiner 5y agoThird world is inaccurate, but what’s wrong with “developing world.” Also: did I call it about China and Australia or did I call it?
- ggpsv 5y agoLike I mentioned in my top-most comment, "developing nation" is what people typically refer to. As to your comment, I was pointing out that "global south" is not a euphemism for "developing nation". I'd say it is the other way around and in a misguided way. This is because the global south/north designation intentionally distances itself from terminology such as "developing nation". I understand if this comes across as pedantry but the global north and south terminology does a better job at leveling the playing field when talking about wealth and progress disparities. As per your other question, Australia is part of the global north, China is part of the global south in the global north and south groupings.
- Talanes 5y ago>I understand if this comes across as pedantry but the global north and south terminology does a better job at leveling the playing field when talking about wealth and progress disparities. I mean... but how? It's just the exact same concepts with less intuitively obvious words. Arguably it frames the disparity as a more immutable part of a nation; it doesn't fit normal language patterns to talk about a country moving north/south.
- rayiner 5y ago> I understand if this comes across as pedantry but the global north and south terminology does a better job at leveling the playing field when talking about wealth and progress disparities. How? South Korea, Japan, and Singapore are richer than France or Spain now. As nations develop the geographic terminology makes less and less sense. Developing nation is much more accurate.
- throwaway290 5y agoDeveloping vs. developed country is always relative, and the term and the implied benchmark is set by developed countries. In other words, effectively developed = what we are, developing = trying to be what we are. It also places unnecessary upper bound on progress (if you call yourself developed, I guess you can stop developing then?). Ultimately it is forcing a finite game onto the world. Global south sounds like a better term.
- rayiner 5y ago> In other words, effectively developed = what we are, developing = trying to be what we are. That’s the plan, yes. > Ultimately it is forcing a finite game onto the world. Global south sounds like a better term. Except that it’s geographically inaccurate as well as kind of racist. Japan, Singapore, and Korea can get richer than France or Spain, but they still get lumped in with the other non-white people in “the global south.”
- throwaway290 5y ago